| 1 | Darien GulickPlace 1 · Penn State University C | — | Penn State University C | 49.76a |
| 2 | Preston LubeskiPlace 2 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 50.11a |
| 3 | Connor GoldfarbPlace 3 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 50.23a |
| 4 | Rayven SamplePlace 4 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 50.63a |
| 5 | Travis BighamPlace 5 · Shippensburg | — | Shippensburg | 51.06a |
| 6 | Amani Ndegwa-BrownPlace 6 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 51.31a |
| 7 | Zachary JelinekPlace 7 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 51.46a |
| 8 | Chris ShortPlace 8 · Muhlenberg | — | Muhlenberg | 51.57a |
| 9 | Ryan MoorePlace 9 · Lafayette | — | Lafayette | 51.69a |
| 10 | Zach BarbanPlace 10 · Lafayette | — | Lafayette | 51.90a |
| 11 | Gardy PhilogenePlace 11 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 52.58a |
| 12 | Sam CoughlinPlace 12 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 52.76a |
| 13 | Quinton TownsendPlace 13 · Shippensburg | — | Shippensburg | 53.35a |
| 14 | Ilios MillettPlace 14 · Lafayette | — | Lafayette | 53.86a |
| 15 | Christopher JonesPlace 15 · Penn State University C | — | Penn State University C | 53.89a |
| 16 | Matthew TomainePlace 16 · Penn State University C | — | Penn State University C | 55.76a |
| 17 | Hayden KleinPlace 17 · Muhlenberg | — | Muhlenberg | 58.12a |