| 1 | Dylan CotePlace 1 · Grade Jr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Jr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 18:16.8 PR |
| 2 | Eli WelchPlace 2 · Grade Jr · Williams | Jr | Williams | 18:23.7 PR |
| 3 | Harrison DowPlace 3 · Grade Sr · Amherst | Sr | Amherst | 18:26.0 PR |
| 4 | Carter BengtsonPlace 4 · Grade So · Amherst | So | Amherst | 18:29.8 PR |
| 5 | Malcolm OakesPlace 5 · Grade Jr · Williams | Jr | Williams | 18:31.4 PR |
| 6 | Zach AllenPlace 6 · Grade Sr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Sr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 18:38.6 PR |
| 7 | Noah MahoneyPlace 7 · Grade Sr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Sr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 18:45.1 PR |
| 8 | Brendan QuinnPlace 8 · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 18:47.1 PR |
| 9 | Keiyu MamiyaPlace 9 · Grade Jr · Williams | Jr | Williams | 18:48.2 PR |
| 10 | Jonah SchulmanPlace 10 · Grade Fr · Amherst | Fr | Amherst | 18:51.5 PR |
| 11 | Gavin EngtrakulPlace 11 · Grade So · Williams | So | Williams | 18:51.8 PR |
| 12 | Avery AllenPlace 12 · Grade Sr · Williams | Sr | Williams | 18:52.8 PR |
| 13 | Parker BoylePlace 13 · Grade Sr · Amherst | Sr | Amherst | 18:55.2 PR |
| 14 | Ben KasenPlace 14 · Grade Jr · Amherst | Jr | Amherst | 18:55.4 |
| 15 | Stan CraigPlace 15 · Grade Sr · Amherst | Sr | Amherst | 18:56.9 |
| 16 | Caleb BarnesPlace 16 · Grade So · Amherst | So | Amherst | 18:58.4 PR |
| 17 | Emmett LeachmanPlace 17 · Grade So · Wesleyan (Conn.) | So | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 18:59.4 PR |
| 18 | Thomas HainesPlace 18 · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:02.8 PR |
| 18 | Henry AlexanderPlace 18 · Grade Sr · Williams | Sr | Williams | 19:02.8 PR |
| 20 | Ezekiel CohenPlace 20 · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:03.7 PR |
| 21 | Emil NelsonPlace 21 · Grade Jr · Williams | Jr | Williams | 19:06.3 |
| 22 | Boomer WeismanPlace 22 · Grade So · Wesleyan (Conn.) | So | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:07.9 PR |
| 23 | Easy WeissmanPlace 23 · Grade Jr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Jr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:11.1 PR |
| 24 | Andrew KolenskiPlace 24 · Grade So · Williams | So | Williams | 19:12.3 PR |
| 25 | Nick SaittaPlace 25 · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:13.0 PR |
| 26 | Dan IrishPlace 26 · Grade So · Wesleyan (Conn.) | So | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:13.7 PR |
| 27 | Michael RynnePlace 27 · Grade Fr · Amherst | Fr | Amherst | 19:15.3 PR |
| 28 | Coleman LovePlace 28 · Grade Jr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Jr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:15.6 PR |
| 29 | Ryan MonohanPlace 29 · Grade Fr · Amherst | Fr | Amherst | 19:19.0 PR |
| 30 | Tim ChurchillPlace 30 · Grade So · Amherst | So | Amherst | 19:23.2 PR |
| 31 | Liam O'ConnorPlace 31 · Grade So · Williams | So | Williams | 19:24.0 PR |
| 32 | Sam BenhamPlace 32 · Grade Sr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Sr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:24.2 PR |
| 33 | Alex FriedmanPlace 33 · Grade So · Williams | So | Williams | 19:24.4 PR |
| 34 | Jackson McFerronPlace 34 · Grade Jr · Williams | Jr | Williams | 19:27.6 PR |
| 35 | Calum MadiganPlace 35 · Grade So · Wesleyan (Conn.) | So | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:30.1 PR |
| 36 | Tate CelebiPlace 36 · Grade So · Wesleyan (Conn.) | So | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:30.2 PR |
| 37 | Ethan Striff-CavePlace 37 · Grade Sr · Williams | Sr | Williams | 19:32.7 PR |
| 38 | Duncan DeProfioPlace 38 · Grade Sr · Williams | Sr | Williams | 19:33.7 PR |
| 39 | Alex LaraPlace 39 · Grade Sr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Sr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:39.2 PR |
| 40 | Luis MendozaPlace 40 · Grade So · Williams | So | Williams | 19:46.1 PR |
| 41 | Charlie BosslerPlace 41 · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:47.2 PR |
| 42 | Calder BurkePlace 42 · Grade Sr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Sr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:47.9 |
| 43 | Rex BedwickPlace 43 · Grade Jr · Williams | Jr | Williams | 19:49.0 PR |
| 44 | Jeffrey SunderlinPlace 44 · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 19:49.6 PR |
| 45 | Luke RostanPlace 45 · Grade Sr · Williams | Sr | Williams | 19:50.9 PR |
| 46 | Harrison TalcottPlace 46 · Grade Sr · Amherst | Sr | Amherst | 19:53.8 |
| 47 | Noah BizerPlace 47 · Grade Fr · Amherst | Fr | Amherst | 19:56.4 PR |
| 48 | Malik GbadamassiPlace 48 · Grade Fr · Amherst | Fr | Amherst | 19:59.4 PR |
| 49 | Chris DohertyPlace 49 · Grade Fr · Amherst | Fr | Amherst | 19:59.8 PR |
| 50 | Carter RauchPlace 50 · Grade Jr · Amherst | Jr | Amherst | 20:00.0 PR |
| 51 | Will PetersonPlace 51 · Grade So · Amherst | So | Amherst | 20:41.9 |
| 52 | Ryan LovePlace 52 · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 20:47.7 PR |
| — | Knox WallaskGrade So · Wesleyan (Conn.) | So | Wesleyan (Conn.) | DNS |
| — | Tom EmeryGrade Sr · Williams | Sr | Williams | DNS |
| — | TJ ZwallGrade So · Williams | So | Williams | DNS |
| — | Anderson KrasnerGrade So · Amherst | So | Amherst | DNS |
| — | William ReevesGrade So · Amherst | So | Amherst | DNS |
| — | Jacob ConnollyGrade Sr · Amherst | Sr | Amherst | DNS |