| 1 | Thomas WestphalPlace 1 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:09.14a |
| 2 | Jasper CanePlace 2 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:09.34a |
| 3 | Evan LoughridgePlace 3 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:10.90a |
| 4 | Samuel AllenPlace 4 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:11.80a |
| 5 | Gavin BorgerPlace 5 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:13.06a |
| 6 | Abdullahi AbdullahiPlace 6 · BDAC | — | BDAC | 4:13.26a |
| 7 | Gabriel ConnellyPlace 7 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:15.26a |
| 8 | Pieter HeestersPlace 8 · University of Notre Dame Club | — | University of Notre Dame Club | 4:16.02a |
| 9 | Andre RichmondPlace 9 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:16.11a |
| 10 | Donis HarrisPlace 10 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:16.54a |
| 11 | Kade CampbellPlace 11 · Windsor (Ont.) | — | Windsor (Ont.) | 4:17.49a |
| 12 | Quinton BauerPlace 12 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:17.80a |
| 13 | Tyler GuggemosPlace 13 · Davenport (Mich.) | — | Davenport (Mich.) | 4:18.00a |
| 14 | Nathan RidderingPlace 14 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:18.27a |
| 15 | Nik ShillingPlace 15 · Davenport (Mich.) | — | Davenport (Mich.) | 4:18.53a |
| 16 | John NicePlace 16 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:19.68a |
| 17 | Ben DevitoPlace 17 · BDAC | — | BDAC | 4:19.92a |
| 18 | Aiden MoorePlace 18 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:20.16a |
| 19 | Ethan BarkerPlace 19 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 4:20.47a |
| 20 | Luke MoorePlace 20 · OPTC | — | OPTC | 4:20.79a |
| 21 | Colin KachlicPlace 21 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:20.85a |
| 22 | Andreas PardalisPlace 22 · Windsor (Ont.) | — | Windsor (Ont.) | 4:21.10a |
| 23 | Colin MacGregorPlace 23 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:21.27a |
| 24 | Brock WoodersonPlace 24 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:21.63a |
| 25 | Lucas Van MeterPlace 25 · Davenport (Mich.) | — | Davenport (Mich.) | 4:21.74a |
| 26 | John ListPlace 26 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:21.83a |
| 27 | Jack SchneiderPlace 27 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:22.51a |
| 28 | Malcolm McCormickPlace 28 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:22.63a |
| 29 | Andy AdamsPlace 29 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:23.00a |
| 30 | Jayden PagePlace 30 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:23.37a |
| 31 | Colin HansonPlace 31 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:23.41a |
| 32 | Iain ForrestPlace 32 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:23.63a |
| 33 | Jacob EsserPlace 33 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:23.74a |
| 34 | Noah GriffithPlace 34 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:24.12a |
| 35 | Justin HoffmanPlace 35 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:24.18a |
| 36 | Dylan EsserPlace 36 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:24.51a |
| 37 | Isaiah JacobsPlace 37 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:24.57a |
| 38 | Joe RinkePlace 38 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:24.89a |
| 39 | Sam YarnellePlace 39 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:25.49a |
| 40 | Adair ArtisPlace 40 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:26.21a |
| 41 | Brian LangloisPlace 41 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 4:26.46a |
| 42 | Quinten Marsh-LansardPlace 42 · Windsor (Ont.) | — | Windsor (Ont.) | 4:27.39a |
| 43 | Zak KimmelPlace 43 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:27.89a |
| 44 | Will VanderboerPlace 44 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 4:28.08a |
| 45 | Sebastian RamirezPlace 45 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:28.24a |
| 46 | Joey SeibertPlace 46 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:28.82a |
| 47 | Gavin VansolkemaPlace 47 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:29.27a |
| 48 | Logan ChurchillPlace 48 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:29.47a |
| 49 | Ethan KrampePlace 49 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:30.08a |
| 50 | Tinsae NelsonPlace 50 · Grand Valley State | — | Grand Valley State | 4:31.03a |
| 51 | Jamin ThompsonPlace 51 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:31.05a |
| 52 | David HarrisPlace 52 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:31.10a |
| 53 | Jackson RodriguezPlace 53 · UNAT-Grand Valley St. | — | UNAT-Grand Valley St. | 4:31.55a |
| 54 | Shema ReponsePlace 54 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 4:32.52a |
| 55 | Luke OysterPlace 55 · Davenport (Mich.) | — | Davenport (Mich.) | 4:33.41a |
| 56 | Ryan FryerPlace 56 · University of Notre Dame Club | — | University of Notre Dame Club | 4:33.99a |
| 57 | Alec SteinPlace 57 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:35.06a |
| 58 | Caleb BitelyPlace 58 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:35.17a |
| 59 | Charlie PhelanPlace 59 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:35.80a |
| 60 | Josh OomPlace 60 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:36.01a |
| 61 | Blake FergusonPlace 61 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:36.15a |
| 62 | Owen DonaherPlace 62 · University of Notre Dame Club | — | University of Notre Dame Club | 4:36.46a |
| 63 | Hunter RichardsPlace 63 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:36.94a |
| 64 | Zach TaubmanPlace 64 · Chicago | — | Chicago | 4:37.30a |
| 65 | Myles TilmaPlace 65 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:39.34a |
| 66 | Ayden PottsPlace 66 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:39.40a |
| 67 | Aden PiercePlace 67 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:39.78a |
| 68 | Johnathan MiedemaPlace 68 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:40.56a |
| 69 | Patrick BoydPlace 69 · University of Notre Dame Club | — | University of Notre Dame Club | 4:41.60a |
| 70 | Aaron DouglassPlace 70 · Bethel (Ind.) | — | Bethel (Ind.) | 4:42.86a |
| 71 | Ben ScottPlace 71 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:43.03a |
| 72 | Jack WhitmanPlace 72 · University of Notre Dame Club | — | University of Notre Dame Club | 4:43.08a |
| 73 | Carson FoondlePlace 73 · Muskegon (Mich.) CC | — | Muskegon (Mich.) CC | 4:43.73a |
| 74 | Carlos JisonPlace 74 · University of Notre Dame Club | — | University of Notre Dame Club | 4:44.56a |
| 75 | Hudson KempermanPlace 75 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:44.60a |
| 76 | Matthew (Matt) NowakPlace 76 · Davenport (Mich.) | — | Davenport (Mich.) | 4:44.61a |
| 77 | Isaiah KanablePlace 77 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:44.72a |
| 78 | Jared JokiPlace 78 · Grand Valley State University Clu | — | Grand Valley State University Clu | 4:45.36a |
| 79 | Kaleb SmithPlace 79 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:47.18a |
| 80 | Benjamin KellerPlace 80 · Bethel (Ind.) | — | Bethel (Ind.) | 4:47.70a |
| 81 | Evan KrakerPlace 81 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:51.24a |
| 82 | Aaron BowermanPlace 82 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:51.43a |
| 83 | Gabe RowellPlace 83 · Grand Valley State University Clu | — | Grand Valley State University Clu | 4:51.58a |
| 84 | Andrew GolbaPlace 84 · Bethel (Ind.) | — | Bethel (Ind.) | 4:51.96a |
| 85 | Aiden GoodwinPlace 85 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 4:52.16a |
| 86 | Mick RobinsonPlace 86 · Ferris State | — | Ferris State | 4:52.97a |
| 87 | Jacob BrouwerPlace 87 · Trinity Christian (Ill.) | — | Trinity Christian (Ill.) | 4:53.23a |
| 88 | Brett LeidalPlace 88 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:53.42a |
| 89 | Kyle ThibideauPlace 89 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:54.71a |
| 90 | Bonfils MatengaPlace 90 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 4:55.33a |
| 91 | William RipplePlace 91 · Muskegon (Mich.) CC | — | Muskegon (Mich.) CC | 4:55.55a |
| 92 | Charlie ConklePlace 92 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:57.14a |
| 93 | Demario AngaritaPlace 93 · Trinity Christian (Ill.) | — | Trinity Christian (Ill.) | 4:58.47a |
| 94 | Bryce StatelerPlace 94 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:58.70a |
| 95 | Caleb DeVriesPlace 95 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 5:00.24a |
| 96 | Ian HinklePlace 96 · Grace Christian (Mich.) | — | Grace Christian (Mich.) | 5:00.47a |
| 97 | Alexavier ArcePlace 97 · Bethel (Ind.) | — | Bethel (Ind.) | 5:00.54a |
| 98 | Bryce SalgatPlace 98 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 5:00.71a |
| 99 | Fred MoreauPlace 99 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 5:05.45a |
| 100 | Mitchell SmithPlace 100 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 5:06.95a |
| 101 | Josiah FrazierPlace 101 · Muskegon (Mich.) CC | — | Muskegon (Mich.) CC | 5:07.00a |
| 102 | Alex CariePlace 102 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 5:07.17a |
| 103 | Jacob BumgardnerPlace 103 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 5:07.40a |
| 104 | Jonathan CarbillidoPlace 104 · Muskegon (Mich.) CC | — | Muskegon (Mich.) CC | 5:10.53a |
| 105 | Eoghan BurnsPlace 105 · Aquinas (Mich.) | — | Aquinas (Mich.) | 5:11.81a |
| 106 | Toby BurnsPlace 106 · Bethel (Ind.) | — | Bethel (Ind.) | 5:17.08a |
| 107 | Andrew BlumPlace 107 · Cornerstone (Mich.) | — | Cornerstone (Mich.) | 5:17.41a |
| 108 | Jonathan Ruiz AltamiranoPlace 108 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 5:21.98a |
| 109 | Cale WebbPlace 109 · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | — | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 5:45.61a |
| 110 | Ben BirdPlace 110 · Grace Christian (Mich.) | — | Grace Christian (Mich.) | 5:49.43a |
| 111 | Cristian ContrerasPlace 111 · Trinity Christian (Ill.) | — | Trinity Christian (Ill.) | 5:50.65a |
| — | Ethan Barnes · Unattached | — | Unattached | DNF |