| 1 | Carver MorganPlace 1 · American | — | American | 1:50.94a |
| 2 | Sam LlanezaPlace 2 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:51.99a |
| 3 | Dyimond WalkerPlace 3 · North Carolina A&T | — | North Carolina A&T | 1:52.18a |
| 4 | Jake RimmelPlace 4 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:53.02a |
| 5 | Kaden KluthPlace 5 · American | — | American | 1:53.15a |
| 6 | Jack MuldoonPlace 6 · Davidson | — | Davidson | 1:53.29a |
| 7 | Kazuma BowringPlace 7 · Marshall | — | Marshall | 1:53.43a |
| 8 | Sam BarnardPlace 8 · UNCG | — | UNCG | 1:53.48a |
| 9 | Gavin GaynorPlace 9 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:53.63a |
| 10 | Justin DePintoPlace 10 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:54.34a |
| 11 | Emmanuel PaddyfotePlace 11 · N.C. Central | — | N.C. Central | 1:54.80a |
| 12 | Brodie SchneiderPlace 12 · UNCG | — | UNCG | 1:54.99a |
| 13 | Jack FischerPlace 13 · Davidson | — | Davidson | 1:55.60a |
| 14 | Jr John FlynnPlace 14 · Saint Francis (Pa.) | — | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 1:55.93a |
| 15 | Robert WetherholtPlace 15 · Campbell | — | Campbell | 1:56.00a |
| 16 | Riley WillcoxPlace 16 · Mount Olive | — | Mount Olive | 1:56.08a |
| 17 | Michael MichelottiPlace 17 · University of Virginia Club | — | University of Virginia Club | 1:56.09a |
| 18 | Chris SmithPlace 18 · Longwood | — | Longwood | 1:56.32a |
| 19 | Dawson GroganPlace 19 · North Carolina A&T | — | North Carolina A&T | 1:56.35a |
| 20 | Andrew HamiltonPlace 20 · UNCG | — | UNCG | 1:56.51a |
| 21 | Ryan HarrisPlace 21 · Davidson | — | Davidson | 1:56.57a |
| 22 | Barak GoldsteinPlace 22 · American | — | American | 1:56.88a |
| 23 | Ben JaminetPlace 23 · North Greenville | — | North Greenville | 1:57.05a |
| 24 | Jake SiskPlace 24 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:57.23a |
| 25 | Titus TanuiPlace 25 · Mount Olive | — | Mount Olive | 1:57.28a |
| 26 | Eli RothPlace 26 · Davidson | — | Davidson | 1:57.31a |
| 27 | Elias MorrisPlace 27 · Campbell | — | Campbell | 1:57.61a |
| 28 | Garrett KinderPlace 28 · Concord | — | Concord | 1:57.72a |
| 29 | Ryan WarnerPlace 29 · Lynchburg | — | Lynchburg | 1:58.20a |
| 30 | Elias AmmonPlace 30 · Roanoke | — | Roanoke | 1:58.42a |
| 31 | Collin DreesePlace 31 · Saint Francis (Pa.) | — | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 1:58.78a |
| 32 | Glodi MvoviPlace 32 · UNCG | — | UNCG | 1:59.03a |
| 33 | Andrew BennettPlace 33 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 1:59.08a |
| 34 | Andrew HathawayPlace 34 · Longwood | — | Longwood | 1:59.13a |
| 35 | Aidan KimenerPlace 35 · Mary Washington | — | Mary Washington | 1:59.27a |
| 36 | Luke BlairPlace 36 · Mary Washington | — | Mary Washington | 1:59.31a |
| 37 | Andrew BarrettPlace 37 · Campbell | — | Campbell | 1:59.37a |
| 38 | Evan BradshawPlace 38 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:59.43a |
| 39 | Adam FoleyPlace 39 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 1:59.52a |
| 40 | Lance HatcherPlace 40 · King | — | King | 1:59.56a |
| 41 | Darren HillPlace 41 · Virginia Union | — | Virginia Union | 1:59.83a |
| 42 | Mason WhitePlace 42 · North Greenville | — | North Greenville | 1:59.91a |
| 43 | Lance StanfordPlace 43 · Louisburg (N.C.) | — | Louisburg (N.C.) | 1:59.99a |
| 44 | Seth PerryPlace 44 · Roanoke | — | Roanoke | 2:00.33a |
| 45 | Papakojo DanquahPlace 45 · American | — | American | 2:00.84a |
| 46 | Natheer SuiedPlace 46 · Lander | — | Lander | 2:00.94a |
| 47 | Spencer UtseyPlace 47 · King | — | King | 2:01.11a |
| 48 | Riley KefferPlace 48 · Mount St. Mary's | — | Mount St. Mary's | 2:01.13a |
| 49 | Jackson HerndonPlace 49 · Hampden-Sydney | — | Hampden-Sydney | 2:01.13a |
| 50 | Nicholas JohnstonePlace 50 · University of Virginia Club | — | University of Virginia Club | 2:01.29a |
| 51 | Landon BrumfieldPlace 51 · Marshall | — | Marshall | 2:01.33a |
| 52 | Ian FellowsPlace 52 · Roanoke | — | Roanoke | 2:01.52a |
| 53 | Lane ProchaskaPlace 53 · UNCG | — | UNCG | 2:01.64a |
| 54 | Octavious SmithPlace 54 · N.C. Central | — | N.C. Central | 2:01.82a |
| 55 | James ParmeleePlace 55 · Saint Francis (Pa.) | — | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 2:01.84a |
| 56 | Craig CostaPlace 56 · Campbell | — | Campbell | 2:01.84a |
| 57 | Matt FillibenPlace 57 · Mount St. Mary's | — | Mount St. Mary's | 2:02.18a |
| 58 | Dylan NavarroPlace 58 · Mount St. Mary's | — | Mount St. Mary's | 2:02.25a |
| 59 | Quinn EliasonPlace 59 · Formula Track Club | — | Formula Track Club | 2:02.40a |
| 60 | Artem MeltsaievPlace 60 · Mount Olive | — | Mount Olive | 2:02.53a |
| 61 | Bradley BernardPlace 61 · Lynchburg | — | Lynchburg | 2:03.00a |
| 62 | Ben CarrPlace 62 · King | — | King | 2:03.15a |
| 63 | Elijah McgeePlace 63 · Longwood | — | Longwood | 2:03.51a |
| 64 | Corey LittlePlace 64 · N.C. Central | — | N.C. Central | 2:03.53a |
| 65 | Franklin KipchirchirPlace 65 · Virginia Union | — | Virginia Union | 2:03.66a |
| 66 | Christian ChildsPlace 66 · Marshall | — | Marshall | 2:03.77a |
| 67 | Brandon SmithPlace 67 · Mount St. Mary's | — | Mount St. Mary's | 2:03.84a |
| 68 | Grahm BreiterPlace 68 · Davidson | — | Davidson | 2:04.04a |
| 69 | Michelangelo PiccirilloPlace 69 · Saint Francis (Pa.) | — | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 2:04.05a |
| 70 | Cole JohnsonPlace 70 · King | — | King | 2:04.35a |
| 71 | William SanchezPlace 71 · Campbell | — | Campbell | 2:04.58a |
| 72 | Andrew SebastianPlace 72 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 2:04.82a |
| 73 | Izaac ErwinPlace 73 · Saint Francis (Pa.) | — | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 2:04.90a |
| 74 | Rodger KorirPlace 74 · Virginia Union | — | Virginia Union | 2:05.02a |
| 75 | Ollie FoleyPlace 75 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:05.32a |
| 76 | Ben ParkerPlace 76 · Marshall | — | Marshall | 2:05.36a |
| 77 | Alan WebsterPlace 77 · N.C. Central | — | N.C. Central | 2:05.61a |
| 78 | Abraham EasonPlace 78 · Mount St. Mary's | — | Mount St. Mary's | 2:05.62a |
| 79 | Dominique CoxPlace 79 · North Greenville | — | North Greenville | 2:05.69a |
| 80 | Xavion BogusPlace 80 · Tusculum | — | Tusculum | 2:05.87a |
| 81 | Daniel MurrayPlace 81 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 2:06.22a |
| 82 | Jeremiah GrantPlace 82 · USC Beaufort (S.C.) | — | USC Beaufort (S.C.) | 2:06.27a |
| 83 | Bradley BeaverPlace 83 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:06.51a |
| 84 | Jack MyattPlace 84 · Winthrop | — | Winthrop | 2:06.73a |
| 85 | Christopher HullemanPlace 85 · Mary Washington | — | Mary Washington | 2:06.97a |
| 86 | Joel HermanPlace 86 · North Greenville | — | North Greenville | 2:07.11a |
| 87 | Landon WeaverPlace 87 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 2:07.34a |
| 88 | Tyler StevensPlace 88 · University of Virginia Club | — | University of Virginia Club | 2:08.01a |
| 89 | William DonohuePlace 89 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 2:08.11a |
| 90 | Zachary SillerPlace 90 · University of Virginia Club | — | University of Virginia Club | 2:08.31a |
| 91 | George CrowderPlace 91 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:08.48a |
| 92 | Clinton ClancyPlace 92 · Longwood | — | Longwood | 2:08.88a |
| 93 | Landen LocklearPlace 93 · Tusculum | — | Tusculum | 2:09.85a |
| 94 | Ethan WaitesPlace 94 · Lander | — | Lander | 2:10.06a |
| 95 | Rayan FoleyPlace 95 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 2:10.74a |
| 96 | Morgan LehockyPlace 96 · Mary Washington | — | Mary Washington | 2:10.77a |
| 97 | John FauncePlace 97 · Spire | — | Spire | 2:11.64a |
| 98 | Kevin KiernanPlace 98 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 2:11.96a |
| 99 | Price LineweaverPlace 99 · Formula Track Club | — | Formula Track Club | 2:11.99a |
| 100 | Nick LavellePlace 100 · North Greenville | — | North Greenville | 2:12.39a |
| 101 | Braydon MuhlyPlace 101 · King | — | King | 2:12.42a |
| 102 | Mason SmithPlace 102 · Mars Hill | — | Mars Hill | 2:12.69a |
| 103 | Zack LangPlace 103 · Lander | — | Lander | 2:12.82a |
| 104 | Garrett UthlautPlace 104 · University of Virginia Club | — | University of Virginia Club | 2:12.99a |
| 105 | Bryson BellPlace 105 · Lander | — | Lander | 2:13.41a |
| 106 | Sam ClinePlace 106 · Carson-Newman | — | Carson-Newman | 2:13.52a |
| 107 | Emilio NunezPlace 107 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 2:14.63a |
| 108 | Jonathan LawPlace 108 · Spire | — | Spire | 2:14.78a |
| 109 | Kade MintonPlace 109 · Hampden-Sydney | — | Hampden-Sydney | 2:15.48a |
| 110 | Brett CramPlace 110 · Mars Hill | — | Mars Hill | 2:15.62a |
| 111 | Ryan KurzPlace 111 · USC Beaufort (S.C.) | — | USC Beaufort (S.C.) | 2:16.70a |
| 112 | Alex ChengPlace 112 · Virginia Tech Running Clu | — | Virginia Tech Running Clu | 2:17.07a |
| 113 | Jordan PalmerPlace 113 · Spire | — | Spire | 2:17.88a |
| 114 | Trey MerazPlace 114 · Southern Virginia | — | Southern Virginia | 2:19.51a |
| 115 | Azael QuinteroPlace 115 · Averett | — | Averett | 2:19.61a |
| 116 | Ke'vannio SmithPlace 116 · Averett | — | Averett | 2:22.26a |
| 117 | Noah HarringtonPlace 117 · Spire | — | Spire | 2:23.10a |
| 118 | Tobi AdebuluPlace 118 · Concord | — | Concord | 2:23.65a |
| 119 | Truman MeyerPlace 119 · Southern Virginia | — | Southern Virginia | 2:24.01a |
| 120 | Jefferson DuffeyPlace 120 · Hampden-Sydney | — | Hampden-Sydney | 2:27.01a |
| 121 | Blaine StricklandPlace 121 · Spire | — | Spire | 2:27.77a |
| 122 | Ali AsfourPlace 122 · University of Virginia Club | — | University of Virginia Club | 2:27.94a |
| 123 | Madoc LathroumPlace 123 · Concord | — | Concord | 2:31.83a |
| 124 | Cooper GiffordPlace 124 · Spire | — | Spire | 2:32.01a |
| 125 | Jakaidyn RossPlace 125 · Southern Virginia | — | Southern Virginia | 2:32.48a |
| 126 | Kevin BuschPlace 126 · Hampden-Sydney | — | Hampden-Sydney | 2:37.58a |
| 127 | James CosenzaPlace 127 · Hampden-Sydney | — | Hampden-Sydney | 2:54.57a |