| 1 | Dustin HUDAKPlace 1 · Grade SO · Trinity Christian | SO | Trinity Christian | 1:54.03 |
| 2 | Spencer CARPENTERPlace 2 · Grade SO · St. Francis (Ind.) | SO | St. Francis (Ind.) | 1:56.82 |
| 3 | Dimitri MARGARITIDISPlace 3 · Grade SR · Grace | SR | Grace | 1:58.15 |
| 4 | Luke SMITHPlace 4 · Grade SR · Grace | SR | Grace | 1:58.92 |
| 5 | Zac MAHERPlace 5 · Grade JR · Trinity Christian | JR | Trinity Christian | 1:59.21 |
| 6 | Bryce NOBLEPlace 6 · Grade FR · Taylor | FR | Taylor | 1:59.51 |
| 7 | Nathan BRAINERPlace 7 · Grade JR · Taylor | JR | Taylor | 1:59.56 |
| 8 | Korry HAMLINPlace 8 · Grade SR · Grace | SR | Grace | 1:59.66 |
| 9 | JR. Maurice MACKLINPlace 9 · Grade SR · Grace | SR | Grace | 1:59.92 |
| 10 | Kennan CLEGGPlace 10 · Grade FR · Taylor | FR | Taylor | 2:00.04 |
| 11 | Bryan HERNANDEZPlace 11 · Grade SR · Grace | SR | Grace | 2:00.58 |
| 12 | Connor JACKSONPlace 12 · Grade SO · St. Francis (Ind.) | SO | St. Francis (Ind.) | 2:01.61 |
| 13 | Pieter HEESTERSPlace 13 · Grade FR · Notre Dame Running Club | FR | Notre Dame Running Club | 2:03.54 |
| 14 | Trenton BROWNPlace 14 · Grade SO · Trinity Christian | SO | Trinity Christian | 2:04.52 |
| 15 | Cade ZOBRISTPlace 15 · Grade FR · Unattached | FR | Unattached | 2:04.59 |
| 16 | Remington CARPENTERPlace 16 · Grade SO · St. Francis (Ind.) | SO | St. Francis (Ind.) | 2:05.01 |
| 17 | Andrew ARDONPlace 17 · Grade FR · Trinity Christian | FR | Trinity Christian | 2:05.36 |
| 18 | James BATESPlace 18 · Grade JR · Taylor | JR | Taylor | 2:05.90 |
| 19 | Andrew DEBLECOURTPlace 19 · Grade SO · Trinity Christian | SO | Trinity Christian | 2:06.25 |
| 20 | Jonathon ROTHPlace 20 · Grade SO · Taylor | SO | Taylor | 2:06.83 |
| 21 | Marston NORRISPlace 21 · Grade JR · Grace | JR | Grace | 2:06.86 |
| 22 | Andrew GOLBAPlace 22 · Grade FR · Bethel (Ind.) | FR | Bethel (Ind.) | 2:07.13 |
| 23 | Kevin LIDDELLPlace 23 · Grade SO · Goshen | SO | Goshen | 2:07.34 |
| 24 | Grayson RASMUSPlace 24 · Grade SO · Taylor | SO | Taylor | 2:07.35 |
| 25 | Aaron YEAKEYPlace 25 · Grade SO · Goshen | SO | Goshen | 2:08.64 |
| 26 | Tiernan BASSPlace 26 · Grade FR · Taylor | FR | Taylor | 2:12.77 |
| 27 | Mateo ARREDONDOPlace 27 · Grade SO · Trinity Christian | SO | Trinity Christian | 2:16.82 |
| 28 | Jesus PORTILLAPlace 28 · Grade FR · Trinity Christian | FR | Trinity Christian | 2:17.33 |
| 29 | Cristian CONTRERASPlace 29 · Grade FR · Trinity Christian | FR | Trinity Christian | 2:17.96 |
| 30 | Devin SCHMENKPlace 30 · Grade SR · St. Francis (Ind.) | SR | St. Francis (Ind.) | 2:19.47 |
| 31 | Cobin MORIARITYPlace 31 · Grade SO · St. Francis (Ind.) | SO | St. Francis (Ind.) | 2:21.07 |
| 32 | Tony REPPMANNPlace 32 · Grade SR · Trinity Christian | SR | Trinity Christian | 2:21.33 |
| 33 | John KENNEDYPlace 33 · Grade SR · Trinity Christian | SR | Trinity Christian | 2:23.21 |
