| -- | Nate JenkinsPlace -- · UNATTACHEDUnofficial | — | UNATTACHED | 4:17.91a | — |
| 1. | Billy HalePlace 1. · Grade Sr · TuftsUnofficial | Sr | Tufts | 4:18.97a PR | 10 |
| 2. | Matt TirrellPlace 2. · Grade Sr · TuftsUnofficial | Sr | Tufts | 4:24.39a PR | 8 |
| 3. | Greg WilsonPlace 3. · Grade Jr · UMass LowellUnofficial | Jr | UMass Lowell | 4:25.50a | 6 |
| 4. | Jeffrey RagazziniPlace 4. · Grade Jr · TuftsUnofficial | Jr | Tufts | 4:26.81a | 5 |
| 5. | Kyle MarksPlace 5. · Grade Fr · TuftsUnofficial | Fr | Tufts | 4:28.03a | 4 |
| 6. | Samuel HaneyPlace 6. · Grade Fr · TuftsUnofficial | Fr | Tufts | 4:28.37a | 3 |
| 7. | Eric MacknightPlace 7. · Grade Jr · Keene StateUnofficial | Jr | Keene State | 4:31.60a | 2 |
| 8. | Jeffrey MarvelPlace 8. · Grade Fr · TuftsUnofficial | Fr | Tufts | 4:32.26a PR | 1 |
| 9. | Jared SamuelPlace 9. · Grade Sr · Keene StateUnofficial | Sr | Keene State | 4:34.02a | — |
| 10. | Lucas MaherPlace 10. · Grade Fr · TuftsUnofficial | Fr | Tufts | 4:34.13a PR | — |
| 11. | Stephen O'BrienPlace 11. · Grade Sr · UMass LowellUnofficial | Sr | UMass Lowell | 4:36.69a PR | — |
| 12. | Erik Dunn-GaudetPlace 12. · Grade Fr · UMass LowellUnofficial | Fr | UMass Lowell | 4:37.13a | — |
| 13. | Brendan DevlinPlace 13. · Grade Fr · UMass LowellUnofficial | Fr | UMass Lowell | 4:38.31a PR | — |
| 14. | Dan TheleenPlace 14. · Grade Jr · Keene StateUnofficial | Jr | Keene State | 4:39.40a PR | — |
| -- | Jeff GoupilPlace -- · UNATTACHEDUnofficial | — | UNATTACHED | 4:41.36a | — |
| 15. | Thomas PaquettePlace 15. · Grade Fr · Keene StateUnofficial | Fr | Keene State | 4:42.48a | — |
| 16. | Timothy PippPlace 16. · Grade Jr · Keene StateUnofficial | Jr | Keene State | 4:42.91a | — |
| 17. | Adam BroshPlace 17. · Grade Fr · TuftsUnofficial | Fr | Tufts | 4:43.10a | — |
| 18. | David BerubePlace 18. · Grade Fr · Keene StateUnofficial | Fr | Keene State | 4:43.12a PR | — |
| 19. | Chris KiblerPlace 19. · Grade So · Fitchburg StateUnofficial | So | Fitchburg State | 4:43.95a | — |
| 20. | Alex DrobyPlace 20. · Grade Fr · Worcester StateUnofficial | Fr | Worcester State | 4:44.06a | — |
| 21. | Matt SpanoPlace 21. · Grade Jr · Fitchburg StateUnofficial | Jr | Fitchburg State | 4:44.28a | — |
| 22. | Nicholas FerrentinoPlace 22. · Grade Fr · TuftsUnofficial | Fr | Tufts | 4:46.07a | — |
| 23. | Kyle SchaefferPlace 23. · Grade Sr · Fitchburg StateUnofficial | Sr | Fitchburg State | 4:46.29a | — |
| 24. | Brendan BlaneyPlace 24. · Grade Jr · TuftsUnofficial | Jr | Tufts | 4:48.40a | — |
| 25. | William LaryPlace 25. · Grade Fr · Fitchburg StateUnofficial | Fr | Fitchburg State | 4:50.13a | — |
| 26. | Alex PerryPlace 26. · Grade Jr · Keene StateUnofficial | Jr | Keene State | 4:50.31a | — |
| 27. | Brenden GuineePlace 27. · Grade Fr · UMass LowellUnofficial | Fr | UMass Lowell | 4:54.51a | — |
| 28. | Andrew PottorfPlace 28. · Grade So · Gordon (Mass.)Unofficial | So | Gordon (Mass.) | 4:55.06a PR | — |
| 29. | Michael GraselaPlace 29. · Grade Fr · Fitchburg StateUnofficial | Fr | Fitchburg State | 5:00.06a | — |
| 30. | George StevensPlace 30. · Grade Jr · Keene StateUnofficial | Jr | Keene State | 5:07.68a | — |
| 31. | Tim MazeikaPlace 31. · Grade Fr · Worcester StateUnofficial | Fr | Worcester State | 5:10.27a | — |
| 32. | Justin HuntPlace 32. · Grade Jr · Worcester StateUnofficial | Jr | Worcester State | 5:12.17a | — |
| 33. | Justin DeRosaPlace 33. · Grade Jr · Salem StateUnofficial | Jr | Salem State | 5:21.05a | — |
| 34. | Eric ThulinPlace 34. · Grade So · Worcester StateUnofficial | So | Worcester State | 5:43.78a | — |