| 1 | Ryan RheamPlace 1 · Grade Jr · Army West Point | Jr | Army West Point | 24:53.26 |
| 2 | Adam FurmanPlace 2 · Grade Sr · Army West Point | Sr | Army West Point | 24:53.96 |
| 3 | Maximus HayniaPlace 3 · Grade Sr · Army West Point | Sr | Army West Point | 24:54.53 |
| 4 | Issaiah McCorveyPlace 4 · Grade Fr · Army West Point | Fr | Army West Point | 25:00.12 PR |
| 5 | Gavin HansenPlace 5 · Grade Sr · Army West Point | Sr | Army West Point | 25:01.95 |
| 6 | Sean GalvinPlace 6 · Grade Fr · Marist | Fr | Marist | 25:07.38 PR |
| 7 | Tyler GreenePlace 7 · Grade Sr · Siena | Sr | Siena | 25:13.95 |
| 8 | Bradford DuchesnePlace 8 · Grade Jr · Fordham | Jr | Fordham | 25:18.63 |
| 9 | Alex SaldanaPlace 9 · Grade Jr · Quinnipiac | Jr | Quinnipiac | 25:23.62 |
| 10 | Jess Joe AugustinePlace 10 · Grade Jr · Army West Point | Jr | Army West Point | 25:34.33 |
| 11 | Santino D'amelioPlace 11 · Grade Jr · Rider | Jr | Rider | 25:35.62 |
| 12 | James StappenbeckPlace 12 · Grade So · Fordham | So | Fordham | 25:37.99 |
| 13 | Austin FerrinPlace 13 · Grade So · Siena | So | Siena | 25:42.66 PR |
| 14 | Harrison CapraraPlace 14 · Grade So · Fairfield | So | Fairfield | 25:43.65 |
| 15 | Aiden FitzgeraldPlace 15 · Grade Fr · Army West Point | Fr | Army West Point | 25:44.08 PR |
| 16 | Aidan UrquiolaPlace 16 · Grade Fr · Fordham | Fr | Fordham | 25:45.40 |
| 17 | Dominik LisickyPlace 17 · Grade Sr · Rider | Sr | Rider | 25:46.96 |
| 18 | Christian BachmannPlace 18 · Grade Jr · Army West Point | Jr | Army West Point | 25:47.90 |
| 19 | Jack BoergerPlace 19 · Grade Sr · Fordham | Sr | Fordham | 25:49.73 |
| 20 | Matthew GormanPlace 20 · Grade Jr · Army West Point | Jr | Army West Point | 25:52.51 |
| 21 | Michael MasonPlace 21 · Grade Sr · Sacred Heart | Sr | Sacred Heart | 25:53.45 |
| 22 | Aakash ArumugamPlace 22 · Grade Jr · Seton Hall | Jr | Seton Hall | 25:54.25 |
| 23 | Eli AhtenPlace 23 · Grade So · Army West Point | So | Army West Point | 25:55.72 |
| 24 | Judah DaffronPlace 24 · Grade Fr · Army West Point | Fr | Army West Point | 25:55.78 PR |
| 25 | Colin BrunellePlace 25 · Grade Jr · Siena | Jr | Siena | 25:59.58 |
| 26 | Brody CoxPlace 26 · Grade So · Manhattan University | So | Manhattan University | 25:59.62 PR |
| 27 | Jake HaroldPlace 27 · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 26:00.03 |
| 28 | Parker HarrisPlace 28 · Grade Jr · Army West Point | Jr | Army West Point | 26:01.33 |
| 29 | Tyler BlissettPlace 29 · Grade Fr · Army West Point | Fr | Army West Point | 26:01.45 PR |
| 30 | Tyler DemePlace 30 · Grade So · Quinnipiac | So | Quinnipiac | 26:01.67 PR |
| 31 | Alex Hahn-VadsteinPlace 31 · Grade So · Army West Point | So | Army West Point | 26:06.75 PR |
| 32 | Ethan PeffleyPlace 32 · Grade So · Rider | So | Rider | 26:09.28 |
| 33 | Matt McCarronPlace 33 · Grade Sr · Rider | Sr | Rider | 26:10.11 |
| 34 | Jeffrey GrynaviskiPlace 34 · Grade Sr · Seton Hall | Sr | Seton Hall | 26:10.34 |
| 35 | Towler ScottPlace 35 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 26:12.29 PR |
| 36 | Shepard LivingstonPlace 36 · Grade So · Quinnipiac | So | Quinnipiac | 26:13.74 |
| 37 | Max DeckerPlace 37 · Grade So · Siena | So | Siena | 26:13.98 |
| 38 | Joseph ButlerPlace 38 · Grade Sr · Seton Hall | Sr | Seton Hall | 26:16.24 |
| 39 | Jack HorrocksPlace 39 · Grade So · Army West Point | So | Army West Point | 26:16.27 |
| 40 | Chayan Ory HurleyPlace 40 · Grade Fr · Fairfield | Fr | Fairfield | 26:17.44 PR |
| 41 | Bryce RobinsonPlace 41 · Grade Jr · Fairfield | Jr | Fairfield | 26:20.76 PR |
| 42 | Ethan ConradPlace 42 · Grade Sr · Seton Hall | Sr | Seton Hall | 26:23.87 |
| 43 | Kevin BeltranPlace 43 · Grade So · Army West Point | So | Army West Point | 26:26.53 |
| 44 | Behn ThomasPlace 44 · Grade So · Siena | So | Siena | 26:27.59 |
| 45 | Reid FinleyPlace 45 · Grade Fr · Army West Point | Fr | Army West Point | 26:28.98 |
| 46 | Benjamin BrasfieldPlace 46 · Grade Fr · Fairfield | Fr | Fairfield | 26:31.09 PR |
| 47 | Noah JohnsonPlace 47 · Grade So · Siena | So | Siena | 26:32.41 |
| 48 | Eric SchleifPlace 48 · Grade So · Fordham | So | Fordham | 26:32.69 |
| 49 | David RodenhaverPlace 49 · Grade Sr · Rider | Sr | Rider | 26:34.03 |
| 50 | Kyle McCarronPlace 50 · Grade So · Quinnipiac | So | Quinnipiac | 26:34.91 PR |
| 51 | Matthew FerreriPlace 51 · Grade Sr · Marist | Sr | Marist | 26:37.70 |
| 52 | Michael StrainPlace 52 · Grade Sr · Quinnipiac | Sr | Quinnipiac | 26:37.72 |
| 53 | Joshua MingoiaPlace 53 · Grade Jr · Manhattan University | Jr | Manhattan University | 26:39.88 |
| 54 | Daniel DiTunnoPlace 54 · Grade So · Fordham | So | Fordham | 26:40.64 |
| 55 | Matthew HauserPlace 55 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 26:41.18 PR |
| 56 | Anan BaumanPlace 56 · Grade Jr · Fordham | Jr | Fordham | 26:41.73 |
| 57 | Matthew MastrolyPlace 57 · Grade Sr · Rider | Sr | Rider | 26:42.23 |
| 58 | James VissichelliPlace 58 · Grade Fr · Fairfield | Fr | Fairfield | 26:45.71 PR |
| 59 | Tommy PincherliPlace 59 · Grade Fr · Fordham | Fr | Fordham | 26:46.90 PR |
| 60 | Evan WattiePlace 60 · Grade Jr · Siena | Jr | Siena | 26:47.34 |
| 61 | Nico HidalgoPlace 61 · Grade Jr · Rider | Jr | Rider | 26:48.18 |
| 62 | Brayden SeraichykPlace 62 · Grade Fr · Quinnipiac | Fr | Quinnipiac | 26:48.20 PR |
| 63 | Chase ChoudhryPlace 63 · Grade Fr · Army West Point | Fr | Army West Point | 26:48.88 |
| 64 | Preston GumannPlace 64 · Grade So · Quinnipiac | So | Quinnipiac | 26:54.00 |
| 65 | Owen StachilkPlace 65 · Grade So · Albany | So | Albany | 26:58.45 |
| 66 | Owen FletcherPlace 66 · Grade So · Fairfield | So | Fairfield | 26:59.45 PR |
| 67 | Nick DowningPlace 67 · Grade Fr · Siena | Fr | Siena | 27:01.92 |
| 68 | Nicholas CatinaPlace 68 · Grade Fr · Siena | Fr | Siena | 27:02.91 PR |
| 69 | Liam GriffithsPlace 69 · Grade Jr · Seton Hall | Jr | Seton Hall | 27:03.23 |
| 70 | Ryan McAleaPlace 70 · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 27:04.59 |
| 71 | Ben SydellPlace 71 · Grade Jr · Army West Point | Jr | Army West Point | 27:05.15 |
| 72 | Slater Von StettenPlace 72 · Grade Jr · Quinnipiac | Jr | Quinnipiac | 27:06.59 |
| 73 | Jack SmithPlace 73 · Grade Jr · Seton Hall | Jr | Seton Hall | 27:08.85 |
| 74 | Zavier DurrandissePlace 74 · Grade Fr · Albany | Fr | Albany | 27:09.84 |
| 75 | Cole CosgrovePlace 75 · Grade Fr · Albany | Fr | Albany | 27:10.80 |
| 76 | Dylan GuarquilaPlace 76 · Grade Jr · Rider | Jr | Rider | 27:11.74 |
| 77 | Colston WisotzkiPlace 77 · Grade So · Fairfield | So | Fairfield | 27:11.91 |
| 78 | Chase OrciuchPlace 78 · Grade Sr · Fairfield | Sr | Fairfield | 27:16.35 |
| 79 | Brady SweeneyPlace 79 · Grade Jr · Sacred Heart | Jr | Sacred Heart | 27:20.59 |
| 80 | Alberto CastilloPlace 80 · Grade Jr · Rider | Jr | Rider | 27:20.64 PR |
| 81 | Patrick KurtzPlace 81 · Grade Jr · Fordham | Jr | Fordham | 27:24.50 PR |
| 82 | Joshua VoorheesPlace 82 · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 27:24.79 PR |
| 83 | Ean PiaschykPlace 83 · Grade So · Siena | So | Siena | 27:25.10 PR |
| 84 | Pierce FrancisPlace 84 · Grade Sr · Marist | Sr | Marist | 27:25.64 |
| 85 | Billy MathisPlace 85 · Grade Fr · Sacred Heart | Fr | Sacred Heart | 27:27.09 |
| 86 | Michael KeltonPlace 86 · Grade Sr · Seton Hall | Sr | Seton Hall | 27:27.65 |
| 87 | Brendan ParsonsPlace 87 · Grade Fr · Fairfield | Fr | Fairfield | 27:27.77 |
| 88 | Ben BailorPlace 88 · Grade So · Quinnipiac | So | Quinnipiac | 27:30.22 |
| 89 | Will PortmanPlace 89 · Grade So · Rider | So | Rider | 27:31.46 PR |
| 90 | Daniel NortonPlace 90 · Grade So · Fairfield | So | Fairfield | 27:31.83 PR |
| 91 | Colin ShandPlace 91 · Grade Sr · Fairfield | Sr | Fairfield | 27:32.21 |
| 92 | Kevin HowardPlace 92 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 27:35.15 PR |
| 93 | Gavin McGannPlace 93 · Grade Fr · Marist | Fr | Marist | 27:36.53 |
| 94 | Zachary DonethPlace 94 · Grade Sr · Seton Hall | Sr | Seton Hall | 27:37.40 |
| 95 | Matthew SearlesPlace 95 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 27:38.17 PR |
| 96 | Lukas PaunovicPlace 96 · Grade So · Manhattan University | So | Manhattan University | 27:40.66 PR |
| 97 | Alexander ArmendarizPlace 97 · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 27:41.48 |
| 98 | Gabriel MontoyaPlace 98 · Grade Jr · Fairfield | Jr | Fairfield | 27:42.76 |
| 99 | Isaac GraberPlace 99 · Grade Sr · Albany | Sr | Albany | 27:43.81 |
| 100 | Marcus HomaPlace 100 · Grade Sr · Siena | Sr | Siena | 27:45.32 |
| 101 | Alejandro JuroPlace 101 · Grade Fr · Quinnipiac | Fr | Quinnipiac | 27:45.77 |
| 102 | Thomas AerdtsPlace 102 · Grade Jr · Manhattan University | Jr | Manhattan University | 27:57.08 PR |
| 103 | Kaleb StoeckmannPlace 103 · Grade So · Marist | So | Marist | 27:58.25 |
| 104 | Aidan CichockiPlace 104 · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 27:58.71 |
| 105 | Colby MicheelsPlace 105 · Grade Sr · Manhattan University | Sr | Manhattan University | 28:00.41 |
| 106 | John WalshPlace 106 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 28:01.45 PR |
| 107 | William Gilhooly IVPlace 107 · Grade So · Seton Hall | So | Seton Hall | 28:05.26 |
| 108 | Evan RobertsPlace 108 · Grade Fr · Seton Hall | Fr | Seton Hall | 28:06.64 |
| 109 | Frankie DiSilvestroPlace 109 · Grade So · Rider | So | Rider | 28:07.52 |
| 110 | Connor DemePlace 110 · Grade Fr · Quinnipiac | Fr | Quinnipiac | 28:08.61 PR |
| 111 | Caden LazzorPlace 111 · Grade So · Seton Hall | So | Seton Hall | 28:09.84 |
| 112 | Sebastian LopezPlace 112 · Grade So · Saint Peter's | So | Saint Peter's | 28:10.20 |
| 113 | Jake WickershamPlace 113 · Grade Fr · Rider | Fr | Rider | 28:11.95 PR |
| 114 | Thomas RuanePlace 114 · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 28:15.65 |
| 115 | Rowan O'BrienPlace 115 · Grade Jr · Sacred Heart | Jr | Sacred Heart | 28:23.91 |
| 116 | Tadael MihretPlace 116 · Grade Sr · Fordham | Sr | Fordham | 28:25.57 |
| 117 | Josiah WadePlace 117 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 28:36.72 PR |
| 118 | Charlie TessierPlace 118 · Grade Jr · Fairfield | Jr | Fairfield | 28:42.43 |
| 119 | Vincent CostelloPlace 119 · Grade So · Albany | So | Albany | 28:44.48 |
| 120 | Joseph FriedmanPlace 120 · Grade Fr · Seton Hall | Fr | Seton Hall | 28:45.28 |
| 121 | Nolan MussattPlace 121 · Grade Fr · Marist | Fr | Marist | 28:46.73 |
| 122 | Trevor PicconePlace 122 · Grade Fr · Sacred Heart | Fr | Sacred Heart | 28:54.30 PR |
| 123 | Simon RohwerPlace 123 · Grade Jr · Manhattan University | Jr | Manhattan University | 28:56.29 PR |
| 124 | Steven TheodoropoulosPlace 124 · Grade Jr · Sacred Heart | Jr | Sacred Heart | 29:29.26 |
| 125 | Aidan SmithPlace 125 · Grade Sr · Seton Hall | Sr | Seton Hall | 29:40.56 |
| 126 | Johan AparicioPlace 126 · Grade Jr · Saint Peter's | Jr | Saint Peter's | 30:07.61 |
| 127 | Patrick DevinePlace 127 · Grade Jr · Sacred Heart | Jr | Sacred Heart | 30:23.26 |
| 128 | Ethan KarisPlace 128 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 30:28.50 PR |
| 129 | Zachary GuberPlace 129 · Grade Fr · Sacred Heart | Fr | Sacred Heart | 30:30.14 |
| 130 | Michael CherubiniPlace 130 · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 30:42.70 PR |
| 131 | Michael AmakerPlace 131 · Grade Sr · Saint Peter's | Sr | Saint Peter's | 31:06.80 PR |
| 132 | Michael MarescaPlace 132 · Grade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | 31:17.12 |
| 133 | Quaglia GiuseppePlace 133 · Grade Fr · Saint Peter's | Fr | Saint Peter's | 31:28.37 |
| 134 | Kevin AckermanPlace 134 · Grade So · Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | So | Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | 31:40.63 |
| 135 | Benjamin VasquezPlace 135 · Grade So · Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | So | Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | 31:49.34 |
| 136 | Davian SimonPlace 136 · Grade Fr · Saint Peter's | Fr | Saint Peter's | 31:53.54 |
| 137 | Edwin RamirezPlace 137 · Grade Fr · Orange County CC | Fr | Orange County CC | 32:04.40 |
| 138 | Kenneth MontesPlace 138 · Grade Jr · Saint Peter's | Jr | Saint Peter's | 32:47.82 |
| 139 | Michael ThompsonPlace 139 · Grade Fr · Orange County CC | Fr | Orange County CC | 36:22.14 |
| 140 | Landin RodriguezPlace 140 · Grade Fr · Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Suffolk County (N.Y.) CC | 37:46.17 |
| — | Earl HartGrade So · Saint Peter's | So | Saint Peter's | DNF |
| — | Jackson CaywardGrade Sr · Siena | Sr | Siena | DNF |
| — | Joseph VogelGrade So · Fairfield | So | Fairfield | DNF |
| — | Thomas MarescaGrade So · Sacred Heart | So | Sacred Heart | DNF |
| — | Melvin LewisGrade So · Rider | So | Rider | DNF |
| — | Declan TolandGrade Sr · Sacred Heart | Sr | Sacred Heart | DNF |
| — | Kevin CannonGrade Jr · Marist | Jr | Marist | DNF |
| — | Jerry LewisGrade Jr · Albany | Jr | Albany | DNF |
| — | Matthew FeblesGrade Sr · Fordham | Sr | Fordham | DNF |
| — | Sean ReidyGrade Sr · Fordham | Sr | Fordham | DNF |
| — | Finlay LumGrade So · Army West Point | So | Army West Point | DNF |
