| 1 | Will SoulePlace 1 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:17.70 |
| 2 | Miles PhillipsPlace 2 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:19.90 |
| 3 | Jacob ScottPlace 3 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:21.88 |
| 4 | Andrew BurrellPlace 4 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 4:25.23 |
| 5 | Mickey SchihlPlace 5 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:26.01 |
| 6 | Stephen FernettiPlace 6 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:27.01 |
| 7 | Walter SellersPlace 7 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 4:32.50 |
| 8 | Lucas PlittPlace 8 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:34.07 |
| 9 | Gage AustinPlace 9 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:34.53 |
| 10 | William WalshPlace 10 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:35.02 |
| 11 | Douglas GledhillPlace 11 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:35.50 |
| 12 | Jared CampbellPlace 12 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:35.75 |
| 13 | Luke ArmentroutPlace 13 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:36.46 |
| 14 | Connor BagwellPlace 14 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:36.58 |
| 15 | Jeremy KernPlace 15 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:41.16 |
| 16 | Jonah MussomeliPlace 16 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:42.16 |
| 17 | Peter SchihlPlace 17 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:43.57 |
| 18 | Conner InmanPlace 18 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:44.51 |
| 19 | Will DownsPlace 19 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 4:44.58 |
| 20 | Charlie SchihlPlace 20 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:46.83 |
| 21 | Henry LenhamPlace 21 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:47.81 |
| 22 | Noah CarterPlace 22 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:48.78 |
| 23 | Ethan DavisPlace 23 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:48.84 |
| 24 | Fletcher WachtelPlace 24 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:50.82 |
| 25 | Benjamin Mills-TarmeyPlace 25 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:50.91 |
| 26 | Mack ViverettePlace 26 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 4:52.11 |
| 27 | Timothy SaliccoPlace 27 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:52.29 |
| 28 | Jackson LackeyPlace 28 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 4:53.39 |
| 29 | Tyler StricklandPlace 29 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:56.20 |
| 30 | Sean O'DeaPlace 30 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:56.89 |
| 31 | Alex KernPlace 31 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 4:58.83 |
| 32 | Ross BridgforthPlace 32 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:59.17 |
| 33 | Ethan HallPlace 33 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 4:59.26 |
| 34 | Justin BevacquaPlace 34 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 4:59.71 |
| 35 | Carter BorgeltPlace 35 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:00.60 |
| 36 | Zachary PatrickPlace 36 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 5:02.85 |
| 37 | Ciaran BurrPlace 37 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:07.12 |
| 38 | Mirko GlavanPlace 38 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 5:07.39 |
| 39 | Matthew CushingPlace 39 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:13.03 |
| 40 | Ryan MalinowskiPlace 40 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:16.01 |
| 41 | Beau BennettPlace 41 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 5:16.14 |
| 42 | Payton BorstPlace 42 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:16.41 |
| 43 | Blake BorstPlace 43 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:16.90 |
| 44 | Clayton SarnoPlace 44 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:17.98 |
| 45 | Lucus O'NealPlace 45 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 5:18.16 |
| 46 | Jacob Serrano-MelgarPlace 46 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 5:20.29 |
| 47 | Vincent VockePlace 47 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:27.93 |
| 48 | Quetzal KuppingerPlace 48 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 5:29.10 |
| 49 | Zeeshawn HasnainPlace 49 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 5:29.56 |
| 50 | Federico SmithPlace 50 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:30.00 |
| 51 | Victor MontalvoPlace 51 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:36.73 |
| 52 | Dillon HardenPlace 52 · Mount Tabor | — | Mount Tabor | 5:41.63 |
| 53 | Parker RansonPlace 53 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 5:42.95 |
| 54 | Michael PavelPlace 54 · North Lincol | — | North Lincol | 5:43.41 |
| 55 | Ryan MillerPlace 55 · Cuthbertson | — | Cuthbertson | 5:47.36 |
| 56 | Neil SoodPlace 56 · Atkins | — | Atkins | 5:54.14 |
| — | Mason Rudel · Atkins | — | Atkins | DNF |