| 1 | Klay GrantPlace 1 · Colorado College | — | Colorado College | 3:55.33a |
| 2 | Myles BachPlace 2 · Neb.-Kearney | — | Neb.-Kearney | 3:58.15a |
| 3 | Ethan FisherPlace 3 · Fort Hays State | — | Fort Hays State | 3:58.42a |
| 4 | Brady StegmanPlace 4 · Fort Hays State | — | Fort Hays State | 4:00.22a |
| 5 | Quentin DreyerPlace 5 · Wayne State (Neb.) | — | Wayne State (Neb.) | 4:01.98a |
| 6 | Landon EckhardtPlace 6 · Neb.-Kearney | — | Neb.-Kearney | 4:04.57a |
| 7 | Ethan WamplerPlace 7 · Colorado College | — | Colorado College | 4:06.75a |
| 8 | Rylan CheneyPlace 8 · UNAT-Nebraska-Kearney | — | UNAT-Nebraska-Kearney | 4:08.32a |
| 9 | Mason GanszPlace 9 · Colorado College | — | Colorado College | 4:08.91a |
| 10 | Oscar Aguado-MendezPlace 10 · Neb.-Kearney | — | Neb.-Kearney | 4:08.97a |
| 11 | Nathan JohnsonPlace 11 · UNAT-Nebraska-Kearney | — | UNAT-Nebraska-Kearney | 4:10.03a |
| 12 | Noah MorenzPlace 12 · Fort Hays State | — | Fort Hays State | 4:11.53a |
| 13 | Carsyn TurpinPlace 13 · Fort Hays State | — | Fort Hays State | 4:12.02a |
| 14 | Chayse McCulloughPlace 14 · Fort Hays State | — | Fort Hays State | 4:15.64a |
| 15 | Evan BrownPlace 15 · Nebraska Wesleyan | — | Nebraska Wesleyan | 4:17.18a |
| 16 | Tanner ReinertPlace 16 · South Dakota Mines | — | South Dakota Mines | 4:17.25a |
| 17 | Thomas VasquezPlace 17 · Nebraska Wesleyan | — | Nebraska Wesleyan | 4:17.37a |
| 18 | Connor ReesonPlace 18 · UNAT-Nebraska-Kearney | — | UNAT-Nebraska-Kearney | 4:19.02a |
| 19 | Mason BachPlace 19 · Neb.-Kearney | — | Neb.-Kearney | 4:19.16a |
| 20 | Quin KarasPlace 20 · Neb.-Kearney | — | Neb.-Kearney | 4:20.98a |
| 21 | Jennings WilsonPlace 21 · Colorado College | — | Colorado College | 4:21.25a |
| 22 | Max BowyerPlace 22 · Fort Hays State | — | Fort Hays State | 4:21.68a |
| 23 | Brady FranzenPlace 23 · Wayne State (Neb.) | — | Wayne State (Neb.) | 4:22.12a |
| 24 | Josh KnispelPlace 24 · Nebraska Wesleyan | — | Nebraska Wesleyan | 4:26.33a |
| 25 | Brandon MitzelPlace 25 · Wayne State (Neb.) | — | Wayne State (Neb.) | 4:26.64a |
| 26 | Ethan OlsonPlace 26 · Nebraska Wesleyan | — | Nebraska Wesleyan | 4:34.72a |
| 27 | Byron JohnsonPlace 27 · Fort Hays State | — | Fort Hays State | 4:39.03a |
| 28 | Brody KoosPlace 28 · Nebraska Wesleyan | — | Nebraska Wesleyan | 4:41.94a |
| 29 | Manuel MartinezPlace 29 · Dodge City (Kan.) CC | — | Dodge City (Kan.) CC | 4:56.65a |