| 1 | Faith SherrillPlace 1 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 163-00 |
| 2 | Kami KlopfensteinPlace 2 · Illinois State | — | Illinois State | 152-05 |
| 3 | Tori ZieglerPlace 3 · Illinois State | — | Illinois State | 148-04 |
| 3 | Kelly AshPlace 3 · Ashland | — | Ashland | 148-04 |
| 5 | Jamie SmithPlace 5 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 147-10 |
| 6 | Emily OvermyerPlace 6 · Dayton | — | Dayton | 147-06 |
| 7 | Kelsey HanleyPlace 7 · Indiana State | — | Indiana State | 144-11 |
| 8 | Andrea HorbanPlace 8 · Indianapolis | — | Indianapolis | 139-05 |
| 9 | Courtney KuzmiczPlace 9 · Indianapolis | — | Indianapolis | 138-09 |
| 10 | Mallory BarnesPlace 10 · Dayton | — | Dayton | 136-05 |
| 11 | Tara CooperPlace 11 · Ashland | — | Ashland | 135-07 |
| 12 | Mackenzie CutterPlace 12 · Indiana | — | Indiana | 133-11 |
| 13 | Alexandra RobertsPlace 13 · Miami (Ohio) | — | Miami (Ohio) | 131-00 |
| 14 | Jessic RutherfordPlace 14 · Grand Valley St. | — | Grand Valley St. | 130-00 |
| 15 | Erin LinesPlace 15 · Findlay | — | Findlay | 127-09 |
| 16 | Amy SchmitzPlace 16 · Indianapolis | — | Indianapolis | 123-08 |
| 17 | meghan kesslerPlace 17 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 122-10 |
| 18 | Molly McCartyPlace 18 · Dayton | — | Dayton | 122-05 |
| 19 | Katelyn FoxPlace 19 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 120-06 |
| 20 | Danielle PetersPlace 20 · Findlay | — | Findlay | 119-09 |
| 21 | Samantha GablePlace 21 · Miami (Ohio) | — | Miami (Ohio) | 118-11 |
| 22 | Tyra SchantzPlace 22 · Ball State | — | Ball State | 116-09 |
| 23 | Tara PerigoPlace 23 · Indiana State | — | Indiana State | 115-11 |
| 24 | Jenny SavickasPlace 24 · Let It Fly Throwing | — | Let It Fly Throwing | 115-08 |
| 25 | Bellosie FrazierPlace 25 · Vincennes | — | Vincennes | 115-07 |
| 26 | Katie SopherPlace 26 · Ashland | — | Ashland | 114-06 |
| 27 | Lauren CleaverPlace 27 · Ball State | — | Ball State | 114-04 |
| 28 | Rachel BilekPlace 28 · Marshall | — | Marshall | 113-04 |
| 29 | Deanna RippyPlace 29 · Cincinnati | — | Cincinnati | 111-11 |
| 30 | Katie AndersonPlace 30 · Xavier (Ohio) | — | Xavier (Ohio) | 108-02 |
| 31 | Melanie HuhnPlace 31 · Grand Valley St. | — | Grand Valley St. | 106-00 |
| 32 | Elizabet ChandlerPlace 32 · Vincennes | — | Vincennes | 103-05 |
| 33 | Kayla KingPlace 33 · Ashland | — | Ashland | 102-03 |
| 34 | Catherine EarlPlace 34 · Cincinnati | — | Cincinnati | 100-03 |
| 35 | Rachel WalkerPlace 35 · Rio Grande | — | Rio Grande | 100-00 |
| 36 | Lauren BureshPlace 36 · Grand Valley St. | — | Grand Valley St. | 98-03 |
| 37 | Julie FlowersPlace 37 · Valparaiso | — | Valparaiso | 96-00 |
| 38 | Sarah BakerPlace 38 · Indiana State | — | Indiana State | 94-09 |
| 39 | Natal McCorristonPlace 39 · Valparaiso | — | Valparaiso | 94-06 |
| 40 | Megan WolfePlace 40 · Indianapolis | — | Indianapolis | 92-11 |
| 41 | Julia ZalewskiPlace 41 · Bellarmine | — | Bellarmine | 90-02 |
| 42 | Kayla RollinsPlace 42 · Indiana State | — | Indiana State | 88-08 |
| 43 | Jessica HuffPlace 43 · Indianapolis | — | Indianapolis | 81-11 |
| 44 | Reghann CovertPlace 44 · Bellarmine | — | Bellarmine | 74-10 |
| — | Kriste Gilgenbach · Cincinnati | — | Cincinnati | FOUL |