| 1. | Alex GarbierPlace 1. · Grade Jr · ChicagoUnofficial | Jr | Chicago | 4:00.73a | 10 |
| 2. | Joe SullivanPlace 2. · Grade Fr · ChicagoUnofficial | Fr | Chicago | 4:00.94a PR | 8 |
| 3. | Micah LorenzenPlace 3. · Grade Sr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Sr | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:03.86a PR | 6 |
| 4. | Pat AustinPlace 4. · Grade Jr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Jr | Elmhurst | 4:04.82a PR | 5 |
| 5. | Connor BoushonPlace 5. · Grade Fr · EdgewoodUnofficial | Fr | Edgewood | 4:06.39a | 4 |
| 6. | Felipe Fernandez Del CastilloPlace 6. · Grade Fr · ChicagoUnofficial | Fr | Chicago | 4:06.84a | 3 |
| 7. | Nicholas NunezPlace 7. · Grade So · ChicagoUnofficial | So | Chicago | 4:07.79a PR | 2 |
| 8. | Alex AgafonovPlace 8. · Grade Fr · Oakton (Ill.) CCUnofficial | Fr | Oakton (Ill.) CC | 4:10.62a PR | 1 |
| 9. | Matt ZaluckyjPlace 9. · Grade Fr · Illinois ChicagoUnofficial | Fr | Illinois Chicago | 4:10.85a | — |
| 10. | Jason SmithPlace 10. · Grade Fr · RiponUnofficial | Fr | Ripon | 4:11.36a | — |
| 11. | Alex ArmanPlace 11. · Grade Jr · Benedictine (Ill.)Unofficial | Jr | Benedictine (Ill.) | 4:13.11a | — |
| 12. | David YuPlace 12. · Grade Sr · ChicagoUnofficial | Sr | Chicago | 4:13.59a PR | — |
| 13. | Matt LumnitzerPlace 13. · Grade Fr · Illinois TechUnofficial | Fr | Illinois Tech | 4:13.74a PR | — |
| 54. | Jon GoesellPlace 54. · Grade So · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | So | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:14:48a PR | — |
| 14. | AJ ThewPlace 14. · Grade Fr · RiponUnofficial | Fr | Ripon | 4:14.13a | — |
| 15. | Kevin DockemeyerPlace 15. · Grade Sr · LewisUnofficial | Sr | Lewis | 4:14.76a PR | — |
| 16. | Dakota WestPlace 16. · Grade Jr · Judson (Ill.)Unofficial | Jr | Judson (Ill.) | 4:15.91a PR | — |
| 17. | Seth WinniePlace 17. · Grade Sr · ChicagoUnofficial | Sr | Chicago | 4:16.03a | — |
| 18. | Joseph PlinerPlace 18. · Grade Fr · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | Fr | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:16.22a | — |
| 19. | Jeffrey CampPlace 19. · Grade Fr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Fr | Elmhurst | 4:17.01a PR | — |
| 20. | Eric KoenigPlace 20. · Grade Fr · BeloitUnofficial | Fr | Beloit | 4:17.59a PR | — |
| 55. | Anthony AJ SobrilskyPlace 55. · Grade Jr · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | Jr | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:18:30a PR | — |
| 56. | Bob SpelichPlace 56. · Grade Sr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Sr | Elmhurst | 4:18:34a | — |
| 21. | Ian JarvisPlace 21. · Grade So · BeloitUnofficial | So | Beloit | 4:19.09a PR | — |
| 22. | William UffenbeckPlace 22. · Grade Sr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Sr | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:19.85a PR | — |
| 57. | Tyler MendenhallPlace 57. · Grade Fr · RockfordUnofficial | Fr | Rockford | 4:20:01a PR | — |
| 23. | Jeff GagePlace 23. · Grade Jr · BeloitUnofficial | Jr | Beloit | 4:21.17a PR | — |
| 58. | Robert AltenburgerPlace 58. · Grade Fr · Judson (Ill.)Unofficial | Fr | Judson (Ill.) | 4:22:35a PR | — |
| 24. | Robert CooperPlace 24. · Grade Fr · ChicagoUnofficial | Fr | Chicago | 4:22.36a | — |
| 59. | Derrick PadovichPlace 59. · Grade Jr · AuroraUnofficial | Jr | Aurora | 4:23:27a PR | — |
| 60. | Nathan SellingPlace 60. · Grade Fr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Fr | Elmhurst | 4:23:57a | — |
| 61. | Todd ByrnePlace 61. · Grade Fr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Fr | Elmhurst | 4:25:10a PR | — |
| 25. | Peter ZanderPlace 25. · Grade Fr · EdgewoodUnofficial | Fr | Edgewood | 4:25.63a | — |
| 26. | Kyle JulianPlace 26. · Grade Fr · Judson (Ill.)Unofficial | Fr | Judson (Ill.) | 4:25.97a | — |
| 62. | Kaleb NyquistPlace 62. · Grade Fr · North ParkUnofficial | Fr | North Park | 4:26:16a PR | — |
| 27. | Travis ShepherdPlace 27. · Grade Sr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Sr | Elmhurst | 4:26.21a PR | — |
| 63. | Ben PapePlace 63. · Grade Fr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Fr | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:27:20a | — |
| 64. | Andrew DunhamPlace 64. · Grade Jr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Jr | Elmhurst | 4:27:38a PR | — |
| 65. | Randy EbertPlace 65. · Grade Jr · RockfordUnofficial | Jr | Rockford | 4:27:48a | — |
| 28. | Mark AkinsPlace 28. · Grade Jr · AuroraUnofficial | Jr | Aurora | 4:27.58a PR | — |
| 29. | Danny GrahamPlace 29. · Grade Fr · Benedictine (Ill.)Unofficial | Fr | Benedictine (Ill.) | 4:27.99a | — |
| 66. | Ryan HanusPlace 66. · Grade Fr · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | Fr | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:28:23a | — |
| 67. | Brian RobbinsPlace 67. · Grade Jr · Illinois TechUnofficial | Jr | Illinois Tech | 4:29:41a PR | — |
| 68. | Derek KieningerPlace 68. · Grade Jr · Concordia ChicagoUnofficial | Jr | Concordia Chicago | 4:30:30a PR | — |
| 30. | Justin EshlemanPlace 30. · Grade Jr · Illinois TechUnofficial | Jr | Illinois Tech | 4:30.55a PR | — |
| 31. | James MumfordPlace 31. · Grade So · ChicagoUnofficial | So | Chicago | 4:32.39a | — |
| 32. | Francisco LangnerPlace 32. · Grade Fr · EdgewoodUnofficial | Fr | Edgewood | 4:33.17a PR | — |
| 33. | Tommy FergusonPlace 33. · Grade Sr · AuroraUnofficial | Sr | Aurora | 4:34.74a | — |
| 34. | Jon OldenburgPlace 34. · Grade Fr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Fr | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:35.80a | — |
| 35. | Joseph ZambettiPlace 35. · Grade Fr · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | Fr | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:36.07a | — |
| 36. | Ciaran ShaugnhessyPlace 36. · Grade Fr · Illinois TechUnofficial | Fr | Illinois Tech | 4:39.24a PR | — |
| 37. | Andy AndersonPlace 37. · Grade Jr · Judson (Ill.)Unofficial | Jr | Judson (Ill.) | 4:40.84a | — |
| 38. | David GrayPlace 38. · Grade So · RockfordUnofficial | So | Rockford | 4:43.72a | — |
| 39. | Chris HoffmanPlace 39. · Grade Fr · Harper (Ill.)Unofficial | Fr | Harper (Ill.) | 4:43.79a | — |
| 41. | Matt DeBallPlace 41. · Grade Fr · Judson (Ill.)Unofficial | Fr | Judson (Ill.) | 4:46.09a | — |
| 42. | Richard ThompsonPlace 42. · Grade So · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | So | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:51.68a | — |
| 43. | Steve EssigPlace 43. · Grade Jr · Benedictine (Ill.)Unofficial | Jr | Benedictine (Ill.) | 4:55.59a PR | — |
| 44. | Jacob WilliamsPlace 44. · Grade Fr · BeloitUnofficial | Fr | Beloit | 4:57.06a | — |
| 45. | Kris BeckPlace 45. · Grade Fr · ElmhurstUnofficial | Fr | Elmhurst | 5:01.45a PR | — |
| 46. | Josh WeberPlace 46. · Grade Sr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Sr | Concordia Wisconsin | 5:04.34a PR | — |
| 47. | Jesus AguilarPlace 47. · Grade So · AuroraUnofficial | So | Aurora | 5:05.35a | — |
| 48. | Justin KoepsellPlace 48. · Grade Fr · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | Fr | Carroll (Wis.) | 5:05.39a | — |
| 49. | Paul GawlasPlace 49. · Grade Jr · Dominican (Ill.)Unofficial | Jr | Dominican (Ill.) | 5:06.70a PR | — |
| 50. | Evan BoylePlace 50. · Grade Fr · BeloitUnofficial | Fr | Beloit | 5:25.24a PR | — |
| 51. | Nathan PritzkerPlace 51. · Grade Fr · EurekaUnofficial | Fr | Eureka | 5:34.80a | — |
| 52. | Jason ListPlace 52. · Grade Jr · EurekaUnofficial | Jr | Eureka | 5:41.47a PR | — |
| 53. | Jordan JessePlace 53. · Grade Sr · EurekaUnofficial | Sr | Eureka | 5:46.98a | — |