| 1 | Ethan Moe RSPlace 1 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:50.33a |
| 2 | Alejandro CivettaPlace 2 · Grade JR · Manitoba | JR | Manitoba | 1:50.88a |
| 3 | Quinn RoehlPlace 3 · Grade SO · North Dakota State | SO | North Dakota State | 1:53.04a |
| 4 | Noah FillionPlace 4 · Manitoba | — | Manitoba | 1:53.25a |
| 5 | Carl RekowPlace 5 · Grade SO · North Dakota State | SO | North Dakota State | 1:53.65a |
| 6 | Jonah DafoePlace 6 · Grade SO · North Dakota State | SO | North Dakota State | 1:53.75a |
| 7 | Zackery BruderPlace 7 · Grade FR · North Dakota State | FR | North Dakota State | 1:54.57a |
| 8 | Ryan FickPlace 8 · Grade FR · North Dakota State | FR | North Dakota State | 1:56.52a |
| 9 | William GerberPlace 9 · Grade SO · North Dakota State | SO | North Dakota State | 1:58.87a |
| 10 | Peyton TuhyPlace 10 · Grade SR · Minot State | SR | Minot State | 1:58.89a |
| 11 | Zach BaumgartnerPlace 11 · Grade SO · Valley City State (N.D.) | SO | Valley City State (N.D.) | 2:00.45a |
| 12 | Kohen HolcombPlace 12 · Grade FR · Unattached | FR | Unattached | 2:00.75a |
| 13 | Micah StoudtPlace 13 · Grade FR · Bismarck State (N.D.) | FR | Bismarck State (N.D.) | 2:00.89a |
| 14 | Dorian JohnsonPlace 14 · Grade 12 · Tough Track Athletic Club | 12 | Tough Track Athletic Club | 2:00.99a |
| 15 | Nicolas BergenPlace 15 · Grade FR · Manitoba | FR | Manitoba | 2:01.08a |
| 16 | Riley HansonPlace 16 · Grade JR · Unattached | JR | Unattached | 2:01.30a |
| 17 | Holter BridwellPlace 17 · Grade JR · Minot State | JR | Minot State | 2:01.42a |
| 18 | Adam SobolikPlace 18 · Grade FR · Jamestown (N.D.) | FR | Jamestown (N.D.) | 2:01.64a |
| 19 | Mateo PennerPlace 19 · Grade 9 · Tough Track Athletic Club | 9 | Tough Track Athletic Club | 2:02.59a |
| 20 | Zander GroverPlace 20 · Grade SO · Minot State | SO | Minot State | 2:02.92a |
| 21 | Lucas DahlPlace 21 · Grade SO · Jamestown (N.D.) | SO | Jamestown (N.D.) | 2:03.24a |
| 22 | Jacob JacksonPlace 22 · Grade FR · Minot State | FR | Minot State | 2:04.62a |
| 23 | Harrison CobbPlace 23 · Grade JR · Bismarck State (N.D.) | JR | Bismarck State (N.D.) | 2:05.42a |
| 24 | Samuel SampersPlace 24 · Grade SO · Jamestown (N.D.) | SO | Jamestown (N.D.) | 2:07.13a |
| 25 | Evan GroverPlace 25 · Grade SR · Concordia Moorhead | SR | Concordia Moorhead | 2:08.53a |
| 26 | Brody SyversonPlace 26 · Grade FR · Concordia Moorhead | FR | Concordia Moorhead | 2:10.10a |
| 27 | Simon SewellPlace 27 · Tough Track Athletic Club | — | Tough Track Athletic Club | 2:10.29a |
| 28 | Weston MaharPlace 28 · Grade FR · Concordia Moorhead | FR | Concordia Moorhead | 2:10.93a |
| 29 | Carter FlatauPlace 29 · Grade FR · Unattached | FR | Unattached | 2:11.28a |
| 30 | Blake AndrewsPlace 30 · Grade FR · Concordia Moorhead | FR | Concordia Moorhead | 2:11.83a |
| 31 | Joe VenablesPlace 31 · Grade SO · Concordia Moorhead | SO | Concordia Moorhead | 2:12.44a |
| 32 | Logan RobbenPlace 32 · Grade FR · Jamestown (N.D.) | FR | Jamestown (N.D.) | 2:13.40a |
| 33 | Avery HarsellPlace 33 · Grade FR · Concordia Moorhead | FR | Concordia Moorhead | 2:28.86a |