| 1. | Kyra LekanidesPlace 1. · Grade 12 · Garden City | 12 | Garden City | 1:39.03a |
| 2. | Taylor MaguirePlace 2. · Grade 11 · Garden City | 11 | Garden City | 1:39.36a PR |
| 3. | Sinead CromiePlace 3. · Grade 9 · General Douglas Macarthur | 9 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:46.54a |
| 4. | Sarah SohlPlace 4. · Grade 12 · Farmingdale | 12 | Farmingdale | 1:47.47a |
| 5. | Abby TedescoPlace 5. · Grade 12 · Garden City | 12 | Garden City | 1:49.20a PR |
| 6. | Emily CastilloPlace 6. · Grade 11 · General Douglas Macarthur | 11 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:50.03a PR |
| 7. | Grace O'DohertyPlace 7. · Grade 9 · General Douglas Macarthur | 9 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:51.11a |
| 8. | Ava ReniPlace 8. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 1:53.64a PR |
| 9. | Sahrina ChoudhuryPlace 9. · Grade 10 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 10 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 1:53.77a |
| 10. | Joanna FiniPlace 10. · Grade 10 · H Frank Carey | 10 | H Frank Carey | 1:54.32a PR |
| 11. | Sydney GilbertPlace 11. · Grade 12 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 12 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 1:54.33a PR |
| 12. | Kailey CabreraPlace 12. · Grade 11 · Westbury | 11 | Westbury | 1:55.10a |
| 13. | Emma MeldromPlace 13. · Grade 10 · Mineola | 10 | Mineola | 1:56.37a PR |
| 14. | Emma FitchPlace 14. · Grade 12 · H Frank Carey | 12 | H Frank Carey | 1:57.07a |
| 15. | Claire Delli CarpiniPlace 15. · Grade 9 · Cold Spring Harbor | 9 | Cold Spring Harbor | 1:57.17a PR |
| 16. | Avery GrevstadPlace 16. · Grade 9 · Farmingdale | 9 | Farmingdale | 1:59.96a PR |
| 17. | Emily McDonaldPlace 17. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 2:00.40a PR |
| 18. | Caitlin PetersPlace 18. · Grade 10 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 10 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 2:01.21a |
| 19. | Sienna ParmarPlace 19. · Grade 8 · Herricks | 8 | Herricks | 2:03.10a |
| 20. | Sophia CanoPlace 20. · Grade 11 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 11 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 2:04.95a PR |
| 21. | Keeley PalmerPlace 21. · Grade 8 · Cold Spring Harbor | 8 | Cold Spring Harbor | 2:05.36a PR |
| 22. | Jessica ScheulenPlace 22. · Grade 11 · Division Avenue (Levittown) | 11 | Division Avenue (Levittown) | 2:05.89a PR |
| 23. | Lora FlanaganPlace 23. · Grade 11 · General Douglas Macarthur | 11 | General Douglas Macarthur | 2:05.90a |
| 24. | Chloe HallPlace 24. · Grade 12 · Herricks | 12 | Herricks | 2:06.39a |
| 25. | Molly McAleaPlace 25. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 2:06.58a PR |
| 26. | Anna Maria CelanoPlace 26. · Grade 10 · Herricks | 10 | Herricks | 2:06.85a PR |
| 27. | Adishree DasPlace 27. · Grade 11 · Herricks | 11 | Herricks | 2:06.89a |
| 28. | Charlotte GrimesPlace 28. · Grade 9 · Farmingdale | 9 | Farmingdale | 2:07.20a PR |
| 29. | Kerly VelasquezPlace 29. · Grade 11 · H Frank Carey | 11 | H Frank Carey | 2:08.05a |
| 30. | Jennifer GerberPlace 30. · Grade 11 · Cold Spring Harbor | 11 | Cold Spring Harbor | 2:08.15a |
| 31. | Riley IannottiPlace 31. · Grade 10 · Locust Valley | 10 | Locust Valley | 2:08.75a PR |
| 32. | Paige KovnerPlace 32. · Grade 9 · Cold Spring Harbor | 9 | Cold Spring Harbor | 2:09.29a PR |
| 33. | Gabriella BraicoPlace 33. · Grade 9 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 9 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 2:10.56a PR |
| 34. | Macie MacalusoPlace 34. · Grade 9 · Cold Spring Harbor | 9 | Cold Spring Harbor | 2:10.67a PR |
| 35. | Margaret RyanPlace 35. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 2:11.61a PR |
| 36. | Smantha ReginaPlace 36. · Grade 10 · Farmingdale | 10 | Farmingdale | 2:11.64a PR |
| 37. | Leena RodriguezPlace 37. · Grade 11 · H Frank Carey | 11 | H Frank Carey | 2:11.82a |
| 38. | Maeve GarveyPlace 38. · Grade 10 · Garden City | 10 | Garden City | 2:12.09a PR |
| 39. | Katherine SalgadoPlace 39. · Grade 12 · Mineola | 12 | Mineola | 2:12.57a |
| 40. | Hope HoysPlace 40. · Grade 11 · Mineola | 11 | Mineola | 2:12.65a |
| 41. | Kacie FinklePlace 41. · Grade 10 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 10 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 2:12.66a |
| 42. | Naomi ChackoPlace 42. · Grade 11 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 11 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 2:12.71a PR |
| 43. | Grace KellyPlace 43. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 2:12.77a PR |
| 44. | Katie KyriacouPlace 44. · Grade 10 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 10 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 2:15.16a PR |
| 45. | Molly KatzPlace 45. · Grade 9 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 9 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 2:15.40a PR |
| 46. | Zoey EiseneggetPlace 46. · Grade 9 · Cold Spring Harbor | 9 | Cold Spring Harbor | 2:16.13a PR |
| 47. | Samantha SchabhuttlPlace 47. · Grade 9 · Garden City | 9 | Garden City | 2:17.84a PR |
| 48. | Madison OttavioPlace 48. · Grade 11 · H Frank Carey | 11 | H Frank Carey | 2:18.58a PR |
| 49. | Cadence SykoraPlace 49. · Grade 9 · General Douglas Macarthur | 9 | General Douglas Macarthur | 2:19.49a PR |
| 50. | Kelly LiPlace 50. · Grade 12 · Mineola | 12 | Mineola | 2:21.92a PR |
| 51. | Valery TorresPlace 51. · Grade 12 · Mineola | 12 | Mineola | 2:34.91a PR |
| -- | Meghan MorrisPlace -- · Grade 9 · General Douglas Macarthur | 9 | General Douglas Macarthur | DQ |