| 1. | Paul HetkePlace 1. · Grade Fr · UW-Eau ClaireUnofficial | Fr | UW-Eau Claire | 4:20.14a | 10 |
| 2. | Brent KannPlace 2. · Grade Sr · UW-Eau ClaireUnofficial | Sr | UW-Eau Claire | 4:20.94a | 8 |
| 3. | Jared BrandenburgPlace 3. · Grade So · UW-River FallsUnofficial | So | UW-River Falls | 4:21.12a | 6 |
| 4. | Adam FlytePlace 4. · Grade Sr · UW-Eau ClaireUnofficial | Sr | UW-Eau Claire | 4:21.83a | 5 |
| 5. | Scott DegnerPlace 5. · Grade Sr · UW-River FallsUnofficial | Sr | UW-River Falls | 4:22.42a | 4 |
| 6. | Derek NechutaPlace 6. · Grade Jr · UW-Stevens PointUnofficial | Jr | UW-Stevens Point | 4:22.55a | 3 |
| 7. | Andrew AshendenPlace 7. · Grade So · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | So | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:23.69a | 2 |
| 8. | Josh WilliamsPlace 8. · Grade Fr · EdgewoodUnofficial | Fr | Edgewood | 4:25.05a | 1 |
| 9. | River KarlPlace 9. · WI Track CluUnofficial | — | WI Track Clu | 4:25.11a | — |
| 10. | Jake ZanderPlace 10. · Grade Fr · UW-Eau ClaireUnofficial | Fr | UW-Eau Claire | 4:26.87a | — |
| 11. | Adam SteinkePlace 11. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 4:27.25a | — |
| 12. | Logan SeipelPlace 12. · Grade Fr · UW-Stevens PointUnofficial | Fr | UW-Stevens Point | 4:28.17a | — |
| 13. | Sam StevensPlace 13. · Grade Fr · LawrenceUnofficial | Fr | Lawrence | 4:29.55a | — |
| 14. | Jared JohnstonPlace 14. · Grade So · Minnesota DuluthUnofficial | So | Minnesota Duluth | 4:30.51a PR | — |
| 15. | Travis NechutaPlace 15. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 4:30.90a | — |
| 16. | Michael BorglinPlace 16. · Grade So · UW-Eau ClaireUnofficial | So | UW-Eau Claire | 4:31.66a | — |
| 17. | Connor BoushonPlace 17. · Grade So · EdgewoodUnofficial | So | Edgewood | 4:32.94a | — |
| 18. | Mark SpitelPlace 18. · Grade Sr · LawrenceUnofficial | Sr | Lawrence | 4:35.74a PR | — |
| 19. | Ryan EasonPlace 19. · Grade Fr · Minnesota DuluthUnofficial | Fr | Minnesota Duluth | 4:35.79a | — |
| 20. | Joseph PlinerPlace 20. · Grade So · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | So | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:38.32a | — |
| 21. | Ryan HanusPlace 21. · Grade So · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | So | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:41.02a | — |
| 22. | Sam KeepmanPlace 22. · WI Track CluUnofficial | — | WI Track Clu | 4:43.34a | — |
| 23. | Robert KostickPlace 23. · Grade Fr · Minnesota DuluthUnofficial | Fr | Minnesota Duluth | 4:45.37a | — |
| 24. | Keenan UnangstPlace 24. · Grade Jr · MSOEUnofficial | Jr | MSOE | 4:46.28a PR | — |
| 25. | Daniel FechtPlace 25. · Grade So · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | So | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:49.06a | — |
| 26. | Kevin MeyerPlace 26. · Grade So · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | So | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:49.65a | — |
| 27. | Ben PapePlace 27. · Grade So · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | So | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:50.94a | — |
| 28. | Lucas PfaffenrothPlace 28. · Grade Jr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Jr | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:51.11a PR | — |
| 29. | Matt MixdorfPlace 29. · WI Track CluUnofficial | — | WI Track Clu | 4:51.60a | — |
| 30. | Dustin WentlandPlace 30. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 4:52.23a | — |
| 31. | Matt HoffmanPlace 31. · Grade Jr · Carroll (Wis.)Unofficial | Jr | Carroll (Wis.) | 4:53.38a | — |
| 32. | Eric WoodPlace 32. · Grade So · CoeUnofficial | So | Coe | 4:56.82a | — |
| 33. | Andrew PfeufferPlace 33. · Grade So · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | So | Concordia Wisconsin | 4:57.45a PR | — |
| 34. | Michael OlkPlace 34. · Grade So · MSOEUnofficial | So | MSOE | 5:00.72a PR | — |
| 35. | kevin DonovanPlace 35. · Grade - · Northern MichiganUnofficial | - | Northern Michigan | 5:01.41a | — |
| 36. | Michael UffenbeckPlace 36. · Grade Fr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Fr | Concordia Wisconsin | 5:05.04a PR | — |
| 37. | Chris ReichardPlace 37. · Grade Sr · MSOEUnofficial | Sr | MSOE | 5:07.05a PR | — |
| 38. | Daniel KlienowskiPlace 38. · Grade So · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | So | Concordia Wisconsin | 5:07.12a PR | — |
| 39. | Matthew JungersPlace 39. · Grade Jr · MSOEUnofficial | Jr | MSOE | 5:07.34a | — |
| 40. | Eddie BollmanPlace 40. · Grade - · Northern MichiganUnofficial | - | Northern Michigan | 5:10.81a PR | — |
| 41. | Jon OldenburgPlace 41. · Grade So · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | So | Concordia Wisconsin | 5:11.31a | — |
| 42. | Freddy FrickPlace 42. · Grade Jr · DubuqueUnofficial | Jr | Dubuque | 5:22.30a | — |
| 43. | David UffenbeckPlace 43. · Grade Jr · Concordia WisconsinUnofficial | Jr | Concordia Wisconsin | 5:44.89a | — |
| -- | Alex NicholsPlace -- · Grade So · UW-River Falls | So | UW-River Falls | DNF | — |
| -- | Dillon JohnstonPlace -- · Grade Jr · Minnesota Duluth | Jr | Minnesota Duluth | DNF | — |
| -- | Nick SchaeferPlace -- · Grade Jr · UW-Stevens Point | Jr | UW-Stevens Point | DNF | — |