| 1 | Sean MillerPlace 1 · Grade Sr · Vassar | Sr | Vassar | 19:15.75 |
| 2 | Wyatt LendonPlace 2 · Grade Fr · NYU | Fr | NYU | 19:16.54 PR |
| 3 | Max FrazeePlace 3 · Grade Sr · Vassar | Sr | Vassar | 19:21.04 PR |
| 4 | Brody RichardsonPlace 4 · Grade Fr · Union (N.Y.) | Fr | Union (N.Y.) | 19:23.13 PR |
| 5 | Sebastian TaylorPlace 5 · Grade Fr · NYU | Fr | NYU | 19:24.35 PR |
| 6 | Luca ManeriPlace 6 · Grade Sr · SUNY New Paltz | Sr | SUNY New Paltz | 19:27.91 PR |
| 7 | Trey DavidsonPlace 7 · Grade Jr · NYU | Jr | NYU | 19:28.38 PR |
| 8 | Amiri WhittlePlace 8 · Grade Jr · NYU | Jr | NYU | 19:29.25 PR |
| 9 | Charles AbemayorPlace 9 · Grade Fr · NYU | Fr | NYU | 19:31.52 PR |
| 10 | Edomias MulugetaPlace 10 · Grade So · NYU | So | NYU | 19:31.75 PR |
| 11 | Drew KoonPlace 11 · Grade Fr · NYU | Fr | NYU | 19:35.32 PR |
| 12 | Anis AbidarPlace 12 · Grade Fr · Vassar | Fr | Vassar | 19:42.65 PR |
| 13 | Jack WilsonPlace 13 · Grade - · Unattached | - | Unattached | 19:45.09 PR |
| 14 | Jay BorlandPlace 14 · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 19:46.43 PR |
| 15 | Jeremy MbogoPlace 15 · Grade - · Unattached | - | Unattached | 19:46.45 PR |
| 16 | Paul TranquillaPlace 16 · Grade So · NYU | So | NYU | 19:52.08 PR |
| 17 | Daniel EscribanoPlace 17 · Grade So · NYU | So | NYU | 19:53.22 PR |
| 18 | Enrique PerezPlace 18 · Grade Jr · NYU | Jr | NYU | 19:53.53 PR |
| 19 | Brian MetzPlace 19 · Grade So · Ramapo | So | Ramapo | 20:02.39 PR |
| 20 | Jordan LevyPlace 20 · Grade So · NYU | So | NYU | 20:05.43 PR |
| 21 | Rafael Mellow-BartelsPlace 21 · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 20:14.08 PR |
| 22 | Riley MagillPlace 22 · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 20:22.97 |
| 23 | Jose EspinalPlace 23 · Grade Sr · Ramapo | Sr | Ramapo | 20:23.39 PR |
| 24 | Galo VazquezPlace 24 · Grade - · Unattached | - | Unattached | 20:34.55 PR |
| 25 | Ben PistinerPlace 25 · Grade Sr · Union (N.Y.) | Sr | Union (N.Y.) | 20:43.84 PR |
| 26 | Cole LewekPlace 26 · Grade So · Union (N.Y.) | So | Union (N.Y.) | 20:48.02 |
| 27 | Brandon MenesesPlace 27 · Grade Sr · Ramapo | Sr | Ramapo | 20:55.01 |
| 28 | Anthony WillisPlace 28 · Grade Sr · SUNY New Paltz | Sr | SUNY New Paltz | 20:57.40 PR |
| 29 | Maslen L'EsperancePlace 29 · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 20:59.32 PR |
| 30 | Wyatt PowersPlace 30 · Grade Fr · Vassar | Fr | Vassar | 20:59.44 PR |
| 31 | Jack BrilliantPlace 31 · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 21:04.23 |
| 32 | Corbin SmithPlace 32 · Grade So · SUNY New Paltz | So | SUNY New Paltz | 21:05.25 PR |
| 33 | Wes LudwigsonPlace 33 · Grade Fr · Vassar | Fr | Vassar | 21:06.33 PR |
| 34 | Alex BonnettePlace 34 · Grade Fr · Union (N.Y.) | Fr | Union (N.Y.) | 21:07.43 PR |
| 35 | Ghanashyama CraigPlace 35 · Grade So · Ramapo | So | Ramapo | 21:11.44 PR |
| 36 | Will BonnettePlace 36 · Grade Sr · Union (N.Y.) | Sr | Union (N.Y.) | 21:14.39 |
| 37 | Lincoln NeiswenderPlace 37 · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 21:14.67 |
| 38 | William BarryPlace 38 · Grade So · Union (N.Y.) | So | Union (N.Y.) | 21:15.66 PR |
| 39 | Elijah FlynnPlace 39 · Grade Sr · Bard | Sr | Bard | 21:23.79 PR |
| 40 | Aiden HesseltinePlace 40 · Grade Sr · SUNY New Paltz | Sr | SUNY New Paltz | 21:24.45 PR |
| 41 | Mike HarbordPlace 41 · Grade So · SUNY New Paltz | So | SUNY New Paltz | 21:26.46 PR |
| 42 | Matthew ReedPlace 42 · Grade So · Ramapo | So | Ramapo | 21:27.35 PR |
| 43 | William CornickPlace 43 · Grade Sr · NYU | Sr | NYU | 21:29.44 PR |
| 44 | Nick AkitaPlace 44 · Grade Fr · Vassar | Fr | Vassar | 21:31.76 PR |
| 45 | Ethan SpritzerPlace 45 · Grade So · Vassar | So | Vassar | 21:36.49 PR |
| 46 | Alexander ColangeloPlace 46 · Grade So · Union (N.Y.) | So | Union (N.Y.) | 21:40.22 PR |
| 47 | Langston ComerPlace 47 · Grade Fr · SUNY New Paltz | Fr | SUNY New Paltz | 21:42.52 PR |
| 48 | Colin ButtittaPlace 48 · Grade Fr · Bard | Fr | Bard | 21:45.61 PR |
| 49 | Chris EskrettPlace 49 · Grade Fr · Bard | Fr | Bard | 21:53.63 PR |
| 50 | Charles GrenadierPlace 50 · Grade Jr · Bard | Jr | Bard | 21:58.81 PR |
| 51 | Brandon LimPlace 51 · Grade So · Baruch | So | Baruch | 22:23.07 PR |
| 52 | Matt VivasPlace 52 · Grade Fr · Union (N.Y.) | Fr | Union (N.Y.) | 22:26.68 PR |
| 53 | Liam DoughertyPlace 53 · Grade Jr · Union (N.Y.) | Jr | Union (N.Y.) | 22:32.73 |
| 54 | Evan MillerPlace 54 · Grade Sr · SUNY New Paltz | Sr | SUNY New Paltz | 22:38.77 |
| 55 | Calvin ThomasPlace 55 · Grade Jr · Bard | Jr | Bard | 22:56.47 PR |
| 56 | Brandon GardnerPlace 56 · Grade Sr · SUNY New Paltz | Sr | SUNY New Paltz | 23:03.62 |
| 57 | Krzysztof Balbuena-MatusiakPlace 57 · Grade Fr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Fr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 23:06.64 PR |
| 58 | Ezekiel DeMercurioPlace 58 · Grade Jr · Vassar | Jr | Vassar | 23:18.80 |
| 59 | Leo CerraiPlace 59 · Grade So · Union (N.Y.) | So | Union (N.Y.) | 23:30.85 PR |
| 60 | Gavin VenoffPlace 60 · Grade Fr · Union (N.Y.) | Fr | Union (N.Y.) | 23:34.55 PR |
| 61 | Michael SerranoPlace 61 · Grade Fr · Union (N.Y.) | Fr | Union (N.Y.) | 23:37.39 PR |
| 62 | Sacha SilviaPlace 62 · Grade So · Union (N.Y.) | So | Union (N.Y.) | 23:39.31 |
| 63 | Elwin LliguisupaPlace 63 · Grade So · Ramapo | So | Ramapo | 23:41.10 |
| 64 | Jacob FreiPlace 64 · Grade Fr · Baruch | Fr | Baruch | 23:46.49 PR |
| 65 | Casey BrownPlace 65 · Grade Fr · SUNY New Paltz | Fr | SUNY New Paltz | 23:56.35 PR |
| 66 | Gregory KeanePlace 66 · Grade So · Union (N.Y.) | So | Union (N.Y.) | 23:58.72 |
| 67 | Thomas LaphamPlace 67 · Grade Sr · Union (N.Y.) | Sr | Union (N.Y.) | 24:02.17 |
| 68 | Robert JacksonPlace 68 · Grade So · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | So | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 24:20.07 PR |
| 69 | Johnny HenriquezPlace 69 · Grade Jr · Bard | Jr | Bard | 24:29.59 PR |
| 70 | Demid ShcheulnikovPlace 70 · Grade So · Baruch | So | Baruch | 24:44.59 |
| 71 | Rehan ZahirPlace 71 · Grade So · Baruch | So | Baruch | 24:49.23 PR |
| 72 | Hameed AzadPlace 72 · Grade Sr · Bard | Sr | Bard | 25:12.74 PR |
| 73 | Eli BashantPlace 73 · Grade Gr · Unattached | Gr | Unattached | 25:29.87 PR |
| 74 | Luca ShapiroPlace 74 · Grade Jr · Baruch | Jr | Baruch | 25:36.46 |
| 75 | Matthew SebastianPlace 75 · Grade Fr · Baruch | Fr | Baruch | 25:55.30 PR |
| 76 | Douglas TrostenPlace 76 · Grade Jr · Baruch | Jr | Baruch | 26:35.81 |
| 77 | Alexis VasconcellosPlace 77 · Grade Fr · Baruch | Fr | Baruch | 27:54.00 PR |
| 78 | Mahi UddinPlace 78 · Grade Jr · Baruch | Jr | Baruch | 28:22.15 |
| 79 | Joseph CarmonaPlace 79 · Grade Sr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Sr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 29:21.40 PR |
| 80 | Kyle ChenPlace 80 · Grade So · Baruch | So | Baruch | 30:33.52 |
| 81 | Tahjeem RossPlace 81 · Grade Fr · Baruch | Fr | Baruch | 30:37.39 PR |
| 82 | Rafael RicaurtePlace 82 · Grade Gr · Unattached | Gr | Unattached | 31:42.83 PR |
| 83 | Abdullah NasirPlace 83 · Grade Fr · Baruch | Fr | Baruch | 44:28.95 PR |
| — | Danny Quito TenezacaGrade Fr · Baruch | Fr | Baruch | DNF PR |
