| 1 | Ramy AyoubPlace 1 · UNAT-Minnesota | — | UNAT-Minnesota | 1:54.17a |
| 2 | Emmett FaltesekPlace 2 · Concordia-St. Paul | — | Concordia-St. Paul | 1:54.81a |
| 3 | Emmett GerresPlace 3 · UNAT-Minnesota | — | UNAT-Minnesota | 1:55.05a |
| 4 | Tyler SmithPlace 4 · Gustavus Adolphus | — | Gustavus Adolphus | 1:55.55a |
| 5 | Nick BrauerPlace 5 · Gustavus Adolphus | — | Gustavus Adolphus | 1:56.76a |
| 6 | Cullen MoorePlace 6 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 1:57.44a |
| 7 | Getinat AsfawPlace 7 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 1:57.53a |
| 8 | Daniel WiltsePlace 8 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 1:58.63a |
| 9 | Markus RupnowPlace 9 · Gustavus Adolphus | — | Gustavus Adolphus | 1:58.68a |
| 10 | Blake FullerPlace 10 · Gustavus Adolphus | — | Gustavus Adolphus | 1:59.98a |
| 11 | Mark RudPlace 11 · Gustavus Adolphus | — | Gustavus Adolphus | 2:00.15a |
| 12 | Max McCoyPlace 12 · Saint John's (Minn.) | — | Saint John's (Minn.) | 2:00.96a |
| 13 | Thomas MalechaPlace 13 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 2:02.06a |
| 14 | Henry SchonebaumPlace 14 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 2:02.23a |
| 15 | Shareef OtyPlace 15 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 2:03.35a |
| 16 | Aidan MackiePlace 16 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 2:03.52a |
| 17 | Bereket WondimuPlace 17 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 2:04.06a |
| 18 | Jake WielgosPlace 18 · Gustavus Adolphus | — | Gustavus Adolphus | 2:04.26a |
| 19 | Jay LebakkenPlace 19 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 2:04.76a |
| 20 | Zach SudaPlace 20 · University of Minnesota | — | University of Minnesota | 2:05.75a |
| 21 | Lars MolenkampPlace 21 · Saint John's (Minn.) | — | Saint John's (Minn.) | 2:06.97a |
| 22 | Logan AroPlace 22 · University of Minnesota | — | University of Minnesota | 2:06.99a |
| 23 | Matthew LeePlace 23 · University of Minnesota | — | University of Minnesota | 2:09.08a |
| 24 | Saif AzmiPlace 24 · University of Minnesota | — | University of Minnesota | 2:09.78a |
| 25 | Logan LongworthPlace 25 · University of Minnesota | — | University of Minnesota | 2:10.26a |
| 26 | Nate EikomPlace 26 · Northwestern-St. Paul | — | Northwestern-St. Paul | 2:10.79a |
| 27 | Camden CilekPlace 27 · Gustavus Adolphus | — | Gustavus Adolphus | 2:11.70a |
| 28 | Matthew HolstadPlace 28 · North Central (Minn.) | — | North Central (Minn.) | 2:14.29a |
| 29 | Sam KordingPlace 29 · University of Minnesota | — | University of Minnesota | 2:14.39a |
| 30 | Michael Herr-ZielkePlace 30 · North Central (Minn.) | — | North Central (Minn.) | 2:16.63a |
| 31 | Hans ChristophersonPlace 31 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 2:19.00a |
| 32 | Josh JohnstonPlace 32 · Saint John's (Minn.) | — | Saint John's (Minn.) | 2:19.27a |
| 33 | Wenyuan ShangPlace 33 · University of Minnesota | — | University of Minnesota | 2:20.84a |
| 34 | Silas DingerPlace 34 · St. Cloud State | — | St. Cloud State | 2:23.77a |