| 1 | Anthony ShiversPlace 1 · Grade 8 · Unattached | 8 | Unattached | 55.37m |
| 2 | James DennisPlace 2 · Grade 8 · Unattached | 8 | Unattached | 51.56m |
| 3 | Coleson KerteszPlace 3 · Grade SR · Youngstown State | SR | Youngstown State | 50.56m |
| 4 | John BowmanPlace 4 · Grade 8 · BOWMANTHROWS | 8 | BOWMANTHROWS | 49.81m |
| 5 | Justin MoorePlace 5 · Grade SO · Shawnee State (Ohio) | SO | Shawnee State (Ohio) | 49.50m |
| 6 | Alan AustinPlace 6 · Grade SO · Shawnee State (Ohio) | SO | Shawnee State (Ohio) | 47.52m |
| 7 | Thomas HickmanPlace 7 · Grade SR · Baldwin Wallace | SR | Baldwin Wallace | 47.14m |
| 8 | Matthew RussoPlace 8 · Grade SR · John Carroll | SR | John Carroll | 45.87m |
| 9 | Connor DewanPlace 9 · Grade SR · Albion | SR | Albion | 45.42m |
| 10 | Antonio SonegoPlace 10 · Grade SR · Ohio Wesleyan | SR | Ohio Wesleyan | 44.41m |
| 11 | Chris BeemillerPlace 11 · Grade SR · Malone | SR | Malone | 42.90m |
| 12 | Evan GomezPlace 12 · Grade JR · Ohio Northern | JR | Ohio Northern | 42.55m |
| 13 | Mason KieselPlace 13 · Grade SR · Baldwin Wallace | SR | Baldwin Wallace | 40.10m |
| 14 | Gavin TrebeloPlace 14 · Grade SO · Malone | SO | Malone | 38.85m |
| 15 | Moose FrombachPlace 15 · Grade SO · John Carroll | SO | John Carroll | 36.01m |
| 16 | Brett StephensPlace 16 · Grade SO · Lake Erie | SO | Lake Erie | 34.99m |
| 17 | Aidan MastasoPlace 17 · Grade SO · Malone | SO | Malone | 34.69m |
| 18 | Troy CrosbyPlace 18 · Grade SO · Wittenberg | SO | Wittenberg | 28.47m |
| 19 | Nicholas LeonPlace 19 · Grade SO · Malone | SO | Malone | 27.29m |