| 1. | Arjun SureshPlace 1. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:37.06a | 0 |
| 2. | Parker ThompsonPlace 2. · Grade Fr · Assumption | Fr | Assumption | 4:37.66a PR | 0 |
| 3. | Tyler DeCiantisPlace 3. · Grade Fr · Sacred Heart | Fr | Sacred Heart | 4:37.88a | 0 |
| 4. | Aaron PelletierPlace 4. · Grade Sr · Assumption | Sr | Assumption | 4:38.77a | 0 |
| 5. | Anthony MannaPlace 5. · Grade Jr · Assumption | Jr | Assumption | 4:41.89a | 0 |
| 6. | Jake FerrarePlace 6. · Grade Fr · Assumption | Fr | Assumption | 4:42.74a PR | 0 |
| 7. | Brady SweeneyPlace 7. · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 4:42.85a | 0 |
| 8. | Casey SymonsPlace 8. · Grade Sr · Merchant Marine Academy | Sr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:44.21a | 0 |
| 9. | Elijah RamthunPlace 9. · Grade Sr · Merchant Marine Academy | Sr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:45.87a PR | 0 |
| 10. | Mosiah CalderonPlace 10. · Grade Fr · Adelphi | Fr | Adelphi | 4:47.41a | 0 |
| 11. | Kyle MartinPlace 11. · Grade So · Assumption | So | Assumption | 4:47.85a PR | 0 |
| 12. | Matthew NofriPlace 12. · Grade Sr · Assumption | Sr | Assumption | 4:49.28a PR | 0 |
| 13. | Evan LawsPlace 13. · Grade Sr · Assumption | Sr | Assumption | 4:49.30a | 0 |
| 14. | Cooper JohnsonPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:52.90a | 0 |
| 15. | Brady CarrollPlace 15. · Grade Sr · Adelphi | Sr | Adelphi | 4:53.48a | 0 |
| 16. | Gabriel AguilarPlace 16. · Grade Jr · Farmingdale State | Jr | Farmingdale State | 4:53.66a | 0 |
| 17. | Jack LengyelPlace 17. · Grade So · Farmingdale State | So | Farmingdale State | 4:55.94a | 0 |
| 18. | Joshua PhinneyPlace 18. · Grade Jr · Assumption | Jr | Assumption | 4:57.45a PR | 0 |
| 19. | Caden DavisPlace 19. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:57.90a PR | 0 |
| 20. | Ian PereiraPlace 20. · Grade Jr · Assumption | Jr | Assumption | 4:58.32a | 0 |
| 21. | Ethan AlliotPlace 21. · Grade So · Merchant Marine Academy | So | Merchant Marine Academy | 5:00.93a | 0 |
| 22. | Gavin GareriPlace 22. · Grade Sr · Assumption | Sr | Assumption | 5:01.59a PR | 0 |
| 23. | Enois MaceiraPlace 23. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 5:03.15a PR | 0 |
| 24. | Chase PavlowPlace 24. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 5:03.33a | 0 |
| 25. | Max ReillyPlace 25. · Grade Jr · Farmingdale State | Jr | Farmingdale State | 5:10.50a | 0 |
| 26. | Alex Sanchez Jr.Place 26. · Grade Fr · Bridgeport | Fr | Bridgeport | 5:12.17a PR | 0 |
| 27. | Steven TheodoropoulosPlace 27. · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 5:12.61a | 0 |
| 28. | Gavin CalvoPlace 28. · Grade Fr · Farmingdale State | Fr | Farmingdale State | 5:15.75a | 0 |
| 29. | Landon GravesPlace 29. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 5:26.15a | 0 |
| -- | Toby MiddletonPlace -- · Grade Sr · Bridgeport | Sr | Bridgeport | DNF | 0 |
| -- | Luke ZweislerPlace -- · Grade Sr · Merchant Marine Academy | Sr | Merchant Marine Academy | DNS | 0 |
| -- | Silas GlynnPlace -- · Grade Sr · Merchant Marine Academy | Sr | Merchant Marine Academy | DNS | 0 |
| -- | Alexander ArmendarizPlace -- · Grade Fr · Sacred Heart | Fr | Sacred Heart | DNS | 0 |
| -- | MJ DeMartinPlace -- · Grade 12 · Unattached | 12 | Unattached | DNS | 0 |
| -- | Brayden MercierPlace -- · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | DNS | 0 |
| -- | Aiden CarringtonPlace -- · Grade Fr · Farmingdale State | Fr | Farmingdale State | DNS | 0 |
| -- | Owen DavisPlace -- · Grade So · Assumption | So | Assumption | DNS | 0 |
| -- | Charles DriscollPlace -- · Grade Sr · Assumption | Sr | Assumption | DNF | 0 |
| -- | Alex VirostekPlace -- · Grade Sr · Merchant Marine Academy | Sr | Merchant Marine Academy | DNS | 0 |