| 1 | Joe BoyerPlace 1 · Grade SO · Illinois State | SO | Illinois State | 53-5 |
| 2 | Jake BormanPlace 2 · Grade FR · Illinois State | FR | Illinois State | 50-10.75 |
| 3 | Payton TaylorPlace 3 · Grade FR · Illinois State | FR | Illinois State | 49-9.75 |
| 5 | Luke CowanPlace 5 · Grade SO · Augustana (Ill.) | SO | Augustana (Ill.) | 46-3.5 |
| 6 | Cole ParadayPlace 6 · Grade SR · Illinois Wesleyan | SR | Illinois Wesleyan | 46-2 |
| 7 | Andy BirdPlace 7 · Grade SR · Monmouth (Ill.) | SR | Monmouth (Ill.) | 45-5.25 |
| 8 | Nolen BowermanPlace 8 · Grade JR · Washington U. | JR | Washington U. | 43-1.75 |
| 9 | Matt WagnerPlace 9 · Grade FR · Illinois Wesleyan | FR | Illinois Wesleyan | 39-3.25 |
| 10 | Carson EipersPlace 10 · Grade JR · Augustana (Ill.) | JR | Augustana (Ill.) | 39-1.25 |
| 11 | Caleb TobermanPlace 11 · Grade SO · Monmouth (Ill.) | SO | Monmouth (Ill.) | 38-9 |
| 12 | Loucas XenakisPlace 12 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 38-4 |
| 13 | Alex JaramilloPlace 13 · Grade SR · Augustana (Ill.) | SR | Augustana (Ill.) | 37-9.25 |
| 14 | Brandt WilliamsonPlace 14 · Grade FR · Millikin | FR | Millikin | 37-5.75 |
| 15 | Benjamin EskenaziPlace 15 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 35-5.75 |
| 16 | Roy BaggioPlace 16 · Grade SO · Millikin | SO | Millikin | 35-0.25 |
| 18 | Shane AndersonPlace 18 · Grade FR · Monmouth (Ill.) | FR | Monmouth (Ill.) | 34-5.75 |
| 19 | Travis PhulnauthPlace 19 · Grade JR · Washington U. | JR | Washington U. | 31-10 |
| 20 | Jeff SchnetzlerPlace 20 · Grade FR · Monmouth (Ill.) | FR | Monmouth (Ill.) | 31-8.75 |