| 1 | Aidan BudgePlace 1 · Grade Sr · Central Connecticut State | Sr | Central Connecticut State | 24:26.26 |
| 2 | Brian MasaiPlace 2 · Grade Jr · LIU | Jr | LIU | 24:45.27 |
| 3 | Joshua RoosPlace 3 · Grade Sr · LIU | Sr | LIU | 26:05.23 PR |
| 4 | Michael KraszewskiPlace 4 · Grade Jr · Central Connecticut State | Jr | Central Connecticut State | 26:10.11 |
| 5 | Thomas Flanders ivPlace 5 · Grade So · Central Connecticut State | So | Central Connecticut State | 26:11.82 PR |
| 6 | Connor GarrettPlace 6 · Grade Fr · Central Connecticut State | Fr | Central Connecticut State | 26:14.97 |
| 7 | Andrew HedgesPlace 7 · Grade Sr · Central Connecticut State | Sr | Central Connecticut State | 26:18.40 PR |
| 8 | Joel SolomonPlace 8 · Grade Sr · Wagner | Sr | Wagner | 26:21.11 PR |
| 9 | Ryan DunningPlace 9 · Grade Fr · Central Connecticut State | Fr | Central Connecticut State | 26:22.80 PR |
| 10 | Caleb HarmanPlace 10 · Grade Sr · Wagner | Sr | Wagner | 26:24.12 PR |
| 11 | Emmett LaRosaPlace 11 · Grade Fr · Central Connecticut State | Fr | Central Connecticut State | 26:27.42 |
| 12 | Daniel ReillyPlace 12 · Grade Fr · Central Connecticut State | Fr | Central Connecticut State | 26:47.66 |
| 13 | Matthew KraszewskiPlace 13 · Grade Fr · Central Connecticut State | Fr | Central Connecticut State | 26:53.07 |
| 14 | Ryan ScappaticciPlace 14 · Grade Sr · Central Connecticut State | Sr | Central Connecticut State | 27:01.91 |
| 15 | Ryan BailorPlace 15 · Grade Jr · LIU | Jr | LIU | 27:02.12 |
| 16 | Ronald CiacciaPlace 16 · Grade Fr · Wagner | Fr | Wagner | 27:04.94 PR |
| 17 | Steven IvesPlace 17 · Grade So · Central Connecticut State | So | Central Connecticut State | 27:06.32 |
| 18 | John FontanezPlace 18 · Grade Sr · Central Connecticut State | Sr | Central Connecticut State | 27:12.17 PR |
| 19 | Kidus ZelekePlace 19 · Grade Jr · FDU | Jr | FDU | 27:22.51 |
| 20 | Dylan ManningPlace 20 · Grade So · FDU | So | FDU | 27:22.52 |
| 21 | Trevor EhrlicherPlace 21 · Grade Sr · FDU | Sr | FDU | 27:44.06 |
| 22 | Jalen GoodePlace 22 · Grade So · FDU | So | FDU | 27:58.50 |
| 23 | Nigel BoboliPlace 23 · Grade Sr · Wagner | Sr | Wagner | 28:30.60 PR |
| 24 | Liam SchwabikPlace 24 · Grade Jr · FDU | Jr | FDU | 28:50.24 |
| 25 | Matt CarranoPlace 25 · Grade Fr · Wagner | Fr | Wagner | 28:58.05 PR |
| 26 | Dylan LittlePlace 26 · Grade So · FDU | So | FDU | 29:05.58 |
| 27 | Jack MatthewsPlace 27 · Grade Fr · LIU | Fr | LIU | 29:09.24 |
| 28 | Will SnootsPlace 28 · Grade So · FDU | So | FDU | 29:12.77 |
| 29 | Chase LopezPlace 29 · Grade Jr · FDU | Jr | FDU | 29:20.18 |
| 30 | Jack ShermanPlace 30 · Grade So · Purchase College | So | Purchase College | 29:29.79 PR |
| 31 | Ignacio San JuanPlace 31 · Grade Jr · Wagner | Jr | Wagner | 29:40.71 |
| 32 | Alex CarboPlace 32 · Grade Sr · Purchase College | Sr | Purchase College | 29:54.77 |
| 33 | Thomas TwomeyPlace 33 · Grade Fr · Unattached | Fr | Unattached | 30:10.23 PR |
| 34 | Garrett ViolaPlace 34 · Grade Fr · LIU | Fr | LIU | 30:29.12 |
| 35 | Saikou SanyangPlace 35 · Grade So · BMCC | So | BMCC | 30:59.38 |
| 36 | Kuvar PeterPlace 36 · Grade Fr · LIU | Fr | LIU | 31:58.34 |
| 37 | Volodymyr TsybriyPlace 37 · Grade Fr · Wagner | Fr | Wagner | 32:13.30 PR |
| 38 | Jaden ForthPlace 38 · Grade So · Purchase College | So | Purchase College | 33:02.01 PR |
| 39 | Thomas Black IVPlace 39 · Grade So · BMCC | So | BMCC | 33:48.56 |
| 40 | Christopher MckenziePlace 40 · Grade Fr · BMCC | Fr | BMCC | 33:54.76 PR |
| 41 | Cole StellmanPlace 41 · Grade Jr · LIU | Jr | LIU | 34:13.39 |
| 42 | Ben CostelloPlace 42 · Grade Fr · FDU | Fr | FDU | 34:41.07 PR |
| 43 | Jeremias MendozaPlace 43 · Grade So · Westchester CC (NY) | So | Westchester CC (NY) | 34:44.58 |
| 44 | Jaydhen DuranPlace 44 · Grade Fr · Purchase College | Fr | Purchase College | 35:49.53 PR |
| 45 | Mamadou DialloPlace 45 · Grade Fr · BMCC | Fr | BMCC | 35:57.95 PR |
| 46 | James Franklin JrPlace 46 · Grade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 37:03.05 |
| 47 | Kevin SanguinaPlace 47 · Grade Jr · Purchase College | Jr | Purchase College | 38:29.79 |
| 48 | Jusuf MrkulicPlace 48 · Grade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 41:24.59 PR |
| 49 | Melakhim-Omega BaileyPlace 49 · Grade Fr · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 41:36.05 PR |
| 50 | Mark Gabriel FarandaPlace 50 · Grade So · Westchester CC (NY) | So | Westchester CC (NY) | 42:38.59 |
| 51 | Rowan ReidPlace 51 · Grade So · Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | So | Queensborough (N.Y.) CC | 46:20.78 |
| 52 | David RomeroPlace 52 · Grade So · Westchester CC (NY) | So | Westchester CC (NY) | 49:06.86 |