| 1. | Matthew DohertyPlace 1. · Grade 9 · Mamaroneck | 9 | Mamaroneck | 2:50.90 |
| 2. | Kyle PhillipsPlace 2. · Grade 9 · Briarcliff | 9 | Briarcliff | 2:52.00 |
| 3. | Ben TaffetPlace 3. · Grade 10 · Rye Neck | 10 | Rye Neck | 2:52.50 |
| 4. | Luke BriodyPlace 4. · Grade 11 · Byram Hills | 11 | Byram Hills | 2:52.90 |
| 5. | Max GoodmanPlace 5. · Grade 10 · John Jay (Cross River) | 10 | John Jay (Cross River) | 2:53.50 |
| 6. | Cole FredericksPlace 6. · Grade 12 · Albertus Magnus | 12 | Albertus Magnus | 2:53.70 |
| 7. | Giovanni CulottaPlace 7. · Grade 10 · Briarcliff | 10 | Briarcliff | 2:54.70 |
| 8. | Chance FiorisiPlace 8. · Grade 11 · Pawling | 11 | Pawling | 2:56.05 |
| 9. | Sam OrientalePlace 9. · Grade 12 · Briarcliff | 12 | Briarcliff | 2:57.80 |
| 10. | John McMillenPlace 10. · Grade 12 · Mamaroneck | 12 | Mamaroneck | 2:59.60 |
| 11. | Walter HoessPlace 11. · Grade 11 · Haldane | 11 | Haldane | 3:00.40 |
| 12. | Matthew FredericksPlace 12. · Grade 12 · Albertus Magnus | 12 | Albertus Magnus | 3:00.60 |
| 13. | Antoine Van HorenPlace 13. · Grade 12 · Horace Greeley | 12 | Horace Greeley | 3:01.70 |
| 14. | Nik SpringerPlace 14. · Grade 11 · Sleepy Hollow | 11 | Sleepy Hollow | 3:02.20 |
| 15. | Jeremy DamonPlace 15. · Grade 12 · Horace Greeley | 12 | Horace Greeley | 3:03.50 |
| 16. | Alexander HerzigPlace 16. · Grade 12 · Mamaroneck | 12 | Mamaroneck | 3:05.80 |
| 17. | Max CohenPlace 17. · Grade 12 · Byram Hills | 12 | Byram Hills | 3:06.50 |
| 18. | Coby RinkePlace 18. · Grade 9 · Briarcliff | 9 | Briarcliff | 3:06.90 PR |
| 19. | Ishan RoyPlace 19. · Grade 11 · Horace Greeley | 11 | Horace Greeley | 3:07.60 |
| 20. | Peter GresslerPlace 20. · Grade 11 · John Jay (Cross River) | 11 | John Jay (Cross River) | 3:09.30 |
| 21. | Jake GreenbergPlace 21. · Grade 9 · North Salem | 9 | North Salem | 3:09.60 |
| 22. | Matt CarnesPlace 22. · Grade 9 · Horace Greeley | 9 | Horace Greeley | 3:09.80 |
| 22. | Wesley BaccayPlace 22. · Grade 11 · Horace Greeley | 11 | Horace Greeley | 3:09.80 PR |
| 24. | Alexander LaqueurPlace 24. · Grade 10 · North Salem | 10 | North Salem | 3:09.90 |
| 25. | Liam TrageserPlace 25. · Grade 10 · North Salem | 10 | North Salem | 3:10.30 |
| 26. | Tyler CelestinPlace 26. · Grade 9 · North Rockland | 9 | North Rockland | 3:11.00 PR |
| 27. | Nicholas GonzalezPlace 27. · Grade 12 · Horace Greeley | 12 | Horace Greeley | 3:12.10 PR |
| 28. | David MagillPlace 28. · Grade 9 · Rye Neck | 9 | Rye Neck | 3:13.40 |
| 29. | Eric SongPlace 29. · Grade 12 · Horace Greeley | 12 | Horace Greeley | 3:13.80 |
| 30. | Luke DennisPlace 30. · Grade 8 · Briarcliff | 8 | Briarcliff | 3:14.80 |
| 31. | Luke McKennaPlace 31. · Grade 10 · Albertus Magnus | 10 | Albertus Magnus | 3:15.40 |
| 32. | Paul CarranoPlace 32. · Grade 12 · North Rockland | 12 | North Rockland | 3:15.90 |
| 33. | Peter SeverinoPlace 33. · Grade 11 · Byram Hills | 11 | Byram Hills | 3:16.50 |
| 34. | Chris SchmidtPlace 34. · Grade 12 · Pawling | 12 | Pawling | 3:17.40 |
| 35. | Sebastian KocklerPlace 35. · Grade 11 · Horace Greeley | 11 | Horace Greeley | 3:17.60 |
| 36. | Kornel SmithPlace 36. · Grade 9 · Briarcliff | 9 | Briarcliff | 3:18.30 |
| 37. | Adam LupatkinPlace 37. · Grade 10 · Horace Greeley | 10 | Horace Greeley | 3:18.70 |
| 38. | Benjamin WangPlace 38. · Grade 10 · Horace Greeley | 10 | Horace Greeley | 3:19.70 |
| 39. | Jack DiMaggioPlace 39. · Grade 9 · Rye Neck | 9 | Rye Neck | 3:21.70 |
| 40. | Justin NgPlace 40. · Grade 10 · Horace Greeley | 10 | Horace Greeley | 3:22.40 |
| 41. | Kyosuke TsunodaPlace 41. · Grade 10 · Rye Neck | 10 | Rye Neck | 3:22.50 |
| 42. | Jacob TalaveraPlace 42. · Grade 11 · Valhalla | 11 | Valhalla | 3:24.70 |
| 43. | James KissanePlace 43. · Grade 10 · Horace Greeley | 10 | Horace Greeley | 3:25.80 PR |
| 44. | Michele IgnomirelloPlace 44. · Grade 12 · Pawling | 12 | Pawling | 3:26.20 |
| 45. | Anthony RusignoPlace 45. · Grade - · Horace Greeley | - | Horace Greeley | 3:26.70 PR |
| 46. | William ArmbrusterPlace 46. · Grade 9 · North Salem | 9 | North Salem | 3:27.30 |
| 47. | Nicholas MarinoPlace 47. · Grade 11 · Valhalla | 11 | Valhalla | 3:30.40 |
| 48. | Jack MangoPlace 48. · Grade 12 · John Jay (Cross River) | 12 | John Jay (Cross River) | 3:31.00 |
| 49. | John GonzalezPlace 49. · Grade 9 · Horace Greeley | 9 | Horace Greeley | 3:32.10 PR |
| 50. | Mason BarlowPlace 50. · Grade 9 · Horace Greeley | 9 | Horace Greeley | 3:32.60 |
| 51. | Jason SingerPlace 51. · Grade 10 · Horace Greeley | 10 | Horace Greeley | 3:32.90 |
| 52. | Reynaldo MendozaPlace 52. · Grade 12 · Pawling | 12 | Pawling | 3:35.10 PR |
| 53. | Jonathan WexlerPlace 53. · Grade 9 · Briarcliff | 9 | Briarcliff | 3:35.30 |
| 54. | Kyle FredericksPlace 54. · Grade 9 · Albertus Magnus | 9 | Albertus Magnus | 3:37.90 PR |
| 55. | Daniel LuanPlace 55. · Grade 9 · Horace Greeley | 9 | Horace Greeley | 3:38.40 PR |
| 56. | David LovejoyPlace 56. · Grade 12 · John Jay (Cross River) | 12 | John Jay (Cross River) | 3:39.20 |
| 57. | Albert GuanPlace 57. · Grade 12 · Briarcliff | 12 | Briarcliff | 3:39.50 |
| 58. | Eytan SebbanePlace 58. · Grade 9 · Rye Neck | 9 | Rye Neck | 3:44.20 |
| 59. | Benjamin McEwenPlace 59. · Grade 11 · Haldane | 11 | Haldane | 3:44.70 |
| 60. | Jackson AndrewPlace 60. · Grade 11 · John Jay (Cross River) | 11 | John Jay (Cross River) | 3:45.10 |
| 61. | Jonathon KrajeskiPlace 61. · Grade 10 · Pawling | 10 | Pawling | 3:45.20 |
| 62. | Alexander SouthernPlace 62. · Grade 9 · Briarcliff | 9 | Briarcliff | 3:46.10 |
| 63. | Mikiel ScarlettPlace 63. · Grade 8 · Spring Valley | 8 | Spring Valley | 3:46.50 PR |
| 64. | Kevin MuckerPlace 64. · Grade 9 · Byram Hills | 9 | Byram Hills | 3:46.90 PR |
| 65. | Matt PerucciPlace 65. · Grade 11 · Pawling | 11 | Pawling | 3:47.10 |
| 66. | Matthias LauvauPlace 66. · Grade 9 · Rye Neck | 9 | Rye Neck | 3:50.10 |
| 67. | Ben ChapmanPlace 67. · Grade 9 · Byram Hills | 9 | Byram Hills | 3:54.40 |
| 68. | Evan MasciaPlace 68. · Grade 9 · Pawling | 9 | Pawling | 3:54.60 |
| 69. | Dante CosciaPlace 69. · Grade 9 · Albertus Magnus | 9 | Albertus Magnus | 3:54.90 |
| 70. | Gabriel LohrfinkPlace 70. · Grade 10 · Pawling | 10 | Pawling | 4:02.60 |
| 71. | Will QuinnPlace 71. · Grade 10 · Byram Hills | 10 | Byram Hills | 4:02.80 |
| 72. | Kyle BeamePlace 72. · Grade 10 · John Jay (Cross River) | 10 | John Jay (Cross River) | 4:04.30 |
| 73. | Ryan BaioPlace 73. · Grade 9 · Rye Neck | 9 | Rye Neck | 4:06.50 |