| 1 | Mike FormicaPlace 1 · Grade JR · Indiana (Pa.) | JR | Indiana (Pa.) | 3:53.09a |
| 2 | Noah BernardingPlace 2 · Grade SR · California (Pa.) | SR | California (Pa.) | 3:54.27a |
| 3 | Aleksei SeletskiyPlace 3 · Grade SR · Carnegie Mellon | SR | Carnegie Mellon | 3:58.67a |
| 4 | Cale BorlandPlace 4 · Grade FR · Mount Union | FR | Mount Union | 3:58.74a |
| 5 | Curtis JoppeckPlace 5 · Grade SR · Mount Union | SR | Mount Union | 3:59.10a |
| 6 | Brock PenningtonPlace 6 · Grade SR · Washington & Jefferson | SR | Washington & Jefferson | 3:59.46a |
| 7 | Cameron BogdanPlace 7 · Grade SO · Duquesne | SO | Duquesne | 3:59.82a |
| 8 | Chase BowenPlace 8 · Grade FR · Point Park (Pa.) | FR | Point Park (Pa.) | 4:01.83a |
| 9 | Tyler KohlmannPlace 9 · Grade SO · Mount Union | SO | Mount Union | 4:02.75a |
| 10 | Ashton BeverlyPlace 10 · Grade SO · Rio Grande (Ohio) | SO | Rio Grande (Ohio) | 4:03.40a |
| 11 | Nick SteinfeldtPlace 11 · Grade FR · Pittsburgh | FR | Pittsburgh | 4:03.77a |
| 12 | Lauge RasmussenPlace 12 · Grade SO · Gannon | SO | Gannon | 4:04.06a |
| 13 | Kaden CrumpPlace 13 · Grade JR · Seton Hill | JR | Seton Hill | 4:04.09a |
| 14 | Cole JoostePlace 14 · Grade JR · Allegheny (Pa.) | JR | Allegheny (Pa.) | 4:04.58a |
| 15 | Tom BradyPlace 15 · Grade JR · Indiana (Pa.) | JR | Indiana (Pa.) | 4:04.93a |
| 16 | Matthew TschantzPlace 16 · Grade JR · Mount Union | JR | Mount Union | 4:05.13a |
| 17 | Sam FreedmanPlace 17 · Grade FR · Duquesne | FR | Duquesne | 4:05.28a |
| 18 | Aike Van der LeiPlace 18 · Grade FR · Point Park (Pa.) | FR | Point Park (Pa.) | 4:05.98a |
| 19 | Thomas DamianiPlace 19 · Grade JR · Carnegie Mellon | JR | Carnegie Mellon | 4:06.25a |
| 20 | Aiden JacksonPlace 20 · Grade SR · Saint Vincent | SR | Saint Vincent | 4:07.15a |
| 21 | Justin DomencicPlace 21 · Grade JR · Robert Morris | JR | Robert Morris | 4:08.11a |
| 22 | Jon BerzonskyPlace 22 · Grade SO · California (Pa.) | SO | California (Pa.) | 4:08.19a |
| 23 | Ethan BarrickPlace 23 · Grade JR · Pitt Johnstown | JR | Pitt Johnstown | 4:09.46a |
| 24 | Emile RaphaelPlace 24 · Grade FR · Point Park (Pa.) | FR | Point Park (Pa.) | 4:09.75a |
| 25 | Zach WysePlace 25 · Grade SR · Allegheny (Pa.) | SR | Allegheny (Pa.) | 4:11.70a |
| 26 | Ryan DomencicPlace 26 · Grade FR · Robert Morris | FR | Robert Morris | 4:12.39a |
| 27 | Bradyn RuschPlace 27 · Grade FR · Gannon | FR | Gannon | 4:13.36a |
| 28 | Ethan QuezadaPlace 28 · Grade FR · Edinboro | FR | Edinboro | 4:13.50a |
| 29 | Owen SparksPlace 29 · Grade SO · Indiana (Pa.) | SO | Indiana (Pa.) | 4:13.70a |
| 30 | Austin MolinaroPlace 30 · Grade SO · Robert Morris | SO | Robert Morris | 4:14.30a |
| 31 | Timothy HamiltonPlace 31 · Grade FR · Penn State Behrend | FR | Penn State Behrend | 4:15.01a |
| 32 | Will StickmanPlace 32 · Grade FR · Saint Vincent | FR | Saint Vincent | 4:15.58a |
| 33 | Philip BergerPlace 33 · Grade SO · Edinboro | SO | Edinboro | 4:15.89a |
| 34 | Jake SinclairPlace 34 · Grade SR · Washington & Jefferson | SR | Washington & Jefferson | 4:16.06a |
| 35 | Ethan BootsPlace 35 · Grade FR · Gannon | FR | Gannon | 4:19.38a |
| 36 | James YohoPlace 36 · Grade SO · Grove City | SO | Grove City | 4:19.71a |
| 37 | Brendon WardPlace 37 · Grade SR · Indiana (Pa.) | SR | Indiana (Pa.) | 4:20.05a |
| 38 | Daniel DealPlace 38 · Grade SR · Washington & Jefferson | SR | Washington & Jefferson | 4:22.09a |
| 39 | Gabriel BibawyPlace 39 · Grade FR · Grove City | FR | Grove City | 4:23.11a |
| 40 | Dane FasickPlace 40 · Grade SR · Westminster (Pa.) | SR | Westminster (Pa.) | 4:23.41a |
| 41 | Kamsi ObuekwePlace 41 · Grade SO · Seton Hill | SO | Seton Hill | 4:23.95a |
| 42 | Will BerzonskyPlace 42 · Grade SO · California (Pa.) | SO | California (Pa.) | 4:24.96a |
| 43 | Ryan CawleyPlace 43 · Grade JR · Saint Vincent | JR | Saint Vincent | 4:27.50a |
| 44 | Brandt PattersonPlace 44 · Grade JR · Pitt Johnstown | JR | Pitt Johnstown | 4:29.08a |
| 45 | Eli FliehmanPlace 45 · Grade FR · Rio Grande (Ohio) | FR | Rio Grande (Ohio) | 4:30.21a |
| 46 | Nathaniel TurnerPlace 46 · Grade SO · Thiel | SO | Thiel | 4:30.51a |
| 47 | Josh HaleyPlace 47 · Grade FR · Grove City | FR | Grove City | 4:30.94a |
| 48 | Justin RedillaPlace 48 · Grade JR · Westminster (Pa.) | JR | Westminster (Pa.) | 4:31.15a |
| 49 | Niko MoorePlace 49 · Grade FR · Allegheny (Pa.) | FR | Allegheny (Pa.) | 4:34.77a |
| 50 | Nicholas KellyPlace 50 · Grade SO · Pitt Johnstown | SO | Pitt Johnstown | 4:36.06a |
| 51 | Jacob CallPlace 51 · Grade SO · Grove City | SO | Grove City | 4:36.12a |
| 52 | Daniel Van Der WesthuizePlace 52 · Grade FR · Gannon | FR | Gannon | 4:39.94a |
| 53 | Eli MillerPlace 53 · Grade SO · Grove City | SO | Grove City | 4:41.06a |
| 54 | John ClackoPlace 54 · Grade SO · California (Pa.) | SO | California (Pa.) | 4:42.73a |
| 55 | Eric FowlerPlace 55 · Grade JR · Carlow (Pa.) | JR | Carlow (Pa.) | 4:56.33a |
| 56 | Francis BochicchioPlace 56 · Grade JR · Carlow (Pa.) | JR | Carlow (Pa.) | 4:58.27a |
| 57 | Anthony ScottPlace 57 · Grade SR · Pitt Johnstown | SR | Pitt Johnstown | 4:59.86a |
| 58 | Hunter BradyPlace 58 · Grade FR · Carlow (Pa.) | FR | Carlow (Pa.) | 5:05.90a |
| 59 | Joel WeberPlace 59 · Grade JR · Pitt Johnstown | JR | Pitt Johnstown | 5:07.74a |
| 60 | Sangay GurungPlace 60 · Grade SO · Carlow (Pa.) | SO | Carlow (Pa.) | 6:15.46a |
| 61 | Ike AguwaPlace 61 · Carlow (Pa.) | — | Carlow (Pa.) | 7:43.97a |
| 62 | Jack CornellPlace 62 · Grade FR · Carlow (Pa.) | FR | Carlow (Pa.) | 8:02.19a |