| 1. | Jonah KoechPlace 1. · Grade So · UTEP | So | UTEP | 4:02.14a |
| 2. | Jack GuytonPlace 2. · Grade Fr · Florida | Fr | Florida | 4:02.37a PR |
| 3. | William SheeranPlace 3. · Grade Sr · Michigan | Sr | Michigan | 4:02.71a |
| 4. | Connor MoraPlace 4. · Grade Jr · Michigan | Jr | Michigan | 4:02.93a |
| 5. | Aaron BaumgartenPlace 5. · Grade Jr · Michigan | Jr | Michigan | 4:03.52a PR |
| 6. | Rob MullettPlace 6. · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:03.92a |
| 7. | Wesley CurlesPlace 7. · Grade Jr · Auburn | Jr | Auburn | 4:04.44a |
| 8. | Ned WilligPlace 8. · Grade Sr · Michigan | Sr | Michigan | 4:05.26a |
| 9. | Trevor GilleyPlace 9. · Grade Sr · Ole Miss | Sr | Ole Miss | 4:06.41a |
| 10. | Zach LongPlace 10. · Grade So · Tennessee | So | Tennessee | 4:06.63a |
| 11. | Andres ArroyoPlace 11. · Grade Sr · Florida | Sr | Florida | 4:07.11a PR |
| 12. | Blair HendersonPlace 12. · Grade Sr · LSU | Sr | LSU | 4:10.34a |
| 13. | Ryan WilkiePlace 13. · Grade So · Michigan | So | Michigan | 4:10.70a |
| 14. | Ben HillPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Michigan | Fr | Michigan | 4:11.72a |
| 15. | Jack BeitterPlace 15. · Grade So · Florida | So | Florida | 4:12.18a |
| 16. | Micah BellerPlace 16. · Grade Jr · Michigan | Jr | Michigan | 4:13.22a |
| 17. | Drew WhitePlace 17. · Grade Sr · Missouri | Sr | Missouri | 4:13.43a PR |
| 18. | Carlos MirandaPlace 18. · Grade Jr · Florida | Jr | Florida | 4:15.03a |
| 19. | Christian BowlesPlace 19. · Grade So · Georgia Tech | So | Georgia Tech | 4:15.13a |
| 20. | Ben WeiselPlace 20. · Grade So · Belmont | So | Belmont | 4:15.95a |
| 21. | Jackson GrzymkowskiPlace 21. · Grade Fr · Belmont | Fr | Belmont | 4:16.44a |
| 22. | Matthew EdwardsPlace 22. · Grade Jr · Belmont | Jr | Belmont | 4:16.92a |
| 23. | Mitchell SandersPlace 23. · Grade So · Georgia Tech | So | Georgia Tech | 4:17.51a |
| 24. | Andres LittigPlace 24. · Grade Jr · Georgia Tech | Jr | Georgia Tech | 4:17.53a PR |
| 25. | Matthew MunnsPlace 25. · Grade Jr · Georgia Tech | Jr | Georgia Tech | 4:17.97a |
| 26. | Alex GradyPlace 26. · Grade Jr · Georgia Tech | Jr | Georgia Tech | 4:18.54a |
| 27. | Nikolaos GkotsisPlace 27. · Grade Sr · Vanderbilt | Sr | Vanderbilt | 4:18.64a PR |
| 28. | Nahom SolomonPlace 28. · Grade So · Georgia Tech | So | Georgia Tech | 4:18.81a |
| 29. | Kaden EatonPlace 29. · Grade Jr · Belmont | Jr | Belmont | 4:19.31a |
| 30. | Anthony DidionPlace 30. · Grade Jr · Belmont | Jr | Belmont | 4:19.39a |
| 31. | Adam JohnstonPlace 31. · Grade Fr · Tennessee | Fr | Tennessee | 4:19.40a |
| 32. | Harrison MartingaylePlace 32. · Grade Fr · LSU | Fr | LSU | 4:20.15a PR |
| 33. | Jack RogersPlace 33. · Grade Fr · Florida | Fr | Florida | 4:21.33a |
| 34. | Andrew AyersPlace 34. · Grade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | 4:21.49a |
| 35. | Christian JohnsonPlace 35. · Grade Jr · LSU | Jr | LSU | 4:22.36a |
| 36. | Jay SpielerPlace 36. · Grade Jr · Auburn | Jr | Auburn | 4:23.01a |
| 37. | Kyle JohnsonPlace 37. · Grade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | 4:23.23a |
| 38. | Chris BurnettPlace 38. · Grade Sr · Georgia Tech | Sr | Georgia Tech | 4:24.69a |
| 39. | Brian HernanPlace 39. · Grade Sr · Missouri | Sr | Missouri | 4:25.14a PR |
| 40. | Leonel PerezPlace 40. · Grade So · UT Martin | So | UT Martin | 4:25.16a |
| 41. | Sam DeFabrizioPlace 41. · Grade Jr · Vanderbilt | Jr | Vanderbilt | 4:25.63a |
| 42. | Psalm OcampoPlace 42. · Grade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | 4:25.71a |
| 43. | Chase HiltonPlace 43. · Grade So · Tennessee | So | Tennessee | 4:25.82a PR |
| 44. | Tanner ShawPlace 44. · Grade Jr · Georgia Tech | Jr | Georgia Tech | 4:26.80a PR |
| 45. | DC LipaniPlace 45. · Grade Jr · LSU | Jr | LSU | 4:28.12a |
| 46. | Brandon WynsmaPlace 46. · Grade Sr · Trevecca Nazarene | Sr | Trevecca Nazarene | 4:29.06a PR |
| 47. | Nathan MorganPlace 47. · Grade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | 4:29.85a PR |
| 48. | Matt DsidaPlace 48. · Grade Sr · Belmont | Sr | Belmont | 4:31.19a PR |
| 49. | David HuezoPlace 49. · Grade Fr · Trevecca Nazarene | Fr | Trevecca Nazarene | 4:35.80a |
| 50. | Sean PinoPlace 50. · Grade So · Lipscomb | So | Lipscomb | 4:36.46a |
| 51. | Quinn CannellaPlace 51. · Grade Fr · Ole Miss | Fr | Ole Miss | 4:38.57a |
| 52. | Collin GunnPlace 52. · Grade Fr · Lipscomb | Fr | Lipscomb | 4:47.14a PR |
| 53. | Austin WoodsPlace 53. · Grade So · Trevecca Nazarene | So | Trevecca Nazarene | 4:49.55a |
| 54. | Corley WebbPlace 54. · Grade Sr · Trevecca Nazarene | Sr | Trevecca Nazarene | 4:57.64a |
| 55. | Micah SmartPlace 55. · Grade Fr · Trevecca Nazarene | Fr | Trevecca Nazarene | 5:10.63a |
| 56. | Collyn BrennerPlace 56. · Grade Fr · Trevecca Nazarene | Fr | Trevecca Nazarene | 5:22.23a |
| — | Kyle SpragueGrade Fr · Western Kentucky | Fr | Western Kentucky | DNS |
| — | William GravesGrade Fr · UT Martin | Fr | UT Martin | DNS |
| — | Andy SmithGrade Fr · Auburn | Fr | Auburn | DNS |
| — | Zach CookGrade So · Missouri | So | Missouri | DNS |
| — | Jonathan ConleyGrade Jr · UT Martin | Jr | UT Martin | DNF |
| — | Geoffry CheruiyotGrade Jr · Middle Tennessee | Jr | Middle Tennessee | DNS |
| — | Mac ReynoldsGrade Sr · Florida | Sr | Florida | DNS |
| — | Wesley PectolGrade So · Auburn | So | Auburn | DNS |
| — | Eliud RuttoGrade Sr · Middle Tennessee | Sr | Middle Tennessee | DNS |