| 2 | Sil PimentelPlace 2 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 22.40 |
| 3 | Levi ConnerPlace 3 · Grade FR · Spring Arbor | FR | Spring Arbor | 22.57 |
| 4 | Matthew HamerPlace 4 · Grade SO · Marian (Ind.) | SO | Marian (Ind.) | 22.74 |
| 5 | Jadyn CourtneyPlace 5 · Grade FR · Cornerstone | FR | Cornerstone | 22.85 |
| 6 | Ethan FloresPlace 6 · Grade FR · Davenport | FR | Davenport | 22.97 |
| 7 | Ross HunterPlace 7 · Grade SO · Cornerstone | SO | Cornerstone | 22.99 |
| 8 | Satchel HortonPlace 8 · Grade SR · Aquinas | SR | Aquinas | 23.07 |
| 9 | Desmond PattersonPlace 9 · Indiana Tech Developmenta | — | Indiana Tech Developmenta | 23.08 |
| 10 | Spencer StalkerPlace 10 · Grade FR · Bethel (Ind.) | FR | Bethel (Ind.) | 23.14 |
| 11 | Will FauncePlace 11 · Grade FR · Cedarville | FR | Cedarville | 23.15 |
| 12 | Taylor PlattnerPlace 12 · Grade JR · St. Francis (Ind.) | JR | St. Francis (Ind.) | 23.19 |
| 13 | Wesley SimpsonPlace 13 · Grade FR · Bethel (Ind.) | FR | Bethel (Ind.) | 23.21 |
| 14 | Jalen FrazierPlace 14 · Illinois Track Club | — | Illinois Track Club | 23.21 |
| 15 | Avery MalonePlace 15 · Grade FR · St. Francis (Ind.) | FR | St. Francis (Ind.) | 23.23 |
| 16 | Matthew RiehlePlace 16 · Grade FR · Marian (Ind.) | FR | Marian (Ind.) | 23.36 |
| 17 | Josh JonesPlace 17 · Grade FR · Cedarville | FR | Cedarville | 23.39 |
| 18 | Andrew McDadePlace 18 · Grade FR · Marian (Ind.) | FR | Marian (Ind.) | 23.39 |
| 19 | Brandon ThomasPlace 19 · Grade FR · Cedarville | FR | Cedarville | 23.42 |
| 20 | Jackson LincolnPlace 20 · Grade SO · Cornerstone | SO | Cornerstone | 23.75 |
| 21 | Charles Crayton IIPlace 21 · Grade JR · Marian (Ind.) | JR | Marian (Ind.) | 23.78 |
| 22 | Nic NovotnyPlace 22 · Grade SO · Marian (Ind.) | SO | Marian (Ind.) | 23.78 |
| 23 | Elisha FlemmingPlace 23 · Grade FR · Bethel (Ind.) | FR | Bethel (Ind.) | 23.81 |
| 24 | Taylor KnightPlace 24 · Grade FR · Bethel (Ind.) | FR | Bethel (Ind.) | 23.86 |
| 25 | Robert NabulerePlace 25 · Grade FR · Huntington | FR | Huntington | 23.88 |
| 26 | Josh TaylorPlace 26 · Grade JR · Goshen | JR | Goshen | 23.92 |
| 27 | Dylan BikimPlace 27 · Grade SR · Indiana Tech | SR | Indiana Tech | 24.06 |
| 28 | Travis JacobsPlace 28 · Indiana Tech Developmenta | — | Indiana Tech Developmenta | 24.20 |
| 30 | Quantavious BagleyPlace 30 · Grade SO · St. Francis (Ind.) | SO | St. Francis (Ind.) | 24.42 |
| 31 | Nathan RosePlace 31 · Grade SO · Ohio Christian | SO | Ohio Christian | 24.46 |
| 32 | Tyree BizzellePlace 32 · Indiana Tech Developmenta | — | Indiana Tech Developmenta | 24.50 |
| 33 | Justin FosterPlace 33 · Grade FR · Taylor | FR | Taylor | 24.57 |
| 34 | Jackson StoosPlace 34 · Grade JR · St. Ambrose | JR | St. Ambrose | 24.59 |
| 35 | Kyle ForkerPlace 35 · Grade JR · St. Francis (Ind.) | JR | St. Francis (Ind.) | 24.66 |
| 36 | Yussuf AbdullahiPlace 36 · Grade FR · Aquinas | FR | Aquinas | 24.69 |
| 37 | Nick WilfordPlace 37 · Grade SO · Huntington | SO | Huntington | 24.79 |
| 38 | Kristofer GrandisonPlace 38 · Grade SO · Madonna | SO | Madonna | 24.85 |
| 39 | Dezman WhitePlace 39 · Indiana Tech Developmenta | — | Indiana Tech Developmenta | 24.98 |
| 40 | Jack BosworthPlace 40 · Grade FR · St. Francis (Ind.) | FR | St. Francis (Ind.) | 25.00 |
| 41 | Mason RosenbergPlace 41 · Illinois Track Club | — | Illinois Track Club | 25.08 |
| 42 | Jakob MaxwellPlace 42 · Grade SO · Bethel (Ind.) | SO | Bethel (Ind.) | 25.22 |
| 43 | Ben TroyerPlace 43 · Grade JR · Goshen | JR | Goshen | 25.25 |
| 44 | Keith DellPlace 44 · Grade FR · Indiana Kokomo | FR | Indiana Kokomo | 25.30 |
| 45 | Josh WhitneyPlace 45 · Grade FR · Huntington | FR | Huntington | 25.33 |
| 46 | Evan CaldwellPlace 46 · Grade FR · Ohio Christian | FR | Ohio Christian | 25.47 |
| 47 | Darius SheltonPlace 47 · Grade SO · Marian (Ind.) | SO | Marian (Ind.) | 25.55 |
| 48 | Hayden TurnerPlace 48 · Grade SO · Indiana Kokomo | SO | Indiana Kokomo | 25.60 |
| 49 | Elijah NewlandPlace 49 · Grade FR · Ohio Christian | FR | Ohio Christian | 27.46 |