| 1 | Jacob RidderhoffPlace 1 · Grade SR · Washington U. | SR | Washington U. | 4:10.79 |
| 2 | Thomas PenneyPlace 2 · Grade SR · Washington U. | SR | Washington U. | 4:15.51 |
| 3 | Michael LyPlace 3 · Grade SR · Washington U. | SR | Washington U. | 4:19.40 |
| 4 | Matthew HornungPlace 4 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:19.73 |
| 5 | Will HouserPlace 5 · Grade SO · Washington U. | SO | Washington U. | 4:19.76 |
| 6 | Michael GillePlace 6 · Grade JR · Augustana (Ill.) | JR | Augustana (Ill.) | 4:19.89 |
| 7 | Charlie WetzelPlace 7 · Grade FR · Illinois State | FR | Illinois State | 4:20.14 |
| 8 | Jeff CandellPlace 8 · Grade JR · Washington U. | JR | Washington U. | 4:20.52 |
| 9 | Cullen CapuanoPlace 9 · Grade SO · Washington U. | SO | Washington U. | 4:20.81 |
| 10 | Pratyay BishnupuriPlace 10 · Grade SR · Washington U. | SR | Washington U. | 4:20.95 |
| 11 | Alexander EvansPlace 11 · Grade JR · Washington U. | JR | Washington U. | 4:24.97 |
| 12 | Fernando Ribeiro DuraesPlace 12 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:26.69 |
| 13 | Julian HeadPlace 13 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:27.10 |
| 14 | Isaiah MooremanPlace 14 · Grade JR · Western Illinois | JR | Western Illinois | 4:30.32 |
| 15 | Austin BridgmanPlace 15 · Grade SO · Millikin | SO | Millikin | 4:30.50 |
| 16 | Jesse SanchezPlace 16 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:31.53 |
| 17 | Jordan WoodPlace 17 · Grade JR · Illinois State | JR | Illinois State | 4:31.59 |
| 18 | Karsten ZielinskiPlace 18 · Grade SR · Augustana (Ill.) | SR | Augustana (Ill.) | 4:34.96 |
| 19 | Charlie FallonPlace 19 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:37.48 |
| 20 | Max LupoPlace 20 · Grade SO · Western Illinois | SO | Western Illinois | 4:42.14 |
| 21 | Kyle PuckettPlace 21 · Grade SO · Washington U. | SO | Washington U. | 4:43.34 |
| 22 | Liam OwensPlace 22 · Grade SR · Illinois Wesleyan | SR | Illinois Wesleyan | 4:46.81 |
| 23 | Ryan SorensonPlace 23 · Grade SR · Augustana (Ill.) | SR | Augustana (Ill.) | 4:48.10 |
| 24 | Evan TurnbullPlace 24 · Grade SO · Illinois Wesleyan | SO | Illinois Wesleyan | 4:48.84 |
| 25 | Andrew JohnsPlace 25 · Grade FR · Augustana (Ill.) | FR | Augustana (Ill.) | 4:53.33 |
| 26 | Eli NewtonPlace 26 · Grade FR · Monmouth (Ill.) | FR | Monmouth (Ill.) | 4:53.37 |
| 27 | Jack BathjePlace 27 · Grade SO · Augustana (Ill.) | SO | Augustana (Ill.) | 4:57.50 |
| 28 | Dakota MyersPlace 28 · Grade JR · Millikin | JR | Millikin | 5:02.80 |
| 29 | Braden BernasPlace 29 · Grade SO · Monmouth (Ill.) | SO | Monmouth (Ill.) | 5:22.65 |