| 1 | John BardPlace 1 · Pomona-Pitzer | — | Pomona-Pitzer | 1:58.04a |
| 2 | Matthew VickersPlace 2 · Occidental | — | Occidental | 1:59.19a |
| 3 | Frederick AmbrosePlace 3 · Pomona-Pitzer | — | Pomona-Pitzer | 1:59.94a |
| 4 | Jonas RickertPlace 4 · Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | — | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | 2:02.14a |
| 5 | Jacob PippelPlace 5 · Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | — | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | 2:02.17a |
| 6 | Nick PaternitiPlace 6 · Pomona-Pitzer | — | Pomona-Pitzer | 2:03.29a |
| 7 | Adrian RodriguezPlace 7 · Cal Lutheran | — | Cal Lutheran | 2:03.66a |
| 8 | Ryan JabroPlace 8 · Pomona-Pitzer | — | Pomona-Pitzer | 2:06.14a |
| 9 | Kiyoshi ToddPlace 9 · Whittier | — | Whittier | 2:07.64a |
| 10 | Alex CohenPlace 10 · Pomona-Pitzer | — | Pomona-Pitzer | 2:08.60a |
| 11 | Samuel NussbaumPlace 11 · Occidental | — | Occidental | 2:09.31a |
| 12 | Josh AbeytaPlace 12 · Occidental | — | Occidental | 2:09.65a |
| 13 | Chase MillerPlace 13 · Occidental | — | Occidental | 2:11.38a |
| 14 | Hunter ThuPlace 14 · Pomona-Pitzer | — | Pomona-Pitzer | 2:12.11a |
| 15 | Max CowanPlace 15 · Occidental | — | Occidental | 2:16.92a |
| 16 | Joe Lopez VasquezPlace 16 · Cal Lutheran | — | Cal Lutheran | 2:22.93a |
| 17 | Derek Alonso SantosPlace 17 · Whittier | — | Whittier | 2:27.24a |
