| 1. | Jessica AlessiPlace 1. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 3:17.53a |
| 2. | Ashley WongPlace 2. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 3:23.25a |
| 3. | Isabella BalounPlace 3. · Grade 10 · H Frank Carey | 10 | H Frank Carey | 3:23.75a |
| 4. | Julie SunPlace 4. · Grade 12 · Great Neck North | 12 | Great Neck North | 3:24.81a |
| 5. | Lana JewettPlace 5. · Grade 10 · South Side (Rockville Centre) | 10 | South Side (Rockville Centre) | 3:26.87a |
| 6. | Kate MarcinoPlace 6. · Grade 12 · H Frank Carey | 12 | H Frank Carey | 3:28.17a |
| 7. | Natalie CampisiPlace 7. · Grade 11 · H Frank Carey | 11 | H Frank Carey | 3:30.50a |
| 8. | Abby TedescoPlace 8. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 3:31.06a |
| 9. | Jennifer RollerPlace 9. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 3:33.38a |
| 10. | Catalina SuauPlace 10. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 3:35.30a |
| 11. | Emma SitterlyPlace 11. · Grade 11 · South Side (Rockville Centre) | 11 | South Side (Rockville Centre) | 3:38.11a |
| 12. | Jessica YuenPlace 12. · Grade 10 · Floral Park Memorial | 10 | Floral Park Memorial | 3:38.19a PR |
| 13. | Jocelyn SchadlerPlace 13. · Grade 9 · Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 9 | Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 3:38.30a |
| 14. | Olivia ScalerePlace 14. · Grade 12 · South Side (Rockville Centre) | 12 | South Side (Rockville Centre) | 3:39.17a PR |
| 15. | Mia GagliardiPlace 15. · Grade 12 · Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 12 | Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 3:40.07a |
| 16. | Morgan McKennaPlace 16. · Grade 11 · South Side (Rockville Centre) | 11 | South Side (Rockville Centre) | 3:40.30a PR |
| 17. | Katherine EscherPlace 17. · Grade 11 · Garden City | 11 | Garden City | 3:41.55a |
| 18. | Kate PogozelskiPlace 18. · Grade 11 · Garden City | 11 | Garden City | 3:42.08a |
| 19. | Sara HutzelPlace 19. · Grade 10 · Island Trees | 10 | Island Trees | 3:44.43a |
| 20. | Catherine ChangPlace 20. · Grade 11 · Great Neck North | 11 | Great Neck North | 3:44.86a |
| 21. | Amanda LavianPlace 21. · Grade 12 · Great Neck North | 12 | Great Neck North | 3:45.10a |
| 22. | Tal GavrielPlace 22. · Grade 11 · Great Neck North | 11 | Great Neck North | 3:46.05a |
| 23. | Julia NapolitanoPlace 23. · Grade 12 · South Side (Rockville Centre) | 12 | South Side (Rockville Centre) | 3:48.88a PR |
| 24. | Sofia ShakhamPlace 24. · Grade 11 · South Side (Rockville Centre) | 11 | South Side (Rockville Centre) | 3:48.96a PR |
| 25. | Julia OhPlace 25. · Grade 12 · Great Neck South | 12 | Great Neck South | 3:51.11a PR |
| 26. | Emily SangPlace 26. · Grade 10 · Great Neck South | 10 | Great Neck South | 3:52.13a |
| 27. | Janis ChenPlace 27. · Grade 9 · Syosset | 9 | Syosset | 3:54.94a PR |
| 28. | Roisin PfaffPlace 28. · Grade 10 · Garden City | 10 | Garden City | 3:56.93a |
| 29. | Bridget MacchioPlace 29. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 3:59.15a |
| 30. | Giovana ErcolinoPlace 30. · Grade 11 · Syosset | 11 | Syosset | 3:59.84a PR |
| 31. | Leeam LupoPlace 31. · Grade 9 · Syosset | 9 | Syosset | 3:59.88a |
| 32. | Skylar SilvermanPlace 32. · Grade 11 · Syosset | 11 | Syosset | 4:03.28a |
| 33. | Lily AdzhiashviliPlace 33. · Grade 10 · Great Neck North | 10 | Great Neck North | 4:04.62a |
| 34. | Caroline OhPlace 34. · Grade 11 · Island Trees | 11 | Island Trees | 4:05.15a PR |
| 35. | Angelica RobertsonPlace 35. · Grade 11 · Baldwin | 11 | Baldwin | 4:19.04a PR |