| 1 | Deshawn DouglasPlace 1 · Grade Sr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Sr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 26:14.3 PR |
| 2 | Ronaldo Rodriguez-PerezPlace 2 · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 27:32.9 |
| 3 | Pedro Mulero-MartinezPlace 3 · Grade Sr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Sr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 27:33.2 PR |
| 4 | Aidan NelsonPlace 4 · Grade Sr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Sr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 28:15.4 PR |
| 5 | William WhittonPlace 5 · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 28:16.1 |
| 6 | Colin GrahamPlace 6 · Grade So · St. Thomas Aquinas | So | St. Thomas Aquinas | 29:00.8 |
| 7 | Hengzhi ZhuPlace 7 · Grade Sr · Hunter | Sr | Hunter | 29:12.1 PR |
| 8 | Kyle KoenigPlace 8 · Grade Sr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Sr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 29:29.9 |
| 9 | John CiuffoPlace 9 · Grade Sr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Sr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 29:34.9 |
| 10 | William FernandezPlace 10 · Grade So · BMCC | So | BMCC | 30:10.9 |
| 11 | Eslian Henriquez FloresPlace 11 · Grade Jr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Jr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 30:51.0 PR |
| 12 | Jack TreacherPlace 12 · Grade Jr · Hunter | Jr | Hunter | 30:58.3 |
| 13 | Jude PetersenPlace 13 · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 31:04.2 |
| 14 | Zachary DertingerPlace 14 · Grade Jr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Jr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 31:17.6 PR |
| 15 | Prince CopelandPlace 15 · Grade Sr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Sr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 31:21.1 |
| 16 | Henry MasciaPlace 16 · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 31:26.9 |
| 17 | Brian AriasPlace 17 · Grade Fr · Hunter | Fr | Hunter | 32:48.2 |
| 18 | William KellyPlace 18 · Grade Jr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Jr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 32:59.0 PR |
| 19 | Robert Liang-XUPlace 19 · Grade Fr · Hunter | Fr | Hunter | 33:00.8 |
| 20 | Thomas Black IVPlace 20 · Grade Fr · BMCC | Fr | BMCC | 33:13.1 |
| 21 | David CastroPlace 21 · Grade Jr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Jr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 33:22.3 |
| 22 | Sam Anthony SamalaPlace 22 · Grade Jr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Jr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 33:36.6 |
| 23 | Barron SefaPlace 23 · Grade So · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | So | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 33:52.4 PR |
| 24 | Daniel FitzgeraldPlace 24 · Grade Sr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Sr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 34:00.3 PR |
| 25 | Leo RosasPlace 25 · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 34:38.2 |
| 26 | Erick SolizPlace 26 · Grade Fr · Westchester CC (NY) | Fr | Westchester CC (NY) | 34:53.1 |
| 27 | William StaackPlace 27 · Grade Jr · Mount Saint Vincent | Jr | Mount Saint Vincent | 34:53.2 |
| 28 | Junseo DeschensesPlace 28 · Grade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 34:53.7 |
| 29 | Raeden NievesPlace 29 · Grade Fr · Mount Saint Vincent | Fr | Mount Saint Vincent | 35:11.7 |
| 30 | Robert JacksonPlace 30 · Grade Fr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Fr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 35:14.3 |
| 31 | Joshua KohnPlace 31 · Grade Jr · Yeshiva | Jr | Yeshiva | 35:39.8 PR |
| 32 | Moshe SitzerPlace 32 · Grade So · Yeshiva | So | Yeshiva | 35:53.7 PR |
| 33 | Dalton LigonPlace 33 · Grade So · BMCC | So | BMCC | 36:00.6 |
| 34 | Julian SalcedoPlace 34 · Grade Fr · Westchester CC (NY) | Fr | Westchester CC (NY) | 36:04.9 PR |
| 35 | Luke SkardinskiPlace 35 · Grade So · St. Thomas Aquinas | So | St. Thomas Aquinas | 36:08.0 |
| 36 | Ian ForsythPlace 36 · Grade Jr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Jr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 37:16.2 |
| 37 | Orlando KellyPlace 37 · Grade So · Hostos CC (NY) | So | Hostos CC (NY) | 37:35.1 |
| 38 | Harrison AbarcaPlace 38 · Grade So · Hunter | So | Hunter | 38:00.6 |
| 39 | Gaury ValerioPlace 39 · Grade Fr · BMCC | Fr | BMCC | 38:31.6 |
| 40 | Paul PatinoPlace 40 · Grade So · Hunter | So | Hunter | 38:51.5 |
| 41 | Ryan TurnerPlace 41 · Grade Fr · St. Thomas Aquinas | Fr | St. Thomas Aquinas | 40:34.8 PR |
| 42 | Angel ZabalaPlace 42 · Grade Fr · Hostos CC (NY) | Fr | Hostos CC (NY) | 40:51.9 |
| 43 | Omar DrammehPlace 43 · Grade So · Hostos CC (NY) | So | Hostos CC (NY) | 40:52.3 |
| 44 | Mark Gabriel FarandaPlace 44 · Grade Fr · Westchester CC (NY) | Fr | Westchester CC (NY) | 42:28.9 |
| 45 | Mekell NubePlace 45 · Grade Fr · Westchester CC (NY) | Fr | Westchester CC (NY) | 42:44.1 PR |
| 46 | Hassani BangurahPlace 46 · Grade So · BMCC | So | BMCC | 42:45.0 |
| 47 | Nickoy HenryPlace 47 · Grade Fr · Dominican (N.Y.) | Fr | Dominican (N.Y.) | 44:01.5 |
| 48 | Jonathan WertaPlace 48 · Grade Jr · Yeshiva | Jr | Yeshiva | 44:06.4 |
| 49 | Quacey GaylePlace 49 · Grade Fr · Mount Saint Vincent | Fr | Mount Saint Vincent | 44:36.3 PR |
| 50 | Keith SunPlace 50 · Grade Fr · Hunter | Fr | Hunter | 44:56.0 |
| 51 | Shateek HarrisPlace 51 · Grade So · Hostos CC (NY) | So | Hostos CC (NY) | 50:24.2 |
| 52 | Nygel ReadyPlace 52 · Grade So · Hostos CC (NY) | So | Hostos CC (NY) | 50:24.4 |
| 53 | Shamal JohnsonPlace 53 · Grade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 52:24.8 PR |
| 54 | David DeutschPlace 54 · Grade So · Yeshiva | So | Yeshiva | 52:38.7 |
| 55 | Malik NicholsonPlace 55 · Grade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 52:47.2 PR |
| 56 | Mark KhanPlace 56 · Grade Jr · Mount Saint Vincent | Jr | Mount Saint Vincent | 53:48.6 |
| 57 | Miguel CorderoPlace 57 · Grade Sr · Mount Saint Vincent | Sr | Mount Saint Vincent | 56:41.7 |
| — | Rowan ReidGrade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | NT |
| — | Alexander ShearmanGrade Fr · Hunter | Fr | Hunter | DNF |
| — | Dylan AsuncionGrade Fr · Hunter | Fr | Hunter | NT |
| — | Ben LandheimGrade Sr · Hunter | Sr | Hunter | NT |
| — | Mateo PenafielGrade Sr · Hunter | Sr | Hunter | NT |
| — | Jonathan PosnerGrade Fr · Yeshiva | Fr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Aharon CohenGrade Sr · Yeshiva | Sr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Benjamin CoplinGrade Sr · Yeshiva | Sr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Noah DinerGrade Sr · Yeshiva | Sr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Avishai JutkowitzGrade Jr · Yeshiva | Jr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Daniel LandoGrade Jr · Yeshiva | Jr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Aviel MetzGrade Sr · Yeshiva | Sr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Jacob RabinovitchGrade Jr · Yeshiva | Jr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Seth SchlankGrade So · Yeshiva | So | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Daniel SimonGrade Jr · Yeshiva | Jr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Synatra TarenyikaGrade Sr · Yeshiva | Sr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Shmuel ZifferGrade Sr · Yeshiva | Sr | Yeshiva | NT |
| — | Saikou SanyangGrade Fr · BMCC | Fr | BMCC | DNF |
