| 1 | Dane BenderPlace 1 · Grade Jr · VoidUnofficial | Jr | Void | 12:40.22 PR |
| 2 | Zane BrylinskyPlace 2 · Grade Fr · StevensUnofficial | Fr | Stevens | 12:41.28 PR |
| 3 | Andrew BallingerPlace 3 · Grade So · StevensUnofficial | So | Stevens | 12:42.73 PR |
| 4 | Travis HeithoffPlace 4 · Grade Jr · StevensUnofficial | Jr | Stevens | 13:16.26 PR |
| 5 | Paul GraybealPlace 5 · Grade So · Goldey-BeacomUnofficial | So | Goldey-Beacom | 13:20.36 PR |
| 6 | George AdamsPlace 6 · Grade Sr · VassarUnofficial | Sr | Vassar | 13:22.27 PR |
| 7 | Steve ChickPlace 7 · UnaUnofficial | — | Una | 13:37.84 |
| 8 | Seneca CurryPlace 8 · Grade Sr · Goldey-BeacomUnofficial | Sr | Goldey-Beacom | 13:43.76 PR |
| 9 | Christopher WallacePlace 9 · Grade Fr · StevensUnofficial | Fr | Stevens | 13:49.90 PR |
| 10 | Justin RichmanPlace 10 · Grade Jr · StevensUnofficial | Jr | Stevens | 13:50.29 PR |
| 11 | Sean RichardsPlace 11 · Grade Fr · StevensUnofficial | Fr | Stevens | 13:53.41 PR |
| 12 | Agustin LastraPlace 12 · Grade Jr · BaruchUnofficial | Jr | Baruch | 14:03.56 PR |
| 13 | Nelson LimPlace 13 · Grade So · BaruchUnofficial | So | Baruch | 14:13.80 PR |
| 14 | Kevin MorgeraPlace 14 · Grade Jr · StevensUnofficial | Jr | Stevens | 14:19.36 PR |
| 15 | Ali JafriPlace 15 · Grade Fr · Goldey-BeacomUnofficial | Fr | Goldey-Beacom | 14:21.27 PR |
| 16 | Laramie MillerPlace 16 · Grade RS · US Military Academy PrepUnofficial | RS | US Military Academy Prep | 14:23.75 PR |
| 17 | Rey PerezPlace 17 · Grade Fr · BaruchUnofficial | Fr | Baruch | 14:28.57 PR |
| 18 | Zachary ZeilmanPlace 18 · Grade So · VassarUnofficial | So | Vassar | 14:29.27 PR |
| 19 | Corey GravesPlace 19 · Grade Fr · Rutgers-NewarkUnofficial | Fr | Rutgers-Newark | 14:34.79 |
| 20 | Shamid ParkerPlace 20 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 14:44.10 PR |
| 21 | Rafael RicaurtePlace 21 · Grade Fr · VassarUnofficial | Fr | Vassar | 14:53.36 PR |
| 22 | John MoroniPlace 22 · Grade Jr · BaruchUnofficial | Jr | Baruch | 14:53.90 PR |
| 23 | Javier BosquePlace 23 · Grade Fr · St. Joseph's (Brooklyn)Unofficial | Fr | St. Joseph's (Brooklyn) | 14:54.20 PR |
| 24 | Justin BookerPlace 24 · Grade Jr · Rutgers-NewarkUnofficial | Jr | Rutgers-Newark | 15:02.18 PR |
| 25 | Richard MayorgaPlace 25 · Grade RS · US Military Academy PrepUnofficial | RS | US Military Academy Prep | 15:02.99 PR |
| 26 | Donel N FernandosPlace 26 · Grade Fr · Monroe University (NY)Unofficial | Fr | Monroe University (NY) | 15:08.93 PR |
| 27 | Andrew AzabPlace 27 · Grade Fr · Rutgers-NewarkUnofficial | Fr | Rutgers-Newark | 15:10.78 PR |
| 28 | Macalbert JeantusPlace 28 · Grade Fr · Rutgers-NewarkUnofficial | Fr | Rutgers-Newark | 15:16.38 PR |
| 29 | Garcia FrancisPlace 29 · Grade So · StevensUnofficial | So | Stevens | 15:27.05 PR |
| 30 | Zach TaylorPlace 30 · Grade RS · US Military Academy PrepUnofficial | RS | US Military Academy Prep | 15:45.12 PR |
| 31 | Edward HanPlace 31 · Grade Jr · St. Joseph's (Brooklyn)Unofficial | Jr | St. Joseph's (Brooklyn) | 15:59.35 PR |
| 32 | Sidney MabeyaPlace 32 · Grade Jr · VoidUnofficial | Jr | Void | 16:03.00 PR |
| 33 | Kenneth RieneckerPlace 33 · Grade Sr · Rutgers-NewarkUnofficial | Sr | Rutgers-Newark | 16:11.80 PR |
| 34 | Christian CoxPlace 34 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 16:14.21 PR |
| 35 | Kenneth RicePlace 35 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 16:17.31 PR |
| 36 | Evan BaytopsPlace 36 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 16:26.76 PR |
| 37 | Demetris HardingPlace 37 · Grade So · Goldey-BeacomUnofficial | So | Goldey-Beacom | 16:27.94 PR |
| 38 | Nnaemeka IbehPlace 38 · Grade Jr · Rutgers-NewarkUnofficial | Jr | Rutgers-Newark | 16:30.34 PR |
| 39 | Hakiem GeorgePlace 39 · Grade Sr · SUNY Old WestburyUnofficial | Sr | SUNY Old Westbury | 16:33.57 PR |
| 40 | Lew MonacoPlace 40 · Grade Sr · St. Joseph's (Brooklyn)Unofficial | Sr | St. Joseph's (Brooklyn) | 16:34.55 PR |
| 41 | Brad NeatonPlace 41 · Grade RS · US Military Academy PrepUnofficial | RS | US Military Academy Prep | 16:35.57 PR |
| 42 | Angel N GonzalezPlace 42 · Grade Fr · Monroe University (NY)Unofficial | Fr | Monroe University (NY) | 16:49.67 PR |
| 43 | Justin LuchanPlace 43 · Grade Sr · BaruchUnofficial | Sr | Baruch | 16:56.85 PR |
| 44 | Steven ChangPlace 44 · Grade Jr · BaruchUnofficial | Jr | Baruch | 16:58.18 PR |
| 45 | Jephte N PierrePlace 45 · Grade Fr · Monroe University (NY)Unofficial | Fr | Monroe University (NY) | 17:01.11 PR |
| 46 | Nicholas PerdamoPlace 46 · Grade Sr · SUNY Old WestburyUnofficial | Sr | SUNY Old Westbury | 17:07.36 PR |
| 47 | Charles AllenPlace 47 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 17:10.35 PR |
| 48 | Siwen LiaoPlace 48 · Grade Jr · BaruchUnofficial | Jr | Baruch | 17:12.46 PR |
| 49 | Rudolph LysPlace 49 · Grade Jr · SUNY Old WestburyUnofficial | Jr | SUNY Old Westbury | 17:25.71 PR |
| 50 | Tim RobertsPlace 50 · Grade RS · US Military Academy PrepUnofficial | RS | US Military Academy Prep | 17:26.17 PR |
| 51 | Taquan GrayPlace 51 · Grade So · SUNY Old WestburyUnofficial | So | SUNY Old Westbury | 17:32.11 PR |
| 52 | Matt SmithPlace 52 · Grade RS · US Military Academy PrepUnofficial | RS | US Military Academy Prep | 17:34.56 PR |
| 53 | Dzidzouli N QuistPlace 53 · Grade So · Monroe University (NY)Unofficial | So | Monroe University (NY) | 17:41.21 PR |
| 54 | Oraldo AustinPlace 54 · Grade Jr · VoidUnofficial | Jr | Void | 17:41.99 PR |
| 55 | Gerald N SimkinsPlace 55 · Grade Fr · Monroe University (NY)Unofficial | Fr | Monroe University (NY) | 18:01.74 PR |
| 56 | Mike DziewitPlace 56 · Grade Sr · St. Joseph's (Brooklyn)Unofficial | Sr | St. Joseph's (Brooklyn) | 18:03.23 PR |
| 57 | Mahdi SumterPlace 57 · Grade Jr · VoidUnofficial | Jr | Void | 18:16.35 PR |
| 58 | Stephen MukomaPlace 58 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 18:16.77 PR |
| 59 | Charles WaughPlace 59 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 18:17.05 PR |
| 60 | Garrett EllisPlace 60 · Grade So · VoidUnofficial | So | Void | 18:34.27 PR |
| 61 | Marc RobinsonPlace 61 · Grade Jr · VoidUnofficial | Jr | Void | 18:35.96 PR |
| 62 | Chezlon N GrayPlace 62 · Grade So · Monroe University (NY)Unofficial | So | Monroe University (NY) | 18:39.87 PR |
| 63 | Maciej SadowskiPlace 63 · Grade So · St. Joseph's (Brooklyn)Unofficial | So | St. Joseph's (Brooklyn) | 19:27.85 PR |
| 64 | Josh WootenPlace 64 · Grade So · SUNY Old WestburyUnofficial | So | SUNY Old Westbury | 19:32.99 PR |
| 65 | Ronald OttPlace 65 · Grade Jr · SUNY Old WestburyUnofficial | Jr | SUNY Old Westbury | 20:22.92 PR |
| 66 | Rory FarrellPlace 66 · Grade So · Saint Peter'sUnofficial | So | Saint Peter's | 20:24.31 PR |
| 67 | Jaques CharlesPlace 67 · Grade So · Monroe University (NY)Unofficial | So | Monroe University (NY) | 20:25.15 PR |
| 68 | Daniel ZaretskyPlace 68 · Grade Fr · St. Joseph's (Brooklyn)Unofficial | Fr | St. Joseph's (Brooklyn) | 20:50.24 PR |
| 69 | Ahmed GueyePlace 69 · Grade Fr · VoidUnofficial | Fr | Void | 22:01.98 PR |