| 1. | Emmanuel KorirPlace 1. · Grade Fr · UTEP | Fr | UTEP | 1:46.50a PR |
| 2. | Michael SaruniPlace 2. · Grade Fr · UTEP | Fr | UTEP | 1:47.94a |
| 3. | Brennan MunleyPlace 3. · Grade Jr · Michigan | Jr | Michigan | 1:49.53a |
| 4. | Brandon LasaterPlace 4. · A.T.C. | — | A.T.C. | 1:50.39a |
| 5. | Jack WilkesPlace 5. · Grade Jr · LSU | Jr | LSU | 1:50.50a |
| 6. | Ryan SpeerPlace 6. · Grade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | 1:51.27a |
| 7. | Justin PacificoPlace 7. · Grade Fr · Florida | Fr | Florida | 1:51.59a |
| 8. | Erik ArmesPlace 8. · Grade So · Auburn | So | Auburn | 1:52.02a PR |
| 9. | Ben GoodmanPlace 9. · Grade Sr · Missouri | Sr | Missouri | 1:52.17a PR |
| 10. | Trevor GilleyPlace 10. · Grade Sr · Ole Miss | Sr | Ole Miss | 1:53.26a PR |
| 11. | Kyren HollisPlace 11. · Grade So · Florida | So | Florida | 1:53.73a |
| 12. | Mark SheridanPlace 12. · Grade Jr · Missouri | Jr | Missouri | 1:53.79a |
| 13. | Payton BallardPlace 13. · Grade Sr · Alabama | Sr | Alabama | 1:53.94a |
| 14. | Sam AhrenholzPlace 14. · Grade So · Florida | So | Florida | 1:54.09a |
| 15. | Josh ShortPlace 15. · Grade So · Alabama | So | Alabama | 1:54.85a PR |
| 16. | Bennett HillierPlace 16. · Grade Fr · Georgia Tech | Fr | Georgia Tech | 1:54.98a |
| 17. | Taylor StephenPlace 17. · Grade So · Missouri | So | Missouri | 1:55.19a |
| 18. | John LyonsPlace 18. · Grade Fr · Georgia Tech | Fr | Georgia Tech | 1:55.26a |
| 19. | Tyler WoodromePlace 19. · Grade So · Tennessee | So | Tennessee | 1:56.09a |
| 20. | Marcus TinerPlace 20. · Grade So · LSU | So | LSU | 1:56.48a |
| 21. | Cain WinebrennerPlace 21. · Grade Sr · Missouri | Sr | Missouri | 1:56.66a |
| 22. | Daniel LenartPlace 22. · Grade Sr · Lipscomb | Sr | Lipscomb | 1:57.24a |
| 23. | Christian GonzalesPlace 23. · Grade Fr · Belmont | Fr | Belmont | 1:57.53a |
| 24. | Esteban MontanezPlace 24. · Grade Jr · UTEP | Jr | UTEP | 1:59.02a |
| 25. | Austin RayPlace 25. · Grade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | 1:59.18a |
| 26. | Robert KuhlmannPlace 26. · Grade Fr · Missouri | Fr | Missouri | 1:59.38a |
| 27. | Justin LoquercioPlace 27. · Grade Fr · Missouri | Fr | Missouri | 1:59.78a PR |
| 28. | Drew KelleyPlace 28. · Grade So · Tennessee | So | Tennessee | 1:59.90a |
| 29. | Trevon SandersPlace 29. · Grade Fr · Middle Tennessee | Fr | Middle Tennessee | 1:59.96a |
| 30. | Nathan MackPlace 30. · Grade Fr · Middle Tennessee | Fr | Middle Tennessee | 2:01.35a |
| 31. | Michael MurrayPlace 31. · US Paralympics | — | US Paralympics | 2:01.62a |
| 32. | Bryant LoeschPlace 32. · Grade Jr · Lipscomb | Jr | Lipscomb | 2:03.44a |
| 33. | Josh DurhamPlace 33. · Grade Sr · Trevecca Nazarene | Sr | Trevecca Nazarene | 2:10.69a |
| 34. | Donnie FryPlace 34. · Grade Fr · Western Kentucky | Fr | Western Kentucky | 2:15.68a |
| — | Dylan QuisenberryGrade Fr · Missouri | Fr | Missouri | DNS |
| — | Quinn CannellaGrade Fr · Ole Miss | Fr | Ole Miss | DNS |
| — | Shamar TuckerGrade Fr · Ole Miss | Fr | Ole Miss | DNS |
| — | Ryan LeeGrade Fr · Auburn | Fr | Auburn | DNS |
| — | Grant IversonGrade Jr · UT Martin | Jr | UT Martin | DNS |
| — | Sam DeFabrizioGrade Jr · Vanderbilt | Jr | Vanderbilt | DNF |
| — | Jacob VanderwellGrade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | DNS |
| — | Alazar HaileGrade Jr · UT Martin | Jr | UT Martin | DNS |
| — | Jonathan ConleyGrade Jr · UT Martin | Jr | UT Martin | DNS |
| — | Ben WeiselGrade So · Belmont | So | Belmont | DNS |
| — | Matt DsidaGrade Sr · Belmont | Sr | Belmont | DNS |