| 1. | Collin DreesePlace 1. · Grade So · Saint Francis (Pa.) | So | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 1:57.50a |
| 2. | Jakob RagerPlace 2. · Grade Jr · Lock Haven | Jr | Lock Haven | 1:58.32a |
| 3. | Jarrett LeePlace 3. · Grade Sr · Lock Haven | Sr | Lock Haven | 1:58.89a |
| 4. | Joshua LopezPlace 4. · Grade Jr · St. Bonaventure | Jr | St. Bonaventure | 1:59.66a |
| 5. | Nathan SikorskiPlace 5. · Grade So · St. Bonaventure | So | St. Bonaventure | 2:00.81a |
| 6. | Owen HibellPlace 6. · Grade Jr · Lock Haven | Jr | Lock Haven | 2:01.45a PR |
| 7. | Evander LackmanPlace 7. · Grade Jr · Susquehanna | Jr | Susquehanna | 2:01.64a |
| 8. | Michelangelo PiccirilloPlace 8. · Grade So · Saint Francis (Pa.) | So | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 2:01.65a |
| 9. | Daniel LanahanPlace 9. · Grade Jr · Scranton | Jr | Scranton | 2:02.10a |
| 10. | Aidan HurleyPlace 10. · Grade Jr · St. Bonaventure | Jr | St. Bonaventure | 2:02.56a |
| 11. | Michael BinkowskiPlace 11. · Grade Fr · St. Bonaventure | Fr | St. Bonaventure | 2:02.64a |
| 12. | Deric FritzgesPlace 12. · Grade So · Juniata | So | Juniata | 2:02.78a |
| 13. | Carson HulkaPlace 13. · Grade Fr · Alfred State | Fr | Alfred State | 2:03.38a |
| 14. | Ben ImburgiaPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Scranton | Fr | Scranton | 2:03.95a |
| 15. | Kevin RennerPlace 15. · Grade So · St. Bonaventure | So | St. Bonaventure | 2:04.08a PR |
| 16. | Ethan CaprarolaPlace 16. · Grade Fr · Scranton | Fr | Scranton | 2:04.32a |
| 17. | Parker KeiserPlace 17. · Grade Fr · Lock Haven | Fr | Lock Haven | 2:04.35a PR |
| 18. | Matthew RyanPlace 18. · Grade Jr · St. Bonaventure | Jr | St. Bonaventure | 2:05.01a |
| 19. | James ParmeleePlace 19. · Grade Sr · Saint Francis (Pa.) | Sr | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 2:05.54a |
| 20. | Robert CaseyPlace 20. · Grade Sr · Scranton | Sr | Scranton | 2:06.06a |
| 21. | Asa AldermanPlace 21. · Grade Jr · Susquehanna | Jr | Susquehanna | 2:06.19a |
| 22. | Nic MattisonPlace 22. · Grade Fr · Mansfield | Fr | Mansfield | 2:06.23a |
| 23. | Owen TrumpPlace 23. · Grade Fr · Susquehanna | Fr | Susquehanna | 2:07.03a PR |
| 24. | Nicco DianaPlace 24. · Grade Fr · Scranton | Fr | Scranton | 2:07.22a |
| 25. | Noah SheddenPlace 25. · Grade Sr · Mansfield | Sr | Mansfield | 2:07.27a |
| 26. | Landon KesterPlace 26. · Grade So · Bloomsburg | So | Bloomsburg | 2:07.45a |
| 27. | Nathanael WalkerPlace 27. · Grade Sr · Scranton | Sr | Scranton | 2:07.57a |
| 28. | Dominic BasselgiaPlace 28. · Grade Fr · Penn State Harrisburg | Fr | Penn State Harrisburg | 2:07.65a PR |
| 29. | Aiden KonetskyPlace 29. · Grade So · St. Bonaventure | So | St. Bonaventure | 2:08.02a |
| 30. | Kristian MizdailPlace 30. · Grade So · Lock Haven | So | Lock Haven | 2:08.06a PR |
| 31. | Josh MalonePlace 31. · Grade Fr · Susquehanna | Fr | Susquehanna | 2:08.35a PR |
| 32. | Nick CribbetPlace 32. · Grade Jr · St. Bonaventure | Jr | St. Bonaventure | 2:08.40a |
| 33. | Jack ComptonPlace 33. · Grade Jr · Susquehanna | Jr | Susquehanna | 2:09.29a |
| 34. | Clark GaynorPlace 34. · Grade So · Juniata | So | Juniata | 2:09.91a PR |
| 35. | Brady KearnsPlace 35. · Grade Fr · Susquehanna | Fr | Susquehanna | 2:10.66a |
| 36. | Ian AndersonPlace 36. · Grade Jr · Susquehanna | Jr | Susquehanna | 2:10.98a |
| 37. | Ryan YoungPlace 37. · Grade Fr · Saint Francis (Pa.) | Fr | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 2:12.57a |
| 38. | Rocky RomaniPlace 38. · Grade So · Lock Haven | So | Lock Haven | 2:12.82a PR |
| 39. | Blake WengerPlace 39. · Grade So · St. Bonaventure | So | St. Bonaventure | 2:13.52a |
| 40. | Michael LoffredoPlace 40. · Grade Jr · Lock Haven | Jr | Lock Haven | 2:14.55a |
| 41. | Anthony MarchettiPlace 41. · Grade Fr · Lock Haven | Fr | Lock Haven | 2:15.04a PR |
| 42. | Paul RubioPlace 42. · Grade Sr · Susquehanna | Sr | Susquehanna | 2:15.59a PR |
| 43. | Shane SmithPlace 43. · Grade So · Juniata | So | Juniata | 2:16.64a |
| 44. | Matthew MaciejewskiPlace 44. · Grade Fr · St. Bonaventure | Fr | St. Bonaventure | 2:17.16a |
| 45. | Greysen KupskyPlace 45. · Grade So · Mansfield | So | Mansfield | 2:17.85a |
| 46. | James DellPlace 46. · Grade Jr · Susquehanna | Jr | Susquehanna | 2:19.38a PR |
| — | Andrew KaneGrade Sr · Bloomsburg | Sr | Bloomsburg | DNS |
| — | Aiden HoltGrade Sr · St. Bonaventure | Sr | St. Bonaventure | DNS |
| — | Derick BlairGrade Fr · Susquehanna | Fr | Susquehanna | DNF |
| — | Tommy HoverGrade So · Susquehanna | So | Susquehanna | DNF |
| — | Ethan YortyGrade Fr · Penn State Harrisburg | Fr | Penn State Harrisburg | DNS |