| 1 | Adam ShawPlace 1 · Milwaukee School of Eng | — | Milwaukee School of Eng | 9:00.33a |
| 2 | Tyler OttPlace 2 · Milwaukee School of Eng | — | Milwaukee School of Eng | 9:08.68a |
| 3 | RJ OlsonPlace 3 · Ripon | — | Ripon | 9:31.69a |
| 4 | Michael KeeganPlace 4 · Milwaukee School of Eng | — | Milwaukee School of Eng | 9:36.10a |
| 5 | Connor MyattPlace 5 · Lawrence | — | Lawrence | 9:40.04a |
| 6 | Noah ReynoldsPlace 6 · Milwaukee School of Eng | — | Milwaukee School of Eng | 9:46.93a |
| 7 | Ben HildebrandPlace 7 · Ripon | — | Ripon | 9:49.21a |
| 8 | Ray WollerPlace 8 · Wisconsin Lutheran | — | Wisconsin Lutheran | 9:55.62a |
| 9 | Matthew SchaberPlace 9 · Milwaukee School of Eng | — | Milwaukee School of Eng | 10:24.48a |
| 10 | Ty TermaatPlace 10 · Carroll (WI) | — | Carroll (WI) | 10:28.00a |
| 11 | Jon LegerPlace 11 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 10:39.45a |
| 12 | William LeonardPlace 12 · Concordia-Chicago | — | Concordia-Chicago | 10:44.40a |