| 1 | David SpandorferPlace 1 · Washington U. | — | Washington U. | 4:25.10 |
| 2 | Eric ClarkPlace 2 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 4:27.90 |
| 3 | Guy VandermostenPlace 3 · Bellarmine | — | Bellarmine | 4:31.51 |
| 4 | Cody BeattyPlace 4 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 4:33.46 |
| 5 | Josh DeatonPlace 5 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 4:34.66 |
| 6 | Alden BlackPlace 6 · Washington U. | — | Washington U. | 4:34.99 |
| 7 | Erik HinrichsenPlace 7 · Washington U. | — | Washington U. | 4:38.42 |
| 8 | Geoff BirdPlace 8 · Monmouth (Ill.) | — | Monmouth (Ill.) | 4:40.04 |
| 9 | Mark HandelmanPlace 9 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 4:40.42 |
| 10 | Lucas WarthPlace 10 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 4:40.98 |
| 11 | Robert McMillanPlace 11 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 4:44.58 |
| 12 | Aaron WeidmanPlace 12 · Washington U. | — | Washington U. | 4:47.84 |
| 13 | Will HawesPlace 13 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 4:50.80 |
| 14 | Kevin OppPlace 14 · Washington U. | — | Washington U. | 4:51.43 |
| 15 | Derek HarrisPlace 15 · Marian (Ind.) | — | Marian (Ind.) | 4:53.00 |
| 16 | Chad BowlingPlace 16 · Bellarmine | — | Bellarmine | 4:53.57 |
| 17 | Alan RosiquezPlace 17 · Monmouth (Ill.) | — | Monmouth (Ill.) | 4:56.37 |
| 18 | Steve BrunsonPlace 18 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 4:57.64 |
| 19 | Dean RothenbergerPlace 19 · Marian (Ind.) | — | Marian (Ind.) | 5:04.43 |
| 20 | Nick SeftonPlace 20 · Marian (Ind.) | — | Marian (Ind.) | 5:08.91 |
| 21 | Terrell BrownPlace 21 · Bellarmine | — | Bellarmine | 5:13.01 |
| 22 | Daniel WolfePlace 22 · Rhodes | — | Rhodes | 5:15.63 |
| 23 | Matt DeCossePlace 23 · Millikin | — | Millikin | 5:16.64 |
| 24 | Matt TaylorPlace 24 · Millikin | — | Millikin | 5:17.49 |