| 1 | Connor RissPlace 1 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:10.52a |
| 2 | Braden NicholsonPlace 2 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:11.94a |
| 3 | Austin SpringerPlace 3 · MSOE | — | MSOE | 4:22.66a |
| 4 | John ListPlace 4 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:25.64a |
| 5 | Jacob EverixPlace 5 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:27.90a |
| 6 | Owen ChristyPlace 6 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:28.07a |
| 7 | Chase NogalskiPlace 7 · MSOE | — | MSOE | 4:28.26a |
| 8 | Isaac CohenPlace 8 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:28.62a |
| 9 | Timothee AdlerPlace 9 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:29.18a |
| 10 | Rishi YoungPlace 10 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:29.83a |
| 11 | LIam EifertPlace 11 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:31.09a |
| 12 | Alex BenkartPlace 12 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:31.93a |
| 13 | Zane GillanPlace 13 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:32.09a |
| 14 | Noah BenderPlace 14 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:33.65a |
| 15 | Bryce WijesekaraPlace 15 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:35.93a |
| 16 | Frankie ReidPlace 16 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:36.32a |
| 17 | Ethan HarperPlace 17 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:38.21a |
| 18 | Ellis AllenPlace 18 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:40.13a |
| 19 | Nicholas SadelskiPlace 19 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:40.97a |
| 20 | Zach TaubmanPlace 20 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:41.87a |
| 21 | Remy JankuskyPlace 21 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:41.93a |
| 22 | Jack DornerPlace 22 · MSOE | — | MSOE | 4:43.51a |
| 23 | Matthew ShimenettoPlace 23 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:45.38a |
| 24 | Brett LitkeyPlace 24 · MSOE | — | MSOE | 4:47.23a |
| 25 | Brayden GroenenboomPlace 25 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:48.37a |
| 26 | Ryan MalveyPlace 26 · MSOE | — | MSOE | 4:52.85a |
| 27 | Logan KeelingPlace 27 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:55.01a |
| 28 | Ryan BreesePlace 28 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:56.59a |
| 29 | Ari ElmayanPlace 29 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 4:58.45a |
| 30 | Benjamin HEARONPlace 30 · Exhibition | — | Exhibition | 4:59.69a |
| 31 | Marcos JAIMESPlace 31 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 5:00.15a |
| 32 | Haroon SalahuddinPlace 32 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 5:00.51a |
| 33 | Reponse NshimiyePlace 33 · Benedictine (Ill.) | — | Benedictine (Ill.) | 5:00.66a |
| 34 | Zachary EricksonPlace 34 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 5:02.63a |
| 35 | Adam TorenPlace 35 · North Central (Ill.) | — | North Central (Ill.) | 5:04.92a |
| 36 | Giovanni Del CarmenPlace 36 · North Park | — | North Park | 6:20.25a |
