| 1 | Matthew ShortPlace 1 · Grade JR · Carnegie Mellon | JR | Carnegie Mellon | 1:55.35 |
| 2 | Adam DickenPlace 2 · Grade FR · Bucknell | FR | Bucknell | 1:56.48 |
| 3 | Edoardo VandelliPlace 3 · Grade SO · Bridgeport | SO | Bridgeport | 1:56.93 |
| 4 | Owen ShraderPlace 4 · Grade FR · Shippensburg | FR | Shippensburg | 1:57.90 |
| 5 | Ryan KenneffPlace 5 · Grade FR · Kutztown | FR | Kutztown | 1:58.17 |
| 6 | Gabe PacynaPlace 6 · Grade JR · Indiana (Pa.) | JR | Indiana (Pa.) | 1:58.56 |
| 7 | Aiden SchwartzPlace 7 · Grade FR · West Chester | FR | West Chester | 2:01.29 |
| 8 | Will WeaverPlace 8 · Grade FR · Indiana (Pa.) | FR | Indiana (Pa.) | 2:01.37 |
| 9 | Daniel SatarianoPlace 9 · Grade SO · Messiah | SO | Messiah | 2:02.89 |
| 10 | Connor GoldfarbPlace 10 · Grade JR · Bucknell | JR | Bucknell | 2:03.10 |
| 11 | John FlammerPlace 11 · Grade JR · Bucknell | JR | Bucknell | 2:03.89 |
| 12 | Alex AmadorPlace 12 · Grade SO · Indiana (Pa.) | SO | Indiana (Pa.) | 2:04.26 |
| 13 | Nathan SteenPlace 13 · Grade FR · Messiah | FR | Messiah | 2:04.98 |
| 14 | Brett PevecPlace 14 · Grade JR · Kutztown | JR | Kutztown | 2:05.21 |
| 15 | Salahudinn Abdul-HamidPlace 15 · Grade JR · Bloomsburg | JR | Bloomsburg | 2:05.33 |
| 16 | Conor FisherPlace 16 · Grade FR · Kutztown | FR | Kutztown | 2:06.03 |
| 17 | Tyler HaroldPlace 17 · Grade FR · Pitt.-Johnstown | FR | Pitt.-Johnstown | 2:06.08 |
| 18 | Jordan MannPlace 18 · Grade JR · Bloomsburg | JR | Bloomsburg | 2:07.13 |
| 19 | Connor MurphyPlace 19 · Grade JR · Kutztown | JR | Kutztown | 2:07.62 |
| — | William ZaneGrade SR · West Chester | SR | West Chester | DNF |