| Pl | Athlete / entry | Gr | School / team | Mark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scarlett HawkinsPlace 1 · Buckingham Browne & Nic | — | Buckingham Browne & Nic | 5:02.01a |
| 2 | Lia GavinPlace 2 · Noble & Greenough | — | Noble & Greenough | 5:41.49a |
| 3 | Luciana Castillo BarcenaPlace 3 · Tabor Academy | — | Tabor Academy | 6:11.15a |
| 4 | Isabel GoddardPlace 4 · Noble & Greenough | — | Noble & Greenough | 6:38.17a |
| 5 | Lauren PeloquinPlace 5 · Noble & Greenough | — | Noble & Greenough | 6:58.65a |
| 6 | Christina HallPlace 6 · Noble & Greenough | — | Noble & Greenough | 7:09.95a |