| 1 | Juan Carlos BarberenaPlace 1 · Grade JR · Hood | JR | Hood | 52.53a |
| 2 | Elijah McKellPlace 2 · Grade SR · Lebanon Valley | SR | Lebanon Valley | 52.97a |
| 3 | Brody TroyPlace 3 · Grade JR · Delaware Valley | JR | Delaware Valley | 52.98a |
| 4 | Zachary SpoonirePlace 4 · Grade SO · Georgian Court | SO | Georgian Court | 53.14a |
| 5 | Khaliq PolesPlace 5 · Grade FR · Elizabethtown | FR | Elizabethtown | 53.44a |
| 6 | Wesley CastelliPlace 6 · Grade SR · Arcadia | SR | Arcadia | 53.56a |
| 7 | Christopher ReyesPlace 7 · Grade FR · Stevens | FR | Stevens | 53.60a |
| 8 | Dylan ChauhanPlace 8 · Grade SO · Arcadia | SO | Arcadia | 54.11a |
| 9 | Sean DonnamariaPlace 9 · Grade SR · Georgian Court | SR | Georgian Court | 54.36a |
| 10 | Marcos Murillo-BenavidesPlace 10 · Grade JR · Georgian Court | JR | Georgian Court | 54.45a |
| 11 | Owen KreiderPlace 11 · Grade FR · Lebanon Valley | FR | Lebanon Valley | 54.46a |
| 12 | Chase KosibaPlace 12 · Grade SO · Stevens | SO | Stevens | 54.60a |
| 13 | Ryan AndersonPlace 13 · Grade SO · Arcadia | SO | Arcadia | 54.74a |
| 14 | Jamar GaudaPlace 14 · Grade SO · Gwynedd-Mercy | SO | Gwynedd-Mercy | 54.79a |
| 15 | Ryan HaislerPlace 15 · Grade 12 · Unattached | 12 | Unattached | 54.82a |
| 16 | Gabe SczesniakPlace 16 · Grade JR · Elizabethtown | JR | Elizabethtown | 54.89a |
| 17 | Nathaniel PerrelliPlace 17 · Grade JR · FDU Florham | JR | FDU Florham | 55.07a |
| 18 | Connor PerezPlace 18 · Grade SO · Alvernia | SO | Alvernia | 55.51a |
| 19 | James McCoyPlace 19 · Grade JR · Georgian Court | JR | Georgian Court | 55.79a |
| 20 | Tristan-Lee EdwardsPlace 20 · Grade SO · Ursinus | SO | Ursinus | 56.05a |
| 21 | Isaac Parks-GillPlace 21 · Grade SO · Gettysburg | SO | Gettysburg | 56.45a |
| 22 | Micah BullockPlace 22 · Grade SO · Arcadia | SO | Arcadia | 56.78a |
| 23 | Tymir Ash-shaheedPlace 23 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 57.19a |
| 24 | Aaron FoyPlace 24 · Grade SO · Ursinus | SO | Ursinus | 57.32a |
| 25 | Aden FlahertyPlace 25 · Grade FR · McDaniel | FR | McDaniel | 58.20a |
| 26 | Jack BisignanoPlace 26 · Grade SO · Delaware Valley | SO | Delaware Valley | 59.62a |
| 27 | Logan KillePlace 27 · Grade FR · McDaniel | FR | McDaniel | 1:01.75a |
| 28 | Daniel MagallanesPlace 28 · Grade JR · Ursinus | JR | Ursinus | 1:02.04a |
| 29 | Abdullah BrownPlace 29 · Grade SO · Georgian Court | SO | Georgian Court | 1:02.12a |
| 30 | Kingsiah OquendoPlace 30 · Grade FR · Lancaster Bible | FR | Lancaster Bible | 1:02.18a |
| 31 | Jaheim Wimberly-ColePlace 31 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:05.17a |
| 32 | Alexander WilsonPlace 32 · Grade SO · Immaculata | SO | Immaculata | 1:07.18a |
| 33 | Christopher ConroyPlace 33 · Grade FR · FDU Florham | FR | FDU Florham | 1:08.30a |
| 34 | Evan KlinePlace 34 · Grade SR · Lancaster Bible | SR | Lancaster Bible | 1:08.42a |