| 1 | Taha OuchenePlace 1 · Iowa Central CC | — | Iowa Central CC | 1:53.25a |
| 2 | Tyson RickerPlace 2 · Augustana (S.D.) | — | Augustana (S.D.) | 1:54.33a |
| 3 | Joe DustinPlace 3 · South Dakota State | — | South Dakota State | 1:54.49a |
| 4 | Alex OttenPlace 4 · Augustana (S.D.) | — | Augustana (S.D.) | 1:54.54a |
| 5 | Cole DobbersteinPlace 5 · South Dakota Mines | — | South Dakota Mines | 1:55.36a |
| 6 | Andrew JohnsonPlace 6 · Borderline Track Club | — | Borderline Track Club | 1:56.27a |
| 7 | Josiah WittenbergPlace 7 · Dordt (Iowa) | — | Dordt (Iowa) | 1:56.50a |
| 8 | Lincoln WoodringPlace 8 · Northern State | — | Northern State | 1:56.55a |
| 9 | Casey ShadePlace 9 · SJ-EP | — | SJ-EP | 1:56.67a |
| 10 | Brennen PetersonPlace 10 · Iowa Central CC | — | Iowa Central CC | 1:57.80a |
| 11 | Jake TurnerPlace 11 · Iowa Western CC | — | Iowa Western CC | 1:57.82a |
| 12 | Sawyer RueckertPlace 12 · South Dakota Mines | — | South Dakota Mines | 1:58.08a |
| 13 | Mohamed MusePlace 13 · South Dakota State | — | South Dakota State | 1:58.37a |
| 14 | Landon HartleyPlace 14 · Iowa Western CC | — | Iowa Western CC | 1:58.46a |
| 15 | Justin QuammenPlace 15 · South Dakota Mines | — | South Dakota Mines | 1:58.81a |
| 16 | Joey HartnettPlace 16 · Iowa Western CC | — | Iowa Western CC | 1:59.07a |
| 17 | Yohannes KassaPlace 17 · South Dakota State | — | South Dakota State | 1:59.50a |
| 18 | Ezra LandmanPlace 18 · Dordt (Iowa) | — | Dordt (Iowa) | 1:59.90a |
| 19 | Austin CarlsonPlace 19 · Crown | — | Crown | 2:00.06a |
| 20 | Alexis OrtizPlace 20 · Iowa Central CC | — | Iowa Central CC | 2:00.12a |
| 21 | Payton Van SicklePlace 21 · Northwestern (Iowa) | — | Northwestern (Iowa) | 2:00.16a |
| 22 | Jacob KuenyPlace 22 · Mount Marty (S.D.) | — | Mount Marty (S.D.) | 2:00.59a |
| 23 | Jessup PedersonPlace 23 · Northern State | — | Northern State | 2:00.76a |
| 24 | Holden JelenPlace 24 · South Dakota State | — | South Dakota State | 2:00.82a |
| 25 | Andrew DeedonPlace 25 · Crown | — | Crown | 2:01.58a |
| 26 | Eli HeacockPlace 26 · Dickinson State (N.D.) | — | Dickinson State (N.D.) | 2:01.71a |
| 27 | Easton Van Den BergPlace 27 · Dordt (Iowa) | — | Dordt (Iowa) | 2:02.77a |
| 28 | Carson ConwayPlace 28 · Mount Marty (S.D.) | — | Mount Marty (S.D.) | 2:04.12a |
| 29 | Abel SquiresPlace 29 · Dordt (Iowa) | — | Dordt (Iowa) | 2:04.94a |
| 30 | Evan PaplowPlace 30 · Iowa Central CC | — | Iowa Central CC | 2:06.46a |
| 31 | Nayati Ringing ShieldPlace 31 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:06.61a |
| 32 | Carmelo AyalaPlace 32 · Chadron State | — | Chadron State | 2:07.73a |
| 33 | Arvid NelsenPlace 33 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:07.92a |
| 34 | Reid GroherPlace 34 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:07.96a |
| 35 | Everett HerrboldtPlace 35 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:10.85a |
| 36 | Seth Vander SluisPlace 36 · Northwestern (Iowa) | — | Northwestern (Iowa) | 2:11.20a |
| 37 | Aemil NelsenPlace 37 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:11.87a |
| 38 | Jamison GouldPlace 38 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:12.07a |
| 39 | Demetry HosethPlace 39 · Briar Cliff (Iowa) | — | Briar Cliff (Iowa) | 2:12.55a |
| 40 | Nathanial MacClurePlace 40 · Briar Cliff (Iowa) | — | Briar Cliff (Iowa) | 2:14.00a |
| 41 | Connor AntoninoPlace 41 · Briar Cliff (Iowa) | — | Briar Cliff (Iowa) | 2:17.29a |
| 42 | Marco SpringmanPlace 42 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:22.41a |
| 43 | Hunter DimickPlace 43 · South Dakota State | — | South Dakota State | 2:32.41a |