| 1 | Gordon DoorePlace 1 · Colby | — | Colby | 3:57.63a |
| 2 | Daniel JutrasPlace 2 · Stevens | — | Stevens | 3:58.81a |
| 3 | Kevin McBirneyPlace 3 · Bridgewater State | — | Bridgewater State | 4:00.50a |
| 4 | Ryan BallardPlace 4 · Wentworth (Mass.) | — | Wentworth (Mass.) | 4:00.75a |
| 5 | Henry ReichlePlace 5 · Colby | — | Colby | 4:02.15a |
| 6 | Angel Mendo AlonsoPlace 6 · Franklin Pierce | — | Franklin Pierce | 4:02.30a |
| 7 | Jake AylmerPlace 7 · Stevens | — | Stevens | 4:02.79a |
| 8 | Ronnie MelaoPlace 8 · Stevens | — | Stevens | 4:03.09a |
| 9 | Charles DriscollPlace 9 · Assumption | — | Assumption | 4:03.89a |
| 10 | Jonathan NortonPlace 10 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:05.29a |
| 11 | Thomas SpeltzPlace 11 · Colby | — | Colby | 4:07.15a |
| 12 | Thomas StonePlace 12 · Eastern Connecticut Sta | — | Eastern Connecticut Sta | 4:08.10a |
| 13 | Liam StaffordPlace 13 · Eastern Connecticut Sta | — | Eastern Connecticut Sta | 4:08.74a |
| 14 | Brendan FantPlace 14 · Coast Guard | — | Coast Guard | 4:08.77a |
| 15 | Cameron ThompsonPlace 15 · UMass Dartmouth | — | UMass Dartmouth | 4:08.89a |
| 16 | Sam WalkerPlace 16 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:09.00a |
| 17 | Adam MulaPlace 17 · Springfield (Mass.) | — | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:10.27a |
| 18 | Aydan FournierPlace 18 · Bridgewater State | — | Bridgewater State | 4:10.89a |
| 19 | Jack ChaussePlace 19 · Wentworth (Mass.) | — | Wentworth (Mass.) | 4:10.92a |
| 20 | Evan LyonsPlace 20 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:10.96a |
| 21 | Aiden WatsonPlace 21 · Molloy | — | Molloy | 4:11.11a |
| 22 | Dylan McGuirePlace 22 · Eastern Connecticut Sta | — | Eastern Connecticut Sta | 4:11.63a |
| 23 | Josef SchultzPlace 23 · Gordon (Mass.) | — | Gordon (Mass.) | 4:13.17a |
| 24 | Liam McGoldrickPlace 24 · Colby | — | Colby | 4:13.62a |
| 25 | Ryan ParadinePlace 25 · Stevens | — | Stevens | 4:14.19a |
| 26 | Ethan SylviaPlace 26 · UMass Dartmouth | — | UMass Dartmouth | 4:15.04a |
| 27 | Ethan LinscottPlace 27 · UMaine Farmington | — | UMaine Farmington | 4:15.23a |
| 28 | Bryan OnodyPlace 28 · Stevens | — | Stevens | 4:15.33a |
| 29 | Nicholas DeMarcoPlace 29 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:15.83a |
| 30 | Chase OrciuchPlace 30 · Fairfield | — | Fairfield | 4:16.50a |
| 31 | Sam BenhamPlace 31 · Trinity (Conn.) | — | Trinity (Conn.) | 4:16.58a |
| 32 | Deem QuinnPlace 32 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:17.07a |
| 33 | Anthony BelfordPlace 33 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:17.22a |
| 34 | Anthony MannaPlace 34 · Assumption | — | Assumption | 4:17.64a |
| 35 | Mitchell ParentPlace 35 · Bridgewater State | — | Bridgewater State | 4:18.18a |
| 36 | Matt FloydPlace 36 · Molloy | — | Molloy | 4:18.66a |
| 37 | Parker MainPlace 37 · Hartford | — | Hartford | 4:19.35a |
| 38 | Benjamin DavignonPlace 38 · UMass Dartmouth | — | UMass Dartmouth | 4:20.00a |
| 39 | Nevan KelleyPlace 39 · Fairfield | — | Fairfield | 4:21.15a |
| 40 | Ryan CotugnoPlace 40 · Roger Williams | — | Roger Williams | 4:22.08a |
| 41 | James NicholPlace 41 · Molloy | — | Molloy | 4:22.29a |
| 42 | Colin CzuchraPlace 42 · Roger Williams | — | Roger Williams | 4:22.62a |
| 43 | Colin ShandPlace 43 · Fairfield | — | Fairfield | 4:22.90a |
| 44 | Grant KellenbergerPlace 44 · Coast Guard | — | Coast Guard | 4:23.58a |
| 45 | Thomas LemprierePlace 45 · Coast Guard | — | Coast Guard | 4:23.86a |
| 46 | Jeremiah SingerPlace 46 · Springfield (Mass.) | — | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:24.07a |
| 47 | Mathias NevinPlace 47 · Hartford | — | Hartford | 4:25.40a |
| 48 | Drew TorellPlace 48 · Coast Guard | — | Coast Guard | 4:27.88a |
| 49 | Tyler SafstromPlace 49 · American International | — | American International | 4:27.94a |
| 50 | Mark BigsbyPlace 50 · Stevens | — | Stevens | 4:27.99a |
| 51 | Jacob CarsonPlace 51 · New Haven | — | New Haven | 4:28.68a |
| 52 | Harry YablonPlace 52 · Springfield (Mass.) | — | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:30.37a |
| 53 | Thomas CarneyPlace 53 · Coast Guard | — | Coast Guard | 4:31.02a |
| 54 | Jack PutnamPlace 54 · Fairfield | — | Fairfield | 4:31.51a |
| 55 | Jackson StonePlace 55 · Univ. of New England | — | Univ. of New England | 4:32.18a |
| 56 | Michael CelatkaPlace 56 · New Haven | — | New Haven | 4:34.31a |
| 57 | Drew PaskanikPlace 57 · Post | — | Post | 4:34.89a |
| 58 | Cameron DavisPlace 58 · Fitchburg State | — | Fitchburg State | 4:35.71a |
| 59 | Gabriel AguilarPlace 59 · Farmingdale State | — | Farmingdale State | 4:36.91a |
| 60 | Dylan IdlemanPlace 60 · Trinity (Conn.) | — | Trinity (Conn.) | 4:39.13a |
| 61 | Aaron PelletierPlace 61 · Assumption | — | Assumption | 4:39.55a |
| 62 | Kevin RogersPlace 62 · Trinity (Conn.) | — | Trinity (Conn.) | 4:39.74a |
| 63 | Max SerlingPlace 63 · Springfield (Mass.) | — | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:40.13a |
| 64 | Ozan TurnerPlace 64 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:41.35a |
| 65 | Anthony PiergiovanniPlace 65 · Farmingdale State | — | Farmingdale State | 4:51.59a |
| 66 | Dylan BrilliantPlace 66 · Wentworth (Mass.) | — | Wentworth (Mass.) | 4:56.35a |
| 67 | Daniel CatanoPlace 67 · Farmingdale State | — | Farmingdale State | 5:01.13a |
| 68 | Griffin KaplanPlace 68 · Univ. of New England | — | Univ. of New England | 5:01.68a |
| 69 | Robert McCuePlace 69 · Wentworth (Mass.) | — | Wentworth (Mass.) | 5:03.64a |
| 70 | Luke O'HalloranPlace 70 · Gordon (Mass.) | — | Gordon (Mass.) | 5:05.33a |
| 71 | Jack O'ConnorPlace 71 · Univ. of New England | — | Univ. of New England | 5:07.70a |
| 72 | Samuel NortonPlace 72 · Clark (Mass.) | — | Clark (Mass.) | 5:08.20a |
| 73 | Joshua LeafferPlace 73 · Fitchburg State | — | Fitchburg State | 5:15.68a |
| 74 | Aiden CattelanPlace 74 · Fitchburg State | — | Fitchburg State | 5:17.59a |
| 75 | Sam PowerPlace 75 · Clark (Mass.) | — | Clark (Mass.) | 5:24.39a |
| 1 | Justin DicksonPlace 1 · Roger Williams | — | Roger Williams | 4:35.09a |
| 2 | Christopher KoskinenPlace 2 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:48.85a |
| 3 | Graham JosephsonPlace 3 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 4:49.51a |
| 4 | Langston PearsonPlace 4 · Sacred Heart | — | Sacred Heart | 5:15.32a |
| 5 | Chrisnel NicolasPlace 5 · Medgar Evers | — | Medgar Evers | 5:38.41a |
| 6 | Ryan McCarthyPlace 6 · Sacred Heart | — | Sacred Heart | 5:38.89a |
| 7 | Emanuele ChiappinelliPlace 7 · Trinity (Conn.) | — | Trinity (Conn.) | 5:49.16a |
| 8 | Kelvin Paulino-AcostaPlace 8 · Sacred Heart | — | Sacred Heart | 5:53.56a |
| 9 | Robert KalinowskiPlace 9 · Farmingdale State | — | Farmingdale State | 5:57.70a |
| 10 | Anders LarsonPlace 10 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 5:58.31a |
| 11 | Dontay WashingtonPlace 11 · Medgar Evers | — | Medgar Evers | 6:05.03a |
| 12 | Ian HopkinsPlace 12 · Connecticut College | — | Connecticut College | 6:12.17a |