| 1. | Chris AndersonPlace 1. · Grade - · Unattached | - | Unattached | 4:01.07a PR | 10 |
| 2. | Sebastian HerreraPlace 2. · Grade Fr · Ramapo | Fr | Ramapo | 4:03.83a | 8 |
| 3. | Joshua MingoiaPlace 3. · Grade So · Manhattan University | So | Manhattan University | 4:05.96a | 6 |
| 4. | Julian MignonePlace 4. · Grade Jr · Ramapo | Jr | Ramapo | 4:06.54a | 5 |
| 5. | Matthew GranoPlace 5. · Grade Fr · Essex County (NJ) | Fr | Essex County (NJ) | 4:07.24a | 4 |
| 6. | Alexander KunzPlace 6. · Grade Fr · SUNY Oneonta | Fr | SUNY Oneonta | 4:08.56a | 3 |
| 7. | Brody CoxPlace 7. · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 4:09.57a | 2 |
| 8. | Bretton GarrickPlace 8. · Grade Jr · Union (N.Y.) | Jr | Union (N.Y.) | 4:09.98a | 1 |
| 9. | Lucas BergPlace 9. · Grade Jr · SUNY Oneonta | Jr | SUNY Oneonta | 4:11.21a | 0 |
| 10. | Ronaldo Rodriguez-PerezPlace 10. · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 4:15.51a | 0 |
| 11. | Dean MayoPlace 11. · Grade Sr · Manhattan University | Sr | Manhattan University | 4:15.57a | 0 |
| 12. | Cooper JohnsonPlace 12. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:16.35a | 0 |
| 13. | Noah PickardPlace 13. · Grade Jr · SUNY Oneonta | Jr | SUNY Oneonta | 4:16.54a | 0 |
| 14. | Ethan SpritzerPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Vassar | Fr | Vassar | 4:20.12a | 0 |
| 15. | Brian MetzPlace 15. · Grade Fr · Ramapo | Fr | Ramapo | 4:21.36a | 0 |
| 16. | Deshawn DouglasPlace 16. · Grade Sr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Sr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 4:22.46a | 0 |
| 17. | Jack FlanaganPlace 17. · Grade Sr · Manhattan University | Sr | Manhattan University | 4:22.76a | 0 |
| 18. | Logan KudlaPlace 18. · Grade Jr · Caldwell | Jr | Caldwell | 4:23.13a | 0 |
| 19. | James NicholPlace 19. · Grade Sr · Molloy | Sr | Molloy | 4:24.02a | 0 |
| 20. | Alejandro ArreagaPlace 20. · Grade Fr · Essex County (NJ) | Fr | Essex County (NJ) | 4:25.64a | 0 |
| 21. | Mathew SosaPlace 21. · Grade Fr · Ramapo | Fr | Ramapo | 4:26.59a PR | 0 |
| 22. | Gavin CasellaPlace 22. · Grade Jr · Montclair State | Jr | Montclair State | 4:28.19a | 0 |
| 23. | Colin GerbschPlace 23. · Grade Jr · SUNY Oneonta | Jr | SUNY Oneonta | 4:29.32a | 0 |
| 24. | John SwaneyPlace 24. · Grade Fr · Ramapo | Fr | Ramapo | 4:31.67a PR | 0 |
| 25. | Evan MillerPlace 25. · Grade Jr · SUNY New Paltz | Jr | SUNY New Paltz | 4:31.83a | 0 |
| 26. | Prince CopelandPlace 26. · Grade Sr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Sr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 4:33.08a | 0 |
| 27. | Aidan NelsonPlace 27. · Grade Sr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Sr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 4:33.29a PR | 0 |
| 28. | Nicholas MarksPlace 28. · Grade So · SUNY Delhi | So | SUNY Delhi | 4:33.83a | 0 |
| 29. | Vincent DiStefanoPlace 29. · Grade So · SUNY Oneonta | So | SUNY Oneonta | 4:36.01a | 0 |
| 30. | Anson NgPlace 30. · Grade Fr · SUNY Delhi | Fr | SUNY Delhi | 4:37.19a | 0 |
| 31. | Ayotunde OyodelePlace 31. · Grade So · Essex County (NJ) | So | Essex County (NJ) | 4:39.14a PR | 0 |
| 32. | Will KanePlace 32. · Grade Fr · SUNY Oneonta | Fr | SUNY Oneonta | 4:39.66a | 0 |
| 33. | Isaiah KirkPlace 33. · Grade Fr · SUNY Delhi | Fr | SUNY Delhi | 4:40.31a | 0 |
| 34. | Jake CookPlace 34. · Grade Fr · SUNY Delhi | Fr | SUNY Delhi | 4:41.12a | 0 |
| 35. | William BarryPlace 35. · Grade Fr · Union (N.Y.) | Fr | Union (N.Y.) | 4:41.66a | 0 |
| 36. | Kyle KoenigPlace 36. · Grade Sr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Sr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 4:42.65a | 0 |
| 37. | William ShermanPlace 37. · Grade Fr · SUNY Oneonta | Fr | SUNY Oneonta | 4:43.46a | 0 |
| 38. | John AbadPlace 38. · Grade Fr · Molloy | Fr | Molloy | 4:45.06a PR | 0 |
| 39. | Jehu ErmilusPlace 39. · Grade Sr · Staten Island | Sr | Staten Island | 4:45.49a | 0 |
| 40. | Kyle RolffotPlace 40. · Grade Fr · Rutgers-Newark | Fr | Rutgers-Newark | 4:45.98a | 0 |
| 41. | Will PlantePlace 41. · Grade Sr · Union (N.Y.) | Sr | Union (N.Y.) | 4:46.96a | 0 |
| 42. | Ezekiel DeMercurioPlace 42. · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 4:47.52a | 0 |
| 43. | Walter GavilanesPlace 43. · Grade So · Staten Island | So | Staten Island | 4:51.11a | 0 |
| 44. | Benjamin VasquezPlace 44. · Grade Fr · Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | 4:52.97a | 0 |
| 45. | Brayden MercierPlace 45. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:53.05a | 0 |
| 46. | Zachary DertingerPlace 46. · Grade Jr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Jr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 4:56.05a | 0 |
| 47. | Landon GravesPlace 47. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 4:56.62a | 0 |
| 48. | Chris CarcichPlace 48. · Grade - · Unattached | - | Unattached | 4:58.81a PR | 0 |
| 49. | Daniel CortezPlace 49. · Grade Sr · Rutgers-Newark | Sr | Rutgers-Newark | 5:01.90a | 0 |
| 50. | Leo RosasPlace 50. · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 5:05.67a | 0 |
| 51. | Matthew AmatoPlace 51. · Grade Sr · Staten Island | Sr | Staten Island | 5:11.50a | 0 |
| 52. | John PiangozzaPlace 52. · Grade So · Merchant Marine Academy | So | Merchant Marine Academy | 5:13.14a | 0 |
| 53. | Miles GravittPlace 53. · Grade Fr · Merchant Marine Academy | Fr | Merchant Marine Academy | 5:21.83a | 0 |
| 54. | Eslian Henriquez FloresPlace 54. · Grade Jr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Jr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 5:25.18a | 0 |
| 55. | Kevin AndrewsPlace 55. · Grade Jr · Albany Pharmacy (N.Y.) | Jr | Albany Pharmacy (N.Y.) | 5:25.38a | 0 |
| 56. | Luke SkardinskiPlace 56. · Grade So · St. Thomas Aquinas | So | St. Thomas Aquinas | 5:38.72a | 0 |
| 57. | Jeremiah DownerPlace 57. · Grade So · Staten Island | So | Staten Island | 5:40.20a PR | 0 |
| 58. | Peter ChryslerPlace 58. · Grade Fr · Void | Fr | Void | 5:40.99a PR | 0 |
| 59. | Daniel RoachPlace 59. · Grade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 5:44.57a PR | 0 |
| 60. | Joseph CarmonaPlace 60. · Grade Jr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Jr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 5:45.88a | 0 |
| 61. | Daniel LePlace 61. · Grade Jr · Albany Pharmacy (N.Y.) | Jr | Albany Pharmacy (N.Y.) | 6:10.61a PR | 0 |
| — | Colby MicheelsGrade Jr · Manhattan University | Jr | Manhattan University | DNS | 0 |
| — | Goncalo CarvalhoGrade So · Void | So | Void | DNS | 0 |
| — | Alexander ColangeloGrade Fr · Union (N.Y.) | Fr | Union (N.Y.) | DNS | 0 |
| — | Thomas LaphamGrade So · Union (N.Y.) | So | Union (N.Y.) | DNS | 0 |
| — | Ian ForsythGrade Jr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Jr | St. Thomas Aquinas | DNS | 0 |
| — | Danny WilsonGrade Fr · Void | Fr | Void | DNS | 0 |
| — | Oscar VazquezGrade Fr · BMCC | Fr | BMCC | DNS | 0 |
