| 1 | Ian KellyPlace 1 · Luther | — | Luther | 3:47.68a |
| 2 | Max HartkePlace 2 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 3:47.91a |
| 3 | Tyler KistingPlace 3 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 3:48.83a |
| 4 | Gabe NicholsPlace 4 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 3:50.53a |
| 5 | Mitchell GrandPlace 5 · St John's (MN) | — | St John's (MN) | 3:54.28a |
| 6 | Lars DewallPlace 6 · St Scholastica | — | St Scholastica | 3:54.54a |
| 7 | Lane SchwarzPlace 7 · Luther | — | Luther | 3:54.99a |
| 8 | Roy LlewellynPlace 8 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 3:56.28a |
| 9 | Matthew RyanPlace 9 · Wisconsin-Stout | — | Wisconsin-Stout | 3:56.48a |
| 10 | Tor OlssonPlace 10 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 3:57.31a |
| 11 | Sean HartneyPlace 11 · St Olaf College | — | St Olaf College | 3:57.63a |
| 12 | Adam KollerPlace 12 · Luther | — | Luther | 3:57.98a |
| 13 | Benjamin GillikinPlace 13 · Luther | — | Luther | 3:58.63a |
| 14 | Ben CrotteauPlace 14 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 3:59.91a |
| 15 | Wyatt TaylorPlace 15 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 3:59.92a |
| 16 | Julian MunozPlace 16 · St Olaf College | — | St Olaf College | 4:00.33a |
| 17 | Eamon CavanaughPlace 17 · St John's (MN) | — | St John's (MN) | 4:00.62a |
| 18 | Jesse PetersonPlace 18 · Wisconsin-Eau Claire | — | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 4:01.20a |
| 19 | Tommy LandtPlace 19 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:01.23a |
| 20 | Reed AndersonPlace 20 · Wisconsin-La Crosse | — | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 4:02.42a |
| 21 | Brady OmtvedtPlace 21 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:03.76a |
| 22 | Mitchell BuerklePlace 22 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:06.28a |
| 23 | Cade HansonPlace 23 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:06.51a |
| 24 | Getinat AsfawPlace 24 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 4:06.82a |
| 25 | Jakin AndersonPlace 25 · Bethany Lutheran | — | Bethany Lutheran | 4:13.48a |
| 26 | Sakariya HussienPlace 26 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 4:14.71a |
| 27 | Bereket WondimuPlace 27 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 4:30.61a |