| 1. | Gabriella DeVitoPlace 1. · Grade 12 · Manhasset | 12 | Manhasset | 3:21.05a |
| 2. | Grace MillerPlace 2. · Grade 10 · Bethpage | 10 | Bethpage | 3:22.18a |
| 3. | Sparke DevynPlace 3. · Grade 12 · Bethpage | 12 | Bethpage | 3:22.73a |
| 4. | Isabella BalounPlace 4. · Grade 11 · H Frank Carey | 11 | H Frank Carey | 3:23.05a |
| 5. | Gianna SforzaPlace 5. · Grade 10 · Manhasset | 10 | Manhasset | 3:24.99a |
| 6. | Riley AdamsPlace 6. · Grade 10 · Wantagh | 10 | Wantagh | 3:26.29a PR |
| 7. | Natalie CampisiPlace 7. · Grade 12 · H Frank Carey | 12 | H Frank Carey | 3:26.60a |
| 8. | Erin BurnsPlace 8. · Grade 9 · Wantagh | 9 | Wantagh | 3:27.26a |
| 9. | Madeleine QuinlanPlace 9. · Grade 8 · Manhasset | 8 | Manhasset | 3:28.39a |
| 10. | Ava NeylonPlace 10. · Grade 12 · Manhasset | 12 | Manhasset | 3:29.20a |
| 11. | Anna PaloubisPlace 11. · Grade 9 · Manhasset | 9 | Manhasset | 3:29.34a |
| 12. | Rachel LeePlace 12. · Grade 11 · Jericho | 11 | Jericho | 3:35.28a PR |
| 13. | Carolina CagnaPlace 13. · Grade 9 · Bethpage | 9 | Bethpage | 3:41.10a |
| 14. | Lianna DominguezPlace 14. · Grade 11 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 11 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 3:41.47a |
| 15. | Joy KimPlace 15. · Grade 12 · Bethpage | 12 | Bethpage | 3:44.63a |
| 16. | Stefani GranadosPlace 16. · Grade 11 · Mineola | 11 | Mineola | 3:45.94a PR |
| 17. | Maiytri DubeyPlace 17. · Grade 10 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 10 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 3:49.71a |
| 18. | Ashley AgatepPlace 18. · Grade 10 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 10 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 3:51.28a |
| 19. | Leah ChangPlace 19. · Grade 12 · Mineola | 12 | Mineola | 3:51.38a |
| 20. | Emma SheahanPlace 20. · Grade 8 · Bethpage | 8 | Bethpage | 3:53.18a |
| 21. | Olivia SchererPlace 21. · Grade 10 · Wantagh | 10 | Wantagh | 3:55.56a PR |
| 22. | Winnie LiuPlace 22. · Grade 11 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 11 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 3:56.99a PR |
| 23. | Ruby CacioppoPlace 23. · Grade 10 · Manhasset | 10 | Manhasset | 3:57.67a |
| 24. | Adelina RodriguezPlace 24. · Grade 12 · Westbury | 12 | Westbury | 4:00.78a |
| 25. | Isabella IodicePlace 25. · Grade 11 · Locust Valley | 11 | Locust Valley | 4:06.42a |
| 26. | Lauren PeersPlace 26. · Grade 12 · H Frank Carey | 12 | H Frank Carey | 4:07.24a |
| 27. | Madison BournePlace 27. · Grade 9 · H Frank Carey | 9 | H Frank Carey | 4:08.38a |
| 28. | Daniella CabreraPlace 28. · Grade 10 · Valley Stream North | 10 | Valley Stream North | 4:09.94a |
| 29. | Baoer HuangPlace 29. · Grade 10 · Floral Park Memorial | 10 | Floral Park Memorial | 4:10.71a PR |
| 30. | Karen Orozco-CastroPlace 30. · Grade 10 · West Hempstead | 10 | West Hempstead | 4:15.77a |
| 31. | Isabella CzapPlace 31. · Grade 10 · Floral Park Memorial | 10 | Floral Park Memorial | 4:20.41a PR |
| 32. | Abigail MaselliPlace 32. · Grade 11 · Locust Valley | 11 | Locust Valley | 4:24.63a |
| 33. | Juliana VanordenPlace 33. · Grade 11 · Wantagh | 11 | Wantagh | 4:25.76a |
| 34. | Isabella UberPlace 34. · Grade 12 · Locust Valley | 12 | Locust Valley | 4:25.92a PR |
| 35. | Gianna CassasePlace 35. · Grade 11 · Locust Valley | 11 | Locust Valley | 4:32.94a PR |
| 36. | Sofia ValentinPlace 36. · Grade 10 · H Frank Carey | 10 | H Frank Carey | 4:44.02a |
| 37. | Shivani PillaiPlace 37. · Grade 9 · H Frank Carey | 9 | H Frank Carey | 4:44.70a |
| 38. | Nicole LiuPlace 38. · Grade 10 · Mineola | 10 | Mineola | 4:53.12a |
| 39. | Regan KahnPlace 39. · Grade 12 · Locust Valley | 12 | Locust Valley | 4:56.77a |
| 40. | Niylah EstinvillePlace 40. · Grade 9 · Valley Stream North | 9 | Valley Stream North | 4:59.38a |
| 41. | Kelly LiPlace 41. · Grade 10 · Mineola | 10 | Mineola | 5:11.29a |