| 1 | Ayobami ArokoyoPlace 1 · Grade SR · St. Xavier | SR | St. Xavier | 52.45m |
| 2 | Christian RiosPlace 2 · Grade SR · Marian (Ind.) | SR | Marian (Ind.) | 52.22m |
| 3 | Josh HolderPlace 3 · Grade FR · Indiana Wesleyan | FR | Indiana Wesleyan | 46.48m |
| 4 | Mason MurphyPlace 4 · Grade JR · Indiana Tech | JR | Indiana Tech | 46.37m |
| 5 | Jacob KavickyPlace 5 · Grade SO · Indiana Tech | SO | Indiana Tech | 44.98m |
| 6 | Darian DixonPlace 6 · Marian University DT | — | Marian University DT | 44.19m |
| 7 | Carter HigginsPlace 7 · Grade FR · Indiana Wesleyan | FR | Indiana Wesleyan | 43.92m |
| 8 | Christian DixonPlace 8 · Grade FR · Indiana Tech | FR | Indiana Tech | 43.07m |
| 9 | Thomas ImburgiaPlace 9 · Grade SO · St. Xavier | SO | St. Xavier | 41.71m |
| 10 | Sam RunholtPlace 10 · Marian University DT | — | Marian University DT | 41.40m |
| 11 | Markevious KeysPlace 11 · Grade JR · Marian (Ind.) | JR | Marian (Ind.) | 39.77m |
| 12 | Javian JonesPlace 12 · Grade FR · Marian (Ind.) | FR | Marian (Ind.) | 39.54m |
| 13 | Ian SlebrchPlace 13 · Grade JR · Indiana Tech | JR | Indiana Tech | 35.70m |
| 14 | Michael RunionsPlace 14 · Grade SO · Marian (Ind.) | SO | Marian (Ind.) | 23.54m |